images

In our era of globalization, the world is getting smaller. It means that people of different identities are in closer contact than ever before, and that is a leadership challenge.

Identity comprises the parts of a person's self that come from belonging to particular groups—some visible, others less apparent. They include age, ethnicity, race, religion, nationality, and socioeconomic status.

WHETHER YOU ARE AWARE OF IT OR NOT, IDENTITY INFORMS HOW YOU LEAD.

Likewise, the identities of those around you affect how they view you as a leader and how they view and work with others. This chapter will help you develop your awareness of identity, the role it plays in your workplace, and how it can be leveraged to create positive outcomes.

So how can we begin to think of our and others' identities? Identity, which is diverse and often nuanced, can be usefully defined using the following three categories:

GIVEN IDENTITY

The attributes or conditions that you have no choice about are your given identity. They may be characteristics you were born with, or they may have been given to you in childhood or later in life. Elements of your given identity include birthplace, age, ethnicity, birth order, physical characteristics and abilities, certain family roles, and possibly religion.

CHOSEN IDENTITY

These are the characteristics that you choose. They may describe your status as well as attributes and skills. Your occupation, hobbies, political affiliation, place of residence, family roles, and religion may all be chosen.

CORE IDENTITY

These are the attributes that you think make you unique as an individual. Some will change over the course of your lifetime; others may remain constant. Elements of your core identity may include traits, behaviors, beliefs, values, and skills.

images

Some attributes may overlap or appear in two categories. Different people might put the same aspect of their identity in different categories depending on how much of a choice it felt like to them. For instance, your religious affiliation could be seen as either a given or a chosen aspect of your identity.

Many attributes are also subjective. One person's interpretation of educated may not match another's definition. Some may assume that you have chosen certain characteristics when, from your vantage point, you had little or no choice. Perhaps you were expected to go into the family business and never really made a choice about your profession.

Finally, context is important. Parts of your identity that matter to you may not matter to others or may matter only in certain situations. Aspects of your identity that seem insignificant to you could become huge benefits or obstacles when you are working in certain situations or with particular groups. In your own country you may leverage local culture to build rapport with others, but when traveling to other countries, you may downplay your culture and leverage your education and career credentials.

With awareness of identity we have clearer, richer interactions with others. It helps us to:

  • UNDERSTAND WHO WE ARE AND WHO OTHERS ARE.
  • CHALLENGE ASSUMPTIONS ABOUT OURSELVES AND OTHERS.
  • ARTICULATE WHAT MATTERS MOST.
  • SEEK COMMON GROUND.
  • USE DIFFERENCES POSITIVELY.
  • CREATE SHARED DIRECTION, ALIGNMENT, AND COMMITMENT.
  • DECREASE THE LIKELIHOOD OF MISUNDERSTANDING.
  • INCREASE YOUR OPENNESS TO DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES.
  • MORE ACCURATELY INTERPRET SITUATIONS THAT CALL ON YOUR ABILITY TO LEAD.

Consider the ten behaviors listed below that typify a leader with a solid grasp of identity; identify the three that you feel you are currently strongest in and the corresponding three that you feel are most in need of development.

STRENGTH NEED
images images   Maintains a clear sense of his or her identity.
images images   Considers how others perceive his or her identity.
images images   Understands how his or her identity contributes to leader effectiveness.
images images   Examines his or her perceptions of others' identity.
images images   Understands the role identity can play in interactions.
images images   Values those with identities that differ from his or hers.
images images   Spots potential identity conflicts quickly.
images images   Directly addresses conflicts that arise from different identities.
images images   Promotes interaction among people with different identities.
images images   Creates an inclusive environment where different identities are accepted.

Take a moment to reflect on how your perceived strengths and corresponding development needs in this area have played out in the past and currently. As you progress through this chapter, keep in mind how you might augment or leverage these approaches.

VOICES OF EXPERIENCE

POPE FRANCIS: THE UNCOMMONLY COMMON MAN

As of 2016, he didn't own a cell phone. Nor did he know how to use a computer. So how did Argentine-born Pope Francis become the most popular leader in the world, transcending ideology, politics, region, socioeconomics, and, not least of all, religion?

Rather than focusing solely on the 1.2 billion members of his own group, the head of the world's largest organization instead turned his attention to engaging those outside his group: people of other faiths and people without organized religion.

The signature of his papacy, small and seemingly unscripted gestures that belie his position, began when he greeted the crowd awaiting his first appearance after being named pope with two simple words: “Buona sera,” good morning. Living in guest quarters at the Vatican, traveling and speaking frequently, Francis has engaged others rather than insulated himself.

The pope's interactions with common people—including the homeless, sick, and disabled—increased his appeal and credibility as a leader who looks past boundaries to see people's commonalities rather than differences.

How might the pope's example of humbleness and inclusivity give you insight into how you can engage others as a leader to remove the barriers sometimes created by differing identities?

images

THE MINDSET for MAPPING YOUR LEADERSHIP IDENTITY

The social identity theory developed by Henri Tajfel and John Turner says we use identity to:

CATEGORIZE people into groups based on a shared belief, experience, or characteristic (for example, women, engineers, Canadians).

IDENTIFY with certain groups ourselves.

COMPARE the groups we belong to with other groups, typically thinking more highly of our own groups.

How we categorize people is a complex, subjective process. For instance, you may believe that religion is one of the most important aspects of a person's identity, so you group people by, and possibly make assumptions about, their religious affiliation. Someone else might not care about or even think about another person's religious affiliation and would therefore give more weight to another social identity—for example, nationality.

The groups you identify with are the ones that you tend to feel most at home with. The behaviors and attributes typical of these groups are what feel normal (read preferable) to you. The coupling between self and identity groups is often powerful, resulting in a bright line being drawn between those who belong with you and those who do not.

We are more likely to assess people in our own groups by their intentions, which suggests positive attributes. On the other hand, we tend to assess people in other groups by how their behavior impacts us, suggesting negative attributes. This comparison process, often not deliberate or even conscious, is a two-way street. That means people belonging to other social identity groups are also making comparisons that may be very different from our own.

To address these potential challenges you must first develop awareness of your own identity.

Worlds Apart or Two of a Kind?

THE STORY OF AKRIT AND LAUREN

Akrit and Lauren hold similar management positions in the same organization located in the United States. Akrit was born in India to a wealthy family and has an advanced degree. Lauren was born in the U.S. to a low-income family. She entered the workforce early and has a lot of work experience but lacks the formal training that Akrit has. Lauren feels that, because Akrit is a man and has a higher education level, he is afforded more opportunities. Akrit feels that, because Lauren is a U.S. native and has been with the organization longer, she has an advantage. Each resents the other for “having it easy.”

Lauren and Akrit are relating to and reacting to each other, in large part, based on their identities. The trouble is, they are only seeing one aspect of each other's overall identities. In other words, they may have more things in common than they realize.

Think about conflicts that you encounter with your colleagues at work. What about them could be attributable to different identities? How might you need to adapt your perceptions of others to better take their identities into account?

“WE SHOULDN'T JUDGE PEOPLE THROUGH THE PRISM OF OUR OWN STEREOTYPES.”.

— QUEEN RANIA OF JORDAN

THE TOOLSET for LEADERSHIP IDENTITY:

Your Identity Map

Creating a map of your identity is a way to capture and articulate how you see yourself. You can look clearly at your obvious, surface-level identity and then begin to dig deeper. This can be very useful in exploring how others perceive you as a leader—who will feel more at home with you, who will give your words more weight, and so on. Your identity map should include the three components discussed earlier:

GIVEN IDENTITY, CHOSEN IDENTITY, AND CORE IDENTITY.

Instructions

1. Draw three concentric circles to represent the different categories of your identity.

2. In the outer ring, write words that describe your given identity: the attributes or conditions that you had no choice about, from birth or later. You may want to include your nationality, age, gender, physical characteristics, certain family roles, and possibly religion. Examples include female, only child, 48, tall, blind, African American, cancer patient, widower..

3. In the next ring, list aspects of your chosen identity. Consider including your occupation, hobbies, political affiliation, where you live, certain family roles, and possibly religion. Examples are cyclist, mother, engineer, expatriate, college graduate, husband, leader, Parisian, Buddhist.

4. In the center circle, write your core attributes—traits, behaviors, beliefs, values, and skills that you think make you unique as an individual. Select things that are relatively enduring about you or that are key to who you are today. For example, you may see yourself as funny, artistic, kind, conservative, attentive, creative, impatient, musical, family-focused, assertive.

AFTER YOU COMPLETE YOUR MAP:

Underline the items that are important to you personally. These are likely to be the terms you would use to describe yourself.
images Put a plus sign beside the items that you believe contribute to your ability to lead effectively in your organization.
images Put a minus sign beside the items that you believe detract from your ability to lead effectively in your organization.
images Put a question mark beside the items that may vary in how they affect your leadership ability, depending on context.

INTERPRETING YOUR MAP

Refer to your map while answering the following questions to examine your identity in more depth.

  • When you look at the underlined items on your map, what trends do you see? Are they mainly part of your given, chosen, or core identity?
  • When you look at the items with pluses, minuses, and question marks, what trends do you see? Are they mainly part of your given, chosen, or core identity?
  • Of the aspects with pluses, minuses, and question marks, which are things you have in common with other people in the organization? Which are things that only you or a very small number of people possess? What are the leadership implications?
  • What aspects of your identity help you make connections with people at work? What aspects of your identity get in the way of making connections with people at work? What gives you the impression that this is the case?
  • Are there aspects of your identity that you keep hidden at work? What impact might that have on you and those around you?
  • How might you reveal or emphasize particular elements of your identity at work in order to build or improve relationships?
  • How might you hide or deemphasize particular elements of your identity at work in order to build or improve relationships?

THE SKILLSET for MAPPING YOUR LEADERSHIP IDENTITY

SEEK ANOTHER PERSPECTIVE

Share your identity map with someone you trust and whose opinion you value. Your partner may or may not see your map the same way you do, but that's the whole point. There is no right or wrong interpretation.

Follow these instructions:

1. Show your partner your completed identity map.

2. Discuss with your partner:

  • aspects of your identity that you believe help you make connections with people at work
  • aspects of your identity that you believe impede making connections at work

3. Then, ask your partner:

  • Are you surprised to see anything on my map?
  • Are there aspects I have left off the map that impact how others perceive me?

“KNOW WHO YOU ARE, WHO YOU WANT TO BE, AND START TALKING AND WORKING WITH WHOM YOU ARE NOT.”

— TARIQ RAMADAN

images

CREATE ROUTINE CONTACT

The simplest and perhaps best known strategy for leveraging identities involves constructing situations so that individual members of different groups come into contact with and get to know one another. Arrange opportunities for personal interaction among supervisors and subordinates and among team members, such as social events, retreats, or team-building activities. This creates more opportunity for one-to-one interactions that are based on individual people rather than the categories they fall into.

MIX IT UP

Either randomly or systematically rotate work group roles in a way that involves people from different identity groups. Again, this softens boundaries between groups, and individuals have more opportunities for interpersonal interaction.

IDENTIFY WITH THE ORGANIZATION

Foster a collective identity by emphasizing that everyone belongs to the same organization and is working toward a common goal. The organization becomes an all-inclusive identity group, and differences between groups are minimized.

images

SHARE THE STATUS

If groups are tightly formed around identity, create situations in which different groups are given equal status. Structure a project or a team so that members of each group have distinct but complementary roles in reaching common goals. This strategy is potentially risky, because differences between groups are made apparent. But if the situation is handled well, individuals learn that they can maintain their group identity and also value another group's unique contributions.

CREATE AN INCLUSIVE ENVIRONMENT

Organizational elements such as policies, practices, and the organizational climate support inclusiveness. Inclusiveness policies and practices that encourage an open dialogue about problems stemming from identity conflict may be helpful. Policies of zero tolerance for fighting, harassment, and discrimination do work. Also, mechanisms for allowing identity issues to emerge in safe and orchestrated ways may be effective. Of course, it is critical to consider the country's culture and laws when determining a suitable remedy for addressing identity conflicts.

TAKE ACTION

Problems started by identity conflicts can become worse when they are ignored. Early actions help to minimize disruptive outcomes. What specific action to take depends very much on the country and cultural situation, but allowing a situation to continue without intervention invites greater trouble.

KEY TAKEAWAYS in MAPPING YOUR LEADERSHIP IDENTITY

  • STAY AWARE OF THE INFLUENCE OF CATEGORIZING, IDENTIFYING, AND COMPARING.
  • CREATE ROUTINE CONTACT BETWEEN DIFFERENT GROUPS.
  • ROTATE WORK GROUP ROLES.
  • FOSTER A COLLECTIVE ORGANIZATIONAL IDENTITY.
  • SHARE STATUS AMONG DIFFERENT GROUPS.
  • CREATE AN INCLUSIVE ENVIRONMENT.
  • TAKE ACTION WHEN IDENTITY CONFLICTS OCCUR.
..................Content has been hidden....................

You can't read the all page of ebook, please click here login for view all page.
Reset
18.191.165.62