4

Getting It Right

The Editing Craft





Key Topics Covered in This Chapter

  • Editing for content
  • Editing for style
  • Tightening and sharpening sentences
  • Editing for accuracy

GETTING THAT first draft down is a major hurdle and in many ways the biggest challenge to business writers. The goal is to make sure that all key ideas and supporting arguments are set forth in a logical manner—and in a reader-friendly format. In some respects drafting is as much about logic as about writing.

The next and final steps involve editing—for content, style, clarity, and accuracy.These steps improve the rough-hewn draft and put an attractive polish on it. They make both the finished product and the writer look good!

Editing for Content

After finishing your first draft, you should edit for content, which involves fine-tuning the structure, logic, and message of your document. The surest approach to content editing is to step back and check to see that your piece has an attention-stopping beginning, a well-crafted middle, and an ending that drives your key point or points home.

Check the Beginning

In the writing business, few things are as important as a strong beginning. A strong beginning captures the interest of readers and moves them toward the main points of the piece. Does your beginning give people a reason to continue reading?

One way to capture reader attention comes right out of Sales 101: Indicate the benefits of reading your piece. Consider this example:

Many in our company have been puzzled and frustrated by high turnover among our customers. In some regions, annual turnover exceeds 73 percent. This report identifies the root causes of customer turnover and proposes a number of practical solutions.

In sales parlance, this type of opening provides the “sizzle” that makes people eager to learn more. But good salesmanship describes features as well as benefits, so consider adding key features to your opening prose:

Many in our company have been puzzled and frustrated by high turnover among our customers. In some regions, annual turnover exceeds 73 percent. This report identifies the root causes of customer turnover and proposes several practical solutions, specifically:

  • Revamping the customer call center
  • A team approach to selling and service
  • A new method for identifying and targeting high-value customers

The reader now has a clear idea of the content of the piece and will be attracted to read it, knowing that it identifies problem causes and offers very specific solutions.

Look For Compelling Logic in the Middle

Having attracted your readers, you must move beyond the sizzle to the steak. Here, check to see that the paragraphs in the middle of your piece unfold in a progressive and compellingly logical way. Each should add value: to convince, to encourage action, or to simply transmit information. Any paragraph or sentence that fails to add value should be either strengthened or eliminated.

After a first pass through the middle of your piece, double-check to make sure that you’ve done all that you promised in the opening. For instance, if you were the author of the preceding example, you could ask yourself two questions: “Have I identified the root causes of customer turnover, and have I described three practical solutions as promised?” If the middle section does not deliver on all that was promised, make the necessary adjustments.

Give It a Tight Wrap-Up

Like the beginning, the ending of a written piece is one of the toughest chores. By the time they’ve said their piece, writers are usually tired of what they’re doing and want to quit. “I don’t have anything more to say about this,” is a typical remark. But a written piece without an ending is incomplete. An ending is needed to close the piece and ease readers out of it. Good endings accomplish one or more things:

Tips for a Good Ending

The following suggestions will help you create a strong ending for any piece of writing:

  • Never introduce new subject matter. When actors return to the stage for a curtain call, they don’t begin a new scene. They bow and make an exit. Likewise, the ending is not a place to introduce new ideas, examples, anecdotes, or other subject matter.
  • Use your own words. Citing and quoting others in the body of a piece is often appropriate and can be very useful in supporting your statements. The ending, however, is reserved for you. Readers expect the final words to be the author’s.
  • Be brief. The ending should represent a very small part of the total word count. To do otherwise, you would have to violate one or both of the two preceding points.
  • Create a sense of closure for the readers
  • Reinforce the main points made in the text without rehashing their details
  • Alert the readers to action steps for the future
  • Urge some type of action on the part of the reader
  • Create a satisfying symmetry that brings the readers back to the themes cited in the beginning

Finish off your piece with a strong ending, and you’re more likely to satisfy your readers and achieve your goal as a writer.

Editing for Style

“He has an engaging style.” “I like her user-friendly style.” “Most people are put off by his writing style.” Much is made of a writer’s style, though almost no one explains what he or she means by it. Fortunately, John Fielden provides a workable definition of style for the business writer: “that choice of words, sentences, and paragraph format which by virtue of being appropriate to the situation and to the power positions of both writer and reader produces the desired reaction and result.”1 As you edit your work, you should try to adopt an appropriate style. But what is an appropriate style? Style, according to Fielden, may be forceful, passive, personal, impersonal, colorful, or colorless.The appropriate choice is determined by the circumstances.

Forceful Style

If you are in a superior position to your readers, or if you seek to compel action, consider using a forceful style. A forceful style makes regular use of the active voice and is very direct. Here are examples of each:

Passive: A letter should be sent to the customer.


Active: Send the customer a letter.


Indirect: Unfortunately, management cannot honor your request for a leave of absence at this time.


Direct: Your request for a leave of absence is denied.

Notice in these examples the bureaucratic, unassertive tone of the passive voice and indirect style.The tone of the active voice and direct style, in contrast, is more authoritative and commanding. Think about the situations in which one style or the other would be the most appropriate.

Passive Style

A passive style never goes for the jugular, and it never gives direct orders. It makes its point through suggestion. This may be perfectly appropriate in certain circumstances. So, instead of writing, “Don’t waste our time at the next meeting; come prepared,” the passive writer would write, “Greater preparation will make the time we spend in meetings more effective.” Fielden recommends this style when a person is faced with a negative situation and is writing as a subordinate to some higher authority.

Personal Style

The personal style is conversational and refers often to the writer and reader by name or through personal pronouns (e.g., I, you, we): “I like your suggestion for providing GPS systems in the delivery trucks, Jack. Let me know what it would cost to try it on a pilot basis.” It also makes heavy use of the active voice. For example, “Please bounce that same idea off Ralph and Harriet. I want to know where they stand on the matter.” A personal style is useful when the goal is to deliver good news, to congratulate, or simply to communicate with a peer, a subordinate, or another person with whom you enjoy a congenial relationship.

Impersonal Style

An impersonal style is appropriate when you’re delivering bad news, writing a technical report, or simply conveying information to a mixed group of readers (subordinates, peers, and higher-ups). The impersonal style avoids the use of individual names and personal pronouns such as me, I, we, and you. The author, in fact, disappears behind the text. Thus, impersonal writing lacks the conversational tone of the personal style.

Instead of saying, “We cannot make a decision based on the information that Bill Jones’s sales group has submitted,” the impersonal stylist would write something quite different: “The information submitted by the Western Sales Group is helpful but insufficient for decision making at the corporate level.” This may sound formal and bureaucratic, but it’s the appropriate style for the circumstances just described.

Colorful Style

Colorful writing is often appropriate when communicating with nonadversarial readers when the goal is to deliver good news, to congratulate, or to motivate. Superlatives and metaphors are often effective.

To Bob, Sue, Alice, and Al—the “Dream Team” of Acme Sales:


Congratulations on your year-to-date sales figures. I am happy to report that your team has already exceeded its annual goal by $234, 000. That puts you “in the money” in terms of the bonus plan and far ahead of all other Acme sales teams. And there are still two months remaining in the fiscal year! I hope that you will use that time to run up the scoreboard still further. Remember that every $1, 000 of sales revenue you generate beyond the current total will earn $100 in bonus money for your team. So go for it!

A colorful and exuberant message like this is fitting for its situation, but would be highly inappropriate in many others, for example:

Dear Cissy:


Your husband, Ralph, is really one of a kind and one heck of a bank employee. And I mean really. What a guy! First he refused to lie facedown on the floor like everyone else in the bank lobby. And then he tried to get the armed robbers to apply for home equity loans! People around here will be talking about it for years to come.

We hope that Ralph’s recovery is swift and that he will return to duty very soon.

Colorless Style

Some situations, like the case of the bank employee, call for distinctly uncolorful writing, in which personal pronouns, adjectives, active voice, and exuberance are limited.

Fielden notes that there is no right style for every occasion and purpose: “In business writing, style cannot be considered apart from the given situation or from the person to whom the writing is directed.”2 Thus, style and situation—and the goal of your writing—should be closely linked. You know, for instance, that the style of a letter written to a friendly colleague must be much different from the style of one written to an irate customer who has threatened to sue you. Consider these examples:

Dear Helen:

It was great seeing you at the national sales meeting last week. Give my best wishes to Freddie and the rest of the east coast regional sales team.

Bill


Dear Mr. Raptor:


We are sorry about the problems you have experienced with our equipment and regret to hear that you feel that litigation is the best remedy. Naturally, we would prefer to work with you in finding the source of the problem and resolving it to your satisfaction. To that end, I have forwarded your letter to our engineering and customer service groups. They will be contacting you this week.


Respectfully,

William D. Turner

Vice President, North American Sales Group

In the end, the style of your communication must be dictated by how you perceive the situation, your relationship with the reader, and the goal you hope to accomplish. Here are some of these various factors:

Situation: adversarial, collaborative, negotiating, sales, social, good news, or bad news


Relationship with reader: arms-length, collegial, customer-oriented, impersonal, subordinate, or superior


Goal: to cajole, conciliate, congratulate, convince, greet, inform, persuade, report, or warn

Tighten and Sharpen Those Sentences

Once you’ve adopted a suitable style for the content of your piece, look closely at the sentences you’ve used and at the words from which they are constructed. Pay particular attention to each of the following: economy of words, word choices, sentence structure, sentence length, and voice.

Economy of Words

Economy of words was cited in chapter 1 as a principle of good writing. Put that principle to work as you edit your letter, e-mail, report, or other form of communication. Look for opportunities in every sentence to eliminate words that add little or no value. Likewise, if a sentence does nothing to support your message or move your argument forward, cut the entire sentence. Saying the same thing in fewer words and fewer sentences will help keep the attention of readers and add impact to your prose.

Here are typical examples of wordy sentences and how they can be tightened:

Wordy: I think that we should raise our prices across the board. (“I think” is understood. If you didn’t think so, why would you say it?)


Improved: We should raise prices across the board.


Wordy: Clearly, it’s time to change the bonus plan. [Or worse]: It’s clear to me that it’s time to change the bonus plan. [Clearly is a weasel word used by writers and lawyers who secretly doubt that the situation is clear.]


Improved: It’s time to change the bonus plan.


Wordy: We plan to give consideration to your proposal the next time that the board meets.


Improved: We will consider your proposal at the next board meeting.


Wordy: What has this department contributed to our goals and objectives?


Improved: What has this department contributed to our goals? [Goals and objectives are repeatedly chained together by businesspeople, even though the words mean the same thing.]

Finally, here’s a sentence that suffers badly from “business BS.” If you read it in a memo, you’d probably gag. How would you cut it down to size?

We plan to devote considerable effort to the study of developing requirements and will seek to develop proposed solutions to the various possible needs we can foresee well in advance of the time that a decision will be needed.

The sentence violates every criterion of good business writing. “We plan to” should be “We’re acting now.” Repeated words, such as develop and developing, or repeated meanings, such as considerable and well, are nothing more than padding. Useless modifiers such as proposed and possible weaken the impact of key nouns. “Will be needed,” a passive construction, begs the questions By whom, and when? It’s impossible to know what the writer hopes to communicate.

Even accomplished business writers find opportunities to reduce verbiage from their drafts. So, apply a sharp pencil to what you’ve written. Doing so will make your piece more readable and make its message stand out.

Use Jargon and Bureaucratic Language with Caution

While you’re trimming away at unnecessary words, take a look at the kinds of words you’re using. Are they straightforward and businesslike, or do they make you sound like a lawyer or government bureaucrat? Are your words part of the readers’ vocabulary, or are they the jargon of a small group? More important, are they appropriate ?

Jargon is not bad and may even be appropriate if the reading audience is familiar with the words and their meaning. Consider this statement:

The consensus 2003 EPS estimate for DataQuack is $0.34. At the current share price, this would push the company’s P/E ratio to around 52, a historic high for the company and a red flag for investors. From a technical viewpoint, however, the ninety-day moving average relative to the S&P 500 trend line is unfavorable.

Though chock-full of jargon, the preceding statement wouldn’t faze an audience of financial analysts and investment managers.They would understand and appreciate the use of these terms. Members of the American Association of Humanities Majors, on the other hand, would probably be mystified.

Consequently, with your audience in mind, aim for simplicity in your word selection. As a rule of thumb, use the simplest words that will communicate your message.

Instead of ... Write . . .
remuneration payment
pending assessment of until
in consequence of as a result
henceforth and hereafter starting today
prioritize rank
optimal best

Sentence Structure

Make sure that each sentence has a simple, logical structure and a clearly defined subject, verb, and object. For example,“Team members [subject] will meet [verb] their QRS Corporation counterparts [object] at 2 P.M.” Some business writing is so muddy that readers cannot identify the subject or what action is being taken or requested.Very often, the best way to avoid this result is to simplify and make the sentences as direct as possible.

Notice in the following sentences how attention to sentence structure and verbiage can make prose shorter, more direct, and clearer.

It is imperative that our current cost overruns be addressed by the responsible parties, namely, the project managers. [18 words]. Project managers should explain the reasons for cost overruns. [9 words].
It’s likely that the odor of paint fumes will be perceivable throughout the building, even though control measures will be in place to minimize them. [25 words]. You may notice paint fumes in the building, but we will do our best to minimize the odor. [18 words.]
Insofar as the submission of time cards is concerned, it is of the essence that all employees be punctual. [19 words]. Please submit your time cards on time. [7 words].

In each of these examples, shorter, more direct sentences make the subject and the requested action stand out.

Sentence Length

Many writing experts say that sentences in business writing should average twelve words. Note the word average.You will be more successful in maintaining reader attention if you mix it up. A short sentence every now and then will make your writing more lively. Like this one. On the other hand, a long sentence that flows smoothly from one line to another will change the rhythm of the piece. If you put short and long sentences together effectively, then you’ll create reader-pleasing variety.

Voice

Voice indicates the relationship between a sentence’s subject and its verb. We addressed active and passive voice earlier in our discussion of appropriate style. Now we will look at how voice relates to sentence structure.

When the subject acts, the sentence has an active voice. When the subject is acted upon, the sentence is in the passive voice:

Active: The editorial director declared the book out of print.


Passive: The book was declared out of print by the editorial director.

A change in voice does not alter the meaning of a sentence, but it does shift its emphasis. In the first example, the emphasis is on the actor—the editorial director. This puts the sentence in the active voice and makes the editorial director the center of interest. In the second example, the book—and not the key actor—is the center of interest; this makes it a passive sentence.

Passive sentences are not always bad or inappropriate. They are useful when the identity of the actor is not your main concern or when you’d like to conceal that identity. For example, you could write, “The book was declared out of print” if you want to play down that it was the editorial director’s decision. The classic case of concealment is “Mistakes were made.” Countless generations of bureaucrats have used this passive expression to hide the fact that they really screwed up.

Passive sentences are generally appropriate in impersonal reports and technical writing. However, they have several drawbacks. First, passive sentences generally require more words—namely, a helping verb and an extra preposition:

Passive: Price changes are disliked by customers. [6 words]


Active: Customers dislike price changes. [4 words]

Second, they make sentences sound formal and ponderous. For example, the preceding active sentence is conversational; the passive version is not. Third, passive sentences conceal the actor. If you write, “Your product will be shipped,” the reader will not know who is handling the shipping. Compare this with “Our Philadelphia office will ship your product.”That information might be important to the readers. Finally, passive sentences lack vigor and assertiveness:

Passive: It was not long before the new assembly routine was mastered by her.


Active: She quickly mastered the new assembly routine.

Most business writing benefits from active and passive sentences. The challenge for writers is to find the right balance between them. That balance is determined by the subject matter, the audience, and the writer’s goal.

Editing for Accuracy

Once you have done all the preceding steps, you are ready for the final step—editing for accuracy. At this stage, you’ll be looking for typos and grammatical errors, misstatements of fact, and vague or ambiguous passages. Before doing this, however, it’s often smart to put your written document aside for a while and attend to something else. This break will help you see your writing with fresh eyes when you return to it. Even better, enlist a reliable third party to troubleshoot the piece for you. Even the best of writers benefit from objective editors.

Spelling and Grammatical Errors

Spelling and grammatical errors lead the list of the little nits that plague business writing. Both detract from the power of the message and the authority of the author. Spelling errors are generally the result of careless typing and are easily remedied through diligent proofreading. Grammatical errors have many origins and are more difficult to identify and fix.


SPELLING Check carefully for spelling errors.Yes, your word processor has a spell checker. But don’t rely on it to find all your mistakes; it’s not that smart. Your spell checker will, for example, judge each of these incorrectly worded sentences to be correct:

Get it right the first thyme.


Get it write the first time.


Got it right the first times.

Considering these shortcomings of the spell checker, you should check every sentence carefully. When in doubt about a particular word spelling or usage, look it up in the dictionary.


AGREEMENT Since a treatise on grammar is beyond the scope of this book, here we treat only one of the more common sources of grammatical errors: agreement. A frequent source of grammatical errors, agreement refers to the correspondence between the elements of a sentence that indicate number, person, gender, or tense. For example, if a sentence has a plural subject, its verb and related words must also be plural:

Although two auditors [plural] were sent to handle the job, they [plural] failed to complete their [plural] task on schedule.

Notice that auditors, they, and their are all plural words. They are in agreement. Now consider a tricker example:

The problem with all these suggestions is their lack of consideration of funding.

Some people would have written:

The problem with all these suggestions are the lack of consideration of funding.

What’s wrong here? Are is a plural verb and agrees with suggestions , a plural noun. Unfortunately, suggestions is not the subject. Problem is the subject—a singular word—and the verb number should agree with it.

Agreement in tense assures that action words (verbs) correspond in terms of past, present, and future. Tenses must agree both within sentences and between them. A frequent mistake of business writers is shifting incorrectly between tenses:

Wrong: Maria will meet with the audit team next week to discuss our treatment of equipment depreciation. Together, they determine the right method and report it to management. [Look at the verbs to see what’s wrong. Here, will meet is in the future tense, yet determine is in present tense.]


Right: Maria will meet with the audit team next week to discuss our treatment of equipment depreciation. Together they will determine the right method and [will] report it to management.

Misstatements of Fact

Few business writers aim to deceive their readers, but many do so when they fail to check for factual errors or misstatements. Credibility suffers when these gaffs are discovered.

Tip for Catching Those Last Errors

Before you send out your written work, consider having another party check it over. A second pair of eyes will bring a fresh perspective that you, as the author, lack. For example, a sentence whose meaning is clear to you may be ambiguous to someone else. Also, if you’ve always spelled the name of Michigan’s state capital L-a-n-d-s-i-n-k, you won’t catch your error in proofing the final copy. Someone else will very likely spot this error.

Numerical errors are the easiest to make. It’s very easy to write 5 percent when you mean to write 0.5 percent or 50 percent. It’s even easier to misstate a number or percentage when it’s in a long table of large numbers. Because the writer is usually copying these numbers from a primary source, keyboard slips are easy to make.

So take the extra time to check all your figures. If you’re trying to build a case with your document, even a small error caught by readers will weaken it. They will naturally wonder, “If this part is wrong, what about the rest?”

Summing Up

This chapter has explained four steps you should take to turn a written draft into a polished piece that you can send to others with confidence:

  • Editing for content: This activity requires that you examine the structure, logic, and message of your draft. Make whatever changes you must to give the draft an attention-stopping beginning, a middle section that logically lays out your message, and an ending that either drives your key point home or urges your reader to action.
  • Editing for style: A writing style can be forceful, passive, personal, impersonal, colorful, or colorless. Examples of each were given. The style that is right for any particular piece of business writing should be determined by the situation, your relationship with the reader, and the goal you hope to accomplish.
  • Tightening and sharpening sentences: There’s probably no written draft that cannot be improved through these editing activities. Remember that every word and every sentence should add value for the reader. Those that don’t should be eliminated. Here are a few summary points to remember: Don’t use words that your readers may not understand; give your sentences a logical structure—and don’t allow them to be too long. Sentences written in the active voice are usually stronger (and almost always shorter) than passive sentences.
  • Editing for accuracy: A written document is a reflection on its author. For this reason, as you make a final editorial pass, double-check for typos, ambiguous statements, misspellings, and errors of fact. Look too for grammatical gaffs, particularly errors in agreement, number, person, gender, and tense. As an extra precaution, have someone else put his or her eyes on your edited work. This person may very well see something you’ve missed.
..................Content has been hidden....................

You can't read the all page of ebook, please click here login for view all page.
Reset
3.137.161.193