“I tell the comp committee: ‘Pay me the most you can. Then push and pay me even a little bit more. When you reach the height of what you can pay, dig deeper.’ After all, this is how I advocate for our clients. Why wouldn’t I advocate for myself?” says Brad, a lawyer.
Can you be as direct as Brad? If you’re nodding yes, then perhaps I should put you and Brad together to run a workshop on asking for what you’re worth. Everyone else, read on.
Repeatedly, I have clients call me, frustrated about failed salary or promotion discussions, angry (at themselves and their bosses) that they accepted offers that were underwhelming, demeaning, and, at times, disrespectful. Is this familiar? You enter the performance review with your manager feeling confident, hopeful that you will get a decent bump in pay and feeling good about all that you have accomplished this past year. And then . . . you’re told you weren’t as great as you’d thought, or you were awesome but the company is capping salary increases, or “Here’s a great big bonus” (but it’s not really that big or that great). This wasn’t the way it was meant to go. Your chest tightens, you’re unable to open that mental file filled with this year’s wins, and you are starting to feel sick. Get me out of here! You want the tension to stop, so you acquiesce. Success. There’s immediate relief. But not for long. You leave the meeting and demotivating resentment kicks in. If you don’t take further action, your relationship with the manager (and others) deteriorates. Advocating well for yourself restores and deepens workplace connections and enhances self-respect.
True, there are situations when it’s best to simply say, “Thank you,” but more often than not, the necessary conversation doesn’t happen because you wanted out of there. Don’t run. Channel your connecting superhero confidence and stay put. Give voice to your discomfort, express your disappointment, and ask if your superior is willing to work through this awkwardness so that together you might find a more satisfying solution. Naming the tension releases some of the emotional pressure (for both of you). Not a good time to go into the details of why you are being denied what you thought you were worth? Pick a date to continue the conversation before you leave. Acknowledge that this can’t be easy for your boss; underscore your commitment to the job. Remember this discussion ultimately is about what you can do for your boss—and that’s why you are being paid. Ask open-ended questions—who, what, when, and why—to learn more about the company’s priorities in the coming year and help your manager get excited about achieving them with your help. Speak in terms of “we.”
The traits associated with the highest levels of success at work—perseverance, tenacity, and doggedness or “grit”—have been studied extensively by Angela Duckworth. Grit was a more accurate predictor of whether an incoming cadet would complete the first summer of basic training at West Point than academic GPA, Military Performance Score, and West Point’s own Whole Candidate Score. Grit also predicts the success of female attorneys in major law firms. It’s not enough to have talent, says Duckworth. You need to work hard, bounce back, and persevere. Next time don’t get angry. Get gritty. Push through the discomfort.
• In the moment you opt to relieve tension rather than pursue a difficult conversation.
• It’s hard to stay motivated when you feel so undervalued.
• Feeding others is easier than taking care of yourself.
Be clear about your goals. Are you asking for a raise or a bonus? Write down the number before you enter the negotiation.
Ask for what you’re worth. Don’t apologize and devalue yourself.
When your employer preempts your request by “giving” you something you “should” be thankful for, consider it the start of a negotiation, not a done deal. Rather than saying (lying), “That’s so generous of you,” try, “That’s a good place to start, but it won’t close the gap between my market value and current salary.”
Avoid the trap of making it easy for the person with whom you’re negotiating. Stay put and don’t retreat at the first hint of tension. Don’t fill the silence.
Focus on mutual wins. What does the other person or the enterprise need for success, and how can you uniquely contribute? Make the conversation about them, not about you and your disappointment or unpaid rent.
Offer to help your manager argue on your behalf. What information would help your boss influence their manager? Prepare those materials.
Create a visual tool. Chart out what you need immediate help with or support for. Put that in red to indicate urgency. Use amber to alert your audience to potential issues and green to illustrate what you have under control. The green is very important as it is a reminder of what you have contributed and validates why your requests are worthwhile. In your meeting, focus on the red to be sure that your needs are met, but leave the chart behind—in paper form (and follow up with a thank-you note and attach a soft copy that can be used by others advocating on your behalf).
Getting to the right solution is often hard. If your salary is capped, be creative. Look for other forms of compensation, such as press coverage, paid meals, parking, or travel expenses. Perhaps moving your desk and shifting your hours would make work more enjoyable (that’s a real value).
If negotiations didn’t end the way you wanted, ask if they can be revisited in three or six months.
• In their 1969 song, “You Can’t Always Get What You Want,” the Rolling Stones said it well, further suggesting that it might be possible to obtain only what is really essential.
• Our mind can play tricks when requests are met with ease; suddenly, we find ourselves dissatisfied.
18.117.93.0