Chapter 6
IN THIS CHAPTER
Grouping customers together through market segmentation
Understanding who buys, what they buy, and why they buy
Creating market segments that make sense
Shaping your business around the key customers you serve
As you put together your business plan, it may seem good to view each of your customers — the Alexes, Aniyahs, and D’Andres who regularly walk through your doors — as individuals with unique personalities and distinct likes and dislikes. You may also be tempted to make things simple and lump everyone together and view all your customers in exactly the same way — after all, the whole world should want your products and services, right?
Unfortunately, neither of these tactics is very helpful when it comes to creating a business plan you can use. In an ideal world, you could address each customer individually. Walmart sees more than 200 million customers a week. Southwest Airlines averages more than 350,000 passengers per day. Starbucks’s baristas serve well over a million worldwide caffeine addicts per hour. But is this one-by-one approach possible in today’s marketplace? Not that long ago, the answer was clear as crystal: You couldn’t personalize your marketing efforts with the customer, certainly not on a mass scale.
But we’re not in Kansas anymore, Toto. The digital revolution has affected a firm’s ability to reach out and touch customers through methods unheard of just a few years back. It’s turned the field of marketing almost upside down, and you, too, might be able to benefit from the revolution. Let’s talk.
In this chapter, we show you how to create practical market strategies that you can use in your business plan. We explore various ways to identify market segments based on who is buying, what they buy, when they buy, and why and how they buy. Finally, we talk about things you can do to make sure that your business plans and practices reflect who your customers are and why they come to you in the first place.
When you take a moment to think about who your customers really are, one of the first things you notice is that many of them have a great deal in common. That simple fact gives you a golden opportunity to divide customers into specific groups based on their similarities. Bingo! By planning your business around these customer groups, you can serve each group’s particular needs almost as effectively as if they were individuals. This saves money — lots of it.
What makes a good customer? The best customers that any business can hope for have these traits in common:
Good customers are more than satisfied; they’re delighted. You provide them with exactly what they need and want. For their part, they keep you on your toes by making sure that you understand their changing needs and requirements.
To begin, we acknowledge that each individual customer is unique: You, dear reader, are you, and so far we’re not cloning humans. But while you’re an individual, you also share some characteristics with others, maybe lots of others. Are you right-handed? Welcome to that intimate little club of 90-plus percent of the world’s population. By identifying those commonalities, we can group customers together into baskets that make it a lot easier and less expensive to serve them.
When you make sense of your marketplace by grouping customers together, you create market segments. To be of any real use in your business planning, however, market segments should describe groups of customers that you can readily identify and that respond to your products and services in similar ways — ways that appear distinct from those of other customer groups. An accurately defined market segment allows you to satisfy the particular needs and wants of an entire group of customers as if they are one — a more cost-efficient approach.
You may remember a time when “sneakers” were simple, rubber-soled canvas shoes that kids played in and maybe used for school sports. But that was back then. Today the market for athletic footwear generates nearly $30 billion in yearly revenue. The difference is phenomenal. Now everyone seems to wear them — kids still wear the shoes, of course, but so do toddlers, tweens, teens, serious runners, amateur wannabes, senior citizens, and just about all other categories of consumers — each demanding choices in various shapes and colors, with different features and options, and in a wide range of prices. Just ask Nike and Michael Jordan. Today the athleisure segment (not a typo) has niches for walking, running, skateboarding, the fashion runway, whatever and wherever. You can even find ones with little lights in the heels that flash when you walk. Cool.
Literally dozens of athletic-shoe segments exist now, each defined in unique ways. For Nike, Adidas, or Puma to attempt to run the table today with one universal shoe would be sheer folly and a financial disaster. The athletic-shoe business and the market segments that shape it have changed beyond recognition during the past 30 years.
Despite what the marketing gurus may tell you, you rarely, if ever, can find a “right” way to carve up your market straight off the bat. You need to view your customers from various angles and describe them based on several factors. The more you can apply your imagination and creativity in this area, the more successful you’re likely to be in coming up with unique and effective market segments. People who subscribe to my service have a computer. Maria and Marvin have computers. Track them down, team — they’re prospects! Ah, no. One dimension isn’t enough.
The first two are easier to answer; the third can be quite tricky indeed.
The place to begin teasing out your market segments is by researching who buys your product or service. If you focus on individual consumers — the B2C market (business-to-consumer) — discover a bit about how they live their lives. If your customers are other companies (the B2B “industrial” market of business-to-business), find out about their business operations. Think about your B2C customers in these terms:
Perhaps the simplest way to describe your customers is based on where they are, beginning with a simple geographic breakdown by these factors:
But geography can also lead to more specialized groups. For example, you may find it useful to describe customers based on factors such as
Dividing customers into groups based on geography is a good way to separate them according to local or regional taste — which often is a significant factor in the distribution and delivery of a product or service. Ethnic foods, for example, tend to sell better in certain regions of the United States. Hispanic foods are hottest in the Southwest; kosher products are most popular on the East Coast; and Asian food is everywhere on the West Coast. Per-capita wine consumption is far higher in San Francisco than it is in Milwaukee. And beer? Well, it made Milwaukee famous.
Speaking of the Midwest, instead of trying to sell heavy coats and sweaters throughout the country, you’d be better off concentrating marketing efforts in regions that have cold winters, taking advantage of customer preferences based on weather patterns. By looking at the geographic characteristics of consumers as they relate to your product or service, you begin to create market segments that you can use. But keep in mind that personal identities are shifting quickly these days; don’t get trapped into thinking yesterday’s truths are the same as tomorrow’s. You might want to read (or re-read) the end of Chapter 5 or jump ahead to all of Chapter 13 before you sketch out that new pattern. (Hey, future coat-makers out there, global warming is happening. Maybe they’ll want bikinis in Buffalo next.)
A profile of your customers includes all the attributes that you may expect to find in a national census. Marketing gurus call these attributes demographic data, which includes the following:
Company profiles, of course, are somewhat different. These profiles can include basic characteristics such as the following:
Lifestyle is an awfully tired word these days. People use it to describe anything and everything that you do in the modern world. If you’re reading this book, you likely fall into the entrepreneurship lifestyle. When applied to your customers, lifestyle has a particular meaning; it captures characteristics that go deeper than what’s available in plain old census data. Customer lifestyle factors include
All this information is sometimes called psychographic data, because you can use it to map out the underlying psychology of the customer, which drives much of buying.
When applied to business firms rather than consumers, lifestyle identifiers might be their desire to be seen as “green,” or socially responsive, or supportive of diversity and inclusion in employee hiring and promotion policies. And let’s not stop there. Some firms want to be associated more with a Wild West, freedom-tinged image: smoking’s allowed, concealed carry tolerated. Hey, it’s America.
You can use these characteristics to understand how you may better serve a particular segment of your business market.
A description of your customers in terms of their geography, profiles, lifestyles, and personalities tells you a lot about them. To begin to understand how customers make choices in the marketplace you compete in, you need to consider not only who they are but also what they buy.
A description of customers based on what they buy enables you to view them from a perspective that you’re very familiar with: your own products and services. After you come up with market segments based on what your customers purchase, you can address the needs of each group by making changes in the following aspects of your product or service:
Features refer to all the specifications and characteristics of a product or service — things that you often find listed in a product brochure, a user manual, or the company website. When you group customers based on the product features they look for, the customers themselves turn out to have a great deal in common. Their similarities include
Spirit Airlines is a player in the so-called no-frills segment of the airline business. The company caters to people who travel relatively short distances and who often have to pay for travel out of their own pockets — and are very conscience of price (the so-called leisure segment of the market). You can find rock-bottom ticket prices to fly Spirit, but don’t expect a seat assignment in advance, free checked luggage, early boarding privileges, or anything edible up there in the sky. You get what you pay for — not much, hopefully an on-time flight from here to there (even though that’s dicey). But then Spirit’s customers don’t see the point of paying extra for things they don’t want. That’s who they are, and the airline’s management knows it.
Spirit Airlines customers tend to be different from those of United Airlines, a global, full-service carrier at the opposite end of the airline spectrum. United offers service to most major airports around the globe. The company targets business customers, frequent flyers, and global travelers who expect a decent hot meal on a ten-hour flight, sufficient bubbly to ease the ride, superior in-flight service from experienced cabin attendants, help with their international connections, and their luggage to arrive when they do, no matter where they are in the world. And they (or their company’s travel department) are willing to pay for it.
When the Madison Avenue types talk about packaging, they refer to much more than cardboard, shrink wrap, and plastic. Packaging means everything that surrounds a product offering, including the following:
The market segments that you identify based on packaging criteria often reflect customer attributes similar to the ones based on product features (see the previous section): frequency of use, level of sophistication, product application, and the type of user.
The pricing of a particular kind of product or service creates different groups of customers. Price-sensitive customers make up one camp (remember the Spirit Airlines customer earlier in this chapter?); financially free customers who are willing to pay for a certain level of quality are in the other. If you’ve ever had to endure a course in microeconomics (yuck), you won’t ever be able to forget two facts: Price is a major market variable, and the price/quality trade-off is a fundamental force in every marketplace. People who buy Timex watches at their local drugstore tend to be price-sensitive, whereas shoppers acquiring a Rolex timepiece at a classy downtown jewelry emporium want luxury, craftsmanship, elegance, maybe even a flute of champagne from the elegantly attired sales associate while they browse, and the chance to make a personal statement.
Distribution and delivery determine how customers actually receive your product or service. In this case, market segments are often based on where your customers shop. Here are some examples:
Distribution is undergoing transformation these days, as the convenience of the Internet pulls more and more shoppers to this option (keep reading to find out why and how this happened). While the total volume of all online sales is in the low-to-mid double digits, the rate of growth has been spectacular compared to brick-and-mortar stores. Every week, it seems, a new category of products shows up online, and consumers — especially Millennials and Gen Zers — are choosing “buy now” on their laptops or phones more than ever. Heard of Carvana? Robinhood? Noémie? Check ’em out.
Moreover, unforeseen events like the COVID-19 pandemic gave a massive booster shot to indirect modes of shopping. You may want to peek at Chapter 13 to see how stress-testing your business plan for random events can make it more resilient in the face of unknowns.
When it comes down to satisfying customers’ needs over the long haul, you can’t forget the basics. Perhaps the most difficult — and useful — questions that you can ask yourself about customers have to do with why they buy in the first place. These include questions such as these:
When you group customers by using the answers to these questions, you create market segments based on the benefits that customers look for. Because these market segments describe your customers from their point of view, rather than your own, they provide the best opportunity for you to satisfy the particular needs of an entire customer group.
As you try to figure out exactly why customers buy products and services in your marketplace, start a list of the benefits that you think they look for. We discuss this a bit earlier in this chapter, urging you to look beyond the easy-to-see veneer and dig deeper for answers. Product benefits may sound an awful lot like product features, but in subtle yet crucial ways, product benefits and product features are really quite different.
Recall Spirit Airlines noted earlier in this chapter. The policies of the market leaders often create opportunities for the new little disrupter who has an ear closer to the ground for sensing customer desires. You need to understand the difference between benefits and features if you plan to use the market segments that you come up with to create an effective business plan. Take a moment to think about the business situations sketched out in Figure 6-2.
Which of the benefits listed represents genuine benefits to the customers of each company? A trick question, of course: You don’t define benefits — only customers do.
A market segment is useful only if it allows you to deliver something of value to the customers you identify — and to do so profitably. Not all the market segments that you come up with are going to be practical ones. What should you look for if you want to find a really useful market segment? In general, you want to make sure that it has the following characteristics:
Choosing a manageable group of customers takes you back to efficiency and effectiveness issues (which we cover more extensively in Chapter 4). For a firm like Walmart or Procter & Gamble, manageable market segments are large and quite different from those of broadcasters like Fox or MSNBC, which cater to a more targeted audience. You want to be effective in serving your market segment — do the right thing. But you also have to be efficient — do it the right way. Clearly, the notion of manageable market segments has changed over the years. In general, they’re shrinking as information technology provides new tools to slice markets into smaller and smaller pieces without sacrificing efficiency — the mass customization approach detailed in the earlier sidebar “The digital revolution and ‘mass customization.’” It’s like having your cake and getting to eat it, too — or cleaning the plate but not gaining weight.
But then what? Unfortunately, you can’t always detect intimate customer behavior — motives, wants, needs, and preferences — from the outside (unless you’re a psychotherapist, of course, but can we really believe them these days?). You may know what these people are really like, but how do you go about tracking them down? If you want to recognize the customers in your market segment, you have to tie their behavior to characteristics that you can see.
After you define a promising market segment based on customer wants and needs and including customers you can describe, you have to develop ways of communicating with those customers. You can’t be satisfied just knowing that this group of customers exists somewhere out there in the consumer universe, even if you can describe and recognize them.
You need to set up affordable ways to contact the right customer through clever marketing, and then deliver your product or service in a timely manner. One approach is through what’s called direct marketing. This means going direct to a prospective customer (duh) and avoiding any intermediaries. The great advantage of direct marketing is that you can target snail mail or email to potential buyers who have already demonstrated interest in what you want to sell. So how do you find out who these potential customers are?
There are folks out there called list brokers. They know where the lists of contacts can be found, which includes name-rank-and-serial-number details. They’ve been around forever. In the past the lists came primarily from magazine subscriptions; more than 7,000 different magazines are available in the United States, so chances are there’s one whose readers are just the kind of customer you’re looking for. This service isn’t free, of course; you typically rent the list for a fee based on the number of prospects it contains. Just Google “list broker” and see what turns up.
The digital version of this approach comes from platforms that capture and store your every key tap on the Internet. If you engage in a search for, say, educational toys for that future little Einstein in the house, the information can be aggregated and your URL (your device’s Internet address) sold to someone for use in a direct marketing campaign.
There’s a relatively sizable group of folks out there who are often frustrated when searching for things suited just for them. They’re called the left-handed. While you might be able to tailor something specific to their manual dexterity needs (golf clubs, for instance, or scissors), you also have to devise a marketing and distribution plan that ties into the common behavior of this group. Ideally, you want to get the full attention of left-handers without incurring the costs of reaching the 90 percent of folks in the right-handed world who couldn’t care less.
This is called the “richness versus reach” dilemma. That is, to extend the reach of your message (the breadth of the market you can reach) at an affordable cost, you have to compromise the richness of the message (the level of detail you present). For example, your new product development team has devised a complex new financial investment product that yields above average returns with good tax advantages. To reach a sizable audience at a reasonable cost, you can place a print ad for the product in mass-circulation media that brings the cost of viewership way down; this is known as the cost-per-thousand (CPM) ratio — that is, what the fee is to reach each thousand viewers. But to do so at a reasonable cost, you end up with a rather abbreviated weak tea message: “Hey, investors! Try this, it’ll save you a bundle!” Spelling out the benefits in granular form, which may be necessary given the circumstances of each potential customer and the complexities of your product, is hugely expensive and likely impossible through mass-media marketing. You end up having to use a financial advisor to explain in detail to each customer, one at a time, and that advisor gets a hefty fee for doing so.
Efficient, yes, but effective no. So how do you gain the attention of, and access to, the narrow slice of the product pie? For investment management firms with curated offerings, the customer has to pay a sizable fee as it is so expensive for that firm to find and identify you (ever notice how those folks are all driving the latest version of luxury cars and you’re not?). As for the left-handed set, an easy method would be to place ads in Southpaw Press and to make your products readily available at all Lefties Outlet stores. The catch is that not one of these companies exists.
Maybe it’s too early to give up. The Internet continues to amaze with its endless opportunities for both disruption and invention. But if you can’t come up with creative ways to reach out to, and communicate with, narrowly defined customer segments, the group isn’t a useful market except when the customer is willing to pay whatever for your offering. In addition to having similar needs, common observable traits, and a manageable size, a useful market segment has to present realistic opportunities to be reached. (Perhaps that’s why left-handers are always so frustrated.)
Remember back in school when you were told to check your homework before handing it in — especially if the teacher was going to grade it? Well, the marketplace is a difficult class to tackle (as difficult as, say, calculus or physics), and the stakes are high. Before you commit to a particular market segment scheme, make sure that you look back over your homework. Pose these review questions to yourself:
At some point, you may want to use a more sophisticated approach to answer some of the questions in the previous list. Test marketing gauges your ideas on a carefully selected sample of potential customers in your market segment. Using a test market, you can often judge how well your product plan is likely to work before you spend beaucoup bucks going forward. And guess what? The proliferation of online test market services has brought down considerably the price of this once expensive tool. (Key in Capterra.com, click on the survey software menu, and you’ll see a gaggle of e-researchers just waiting for you to contact them; Capterra’s not the only source for this service, either.) You also may want to start by just conducting some preliminary customer interviews on your own. Dial up some folks who have some basic interest in your concept and see what they think. Not scientific, but their initial response might be a good way to kickstart the research process. It’s also free.
Prod them to talk a bit about themselves.
You don’t need to precisely categorize them at this point, but gathering some identifiers — gender, education, and so on — will help.
Have them tell you what they like and don’t like about your product.
Push hard on this; people often don’t like to give bad news in person, especially if they know you.
IT firms have a special challenge when introducing new or upgraded software products: Any bugs can be disastrous for everyone involved, and even give the firm a serious black eye that’s difficult to recover from. It can cost four to five times as much to repair flaws after product release, compared to doing the fix in the design stage. Back in 1993, the leading semiconductor firm Intel introduced its Pentium i486 processor that had a calculation bug; the damage cost the firm $475 million. Not only do product features have to be relevant and useful to users, but they also have to work as advertised. One way IT firms do this is a two-stage process: alpha and beta testing.
3.147.49.252