Chapter 19
Writers’ Protections

Ideas vs. Stories

In an age where piracy, intellectual property theft, and identity theft are rampant, it is all the more important for all writers to protect their material. After laboring over the research and painstaking work required to write and hone a screenplay, writers must be proactive in protecting their work. Copyright is the best protection for writers and intellectual property, which we will go into more detail shortly, but from a linear standpoint, everything starts with an idea.

Ideas are common to many of us. Whatever your idea for a movie may be, I can guarantee you that at least a dozen other people in the world right now have the same idea. I have had many ideas for films over the years, which I didn’t pursue and develop for one reason or another, and others, with the same ideas, saw them to completion and fruition. I’m sure, conversely, that many others have had similar or identical ideas to those that I have developed into screenplays and made into films, while they simply did not. If you are reading this book, chances are you are motivated to take your ideas beyond thoughts and concepts and transpose them into screenplays. What makes a common idea extraordinary is how you as the writer breathe life into it and the form with its proprietary nuances it takes thereafter. The flushed out manifestation of the idea is yours and yours alone. The more unique it is, the more valuable your idea will be in the marketplace. As evidenced by many of my ideas being made into films by others who had the same or similar ideas, you cannot protect an idea. When you think you have a great idea for a movie, the first step toward protecting it is to commit the idea to paper. Write the most detailed account of your idea possible. The more in depth and specific your idea, story, and characters are, the more unique elements a judge may be able to differentiate between your idea and someone else’s should a copyright case regarding a dispute over your work ever be heard in a court of law. The whole point of copyright law is to distinguish one person’s ideas from a competitor’s. The more comprehensive the key points of your outline and story are, the better protected you are.

WGA Registration

For the purpose of establishing evidence that a screenwriter is the author of a particular screenplay, the WGA offers a service through which screenplays may be registered.

Screenwriters can obtain a Certificate of Registration from the WGA (www.wga.org) and register their completed screenplays for a nominal fee. Along with the Certificate of Registration, you will enclose a copy of the final version of your screenplay. In return, you will receive a letter from the WGA stating the date your script was received and a serial number as reference, should you ever need to prove date of registration and origin of material. Keep this number in a safe place. However, since this service is one of record keeping and is not regulated by law, a variety of commercial and non-profit organizations exist for registering screenplays, which can provide proof-of-authorship by third-party assurance vendors, such as the Creators Vault. Note that registering a screenplay is not the same as the legal copyrighting of a written work.

Many years ago, screenwriters were advised to protect their work by putting their script into a self-addressed envelope and to mail it to themselves via registered mail, relying on the postmark from the unopened envelope to provide proof, if ever needed, of when the work was created. In today’s world, you need to register your script with a third party. Never tell anyone an idea until you have written it down as completely as possible and registered it. Keep a record of everyone you have discussed your screenplay with and/or submitted it to. Treat your work and how you protect it as you would in any other business or proprietary information.

Copyrights

The moment you create a work, you as the writer or artist own the copyright, which is universally recognized worldwide. The sticky part is being able to prove it in a court of law, should it ever become necessary. As we discussed above, you can’t copyright an idea, but you can copyright the expression of that idea, whether it is a screenplay, play, poem, fiction or non-fiction book, sculpture, or painting. Sometimes, the difference between what is an idea and what is an individual’s unique and distinct expression of an idea can be complex. Often in the film business, two different writers may each come up with the same idea and basic storyline for a film, whether fiction or bio-pic, but they write two very different screenplays from very different perspectives and often compete with each other for prime release dates. Most often when this occurs, one studio usually backs off rather than risk greater failure by dissipating the market share and interest in a particular topic. The screenplays in this instance can each be copyrighted, but the idea the screenplays were based on cannot be copyright protected.

Today, most motion picture and television production companies refuse to read unsolicited screenplays from unknown writers, so representation has become increasingly vital. With our litigious society, studios and networks now accept screenplays only through official channels like talent agents, managers, and entertainment attorneys and require that screen-writers sign comprehensive legal releases before accepting a submission and passing the script on to actually be read and considered.

The Library of Congress

The Library of Congress will formally register your screenplay and issue a copyright certificate.

Steps to Registering a Copyright

  • Create.
  • Compose a song. Write book, a play, a poem, a screenplay. Paint a picture.
  • Register your copyright.
  • Complete an application.
  • Include the correct fee.
  • Include non-returnable copies (usually, one for unpublished and two for published).
  • Send the package to:
    • Library of Congress
    • Copyright Office
    • 101 Independence Avenue, SE.
    • Washington, D.C. 20559 6000

  • The Copyright Office receives your package, and your registration becomes effective on that day.
  • Your payment is processed.
  • The Library of Congress examines your application and deposit and makes sure they’re acceptable and meet the requirements of copyright law and regulations.
  • Your registration is assigned a number and a certificate of registration is issued as well as an online, searchable public record of your registration. (You’ll receive that certificate in the mail about four months after you submit your package.)

The certificate is proof that the copyright belongs to you. However, proof of copyright is not the same as proof of authorship. For instance, a producer could hire a writer to write a screenplay and as part of the deal, the writer might agree to transfer the copyright to the producer, who could legally own the copyright to a script that he or she did not write.

Underlying Source Material

Writers will often base stories or screenplays on underlying material, such as true-life stories, which may be based on accounts reported in newspapers, magazines, online, on television, or in books. In order to have a clean chain of title (explained in detail below), based on underlying source material, the writer must have first acquired the screenplay rights to the true-life person or event that is the subject of the script, with a written agreement granting permission and the terms and conditions upon which the grant of rights is based. Make absolutely certain that you have necessary permission before you start writing.

In the past, I have contacted journalists or publications regarding acquiring the rights to a story that appeared in a periodical. I have also often directly approached the individual subject of an article if the subject matter is about an individual’s life, life events, or personal accomplishments. When dealing with an individual about their life story or an event that is meaningful in their life, the greatest key to persuading them to grant their rights to you is to be empathetic and to listen to their fear and concerns of how they or others in the story might be portrayed. If the subject of the underlying rights you desire has been convicted of a crime, there are restrictive laws governing the stories of criminals. Most countries will not allow a criminal to profit from any story about their crime. In the United States, there are Son of Sam laws, which are any laws designed to prohibit criminals from financially benefitting from the publicity of their crimes, which includes selling their stories to publishers, screenwriters, or filmmakers, and similar laws exist in other countries. When contacting a person convicted of a crime, always use the services of an entertainment attorney who can guide and advise you.

Chain of Title

In real estate, the chain of title for a house traces all the previous owners back in time to make sure that the title has no unpaid mortgages, liens for taxes, or any other encumbrances, so that it may transfer freely to the new owner. Screenplays are intellectual property, and the laws governing the optioning, buying, and selling of intellectual property are similar to those governing real estate transaction. Think of the chain of title as you would your birth certificate, driver’s license, and passport, which not only prove your origin, but the legitimacy of the documents grant you the legal right to drive a car or to travel internationally. As a screenwriter, you need to prove the origin of your script and verify that you are the registrar of the original story and screenplay. Remember, chain of title must be clear before any film project may move forward!

For every legitimate motion picture made, a clean chain of title is required. In the film business, the chain of title is the documentation that establishes the exclusive, irrefutable rights in and to the material upon which a screenplay and the resulting movie are based. Without a clean chain of title, no bank or equity financier will fund any film; no completion bond company will guarantee it; and no state or federal subsidy, tax credit, or grant will be given. For all of these reasons, entertainment attorneys are sticklers about chain of title. Attorneys’ due diligence usually starts with the U.S. Copyright Office to see if any other companies or individuals have filed any claims or an interest in the screenplay’s copyright or underlying story, where usually, any potential ownership problems or inconsistencies will be discovered. Chain of title is a linear series of contract that connects the dots from A to B, B to C, and so on concerning the initial story, screenplay, or any purchase or option agreements from any previous persons or companies who may have had an interest, claim, or lien of the screenplay.

Imagine a producer hires a non-WGA writer (writer A) on a step deal. Writer A writes a story and a treatment and is fired. The producer then hires writer B to write a new draft with many new ideas and concepts. He next hires writer C to do a polish and then hires a director who does his own rewrite. There must be a clear and concise written agreement with each writer, as well as the director, conveying any and all material created by each writer and the writer/director for a clean chain of title.

Example of Chain of Title

As a real world example, in 2009/2010, I produced a SyFy channel premiere movie called Mongolian Death Worm. The concept originated in Canada, was transferred to a Canadian production services company which hired a writer, and subsequently a director, with the intent of producing the movie in Canada. A series of unforeseen events occurred and a better opportunity arose for the picture to be financed and shot in the U.S., and there were many agreements which were necessary to document the linear chain of events which made the chain of title vastly more complex and necessitated many steps and documents to make it complete for legal clearance, which I have summarized below:

Mongolian Death Worm Concept Assignment Agreement

The original concept was created by a producer (owner) who was a resident of Canada. A Concept Assignment Agreement was the first document in the chain, in which the owner, through his company, sold all rights to his entertainment company:

Owner does hereby grant, assign, transfer and sell to XYZ Productions, Inc. (“Company”), its successors and assigns throughout the world, all right, title and interest in Mongolian Death Worm (the “Concept”), together with all copyrights and extensions and renewals of copyrights, if any, including the sole exclusive, perpetual and world-wide motion picture, television and allied and incidental rights in the concept and any and all adaptations thereof including but not limited to, theatrical, television (whether films, tapes or otherwise recorded and including series rights), CD-ROM, CD-1, cassette or other compact devices, sequel, remake and advertising rights (including publication rights); all rights to exploit, distribute and exhibit any motion picture or any other production produced herein in all media now known or hereinafter devise; all rights to make any and all changes and adaptations to the Concept; merchandising, soundtrack, music publishing and all other exploitation rights. All causes of action for infringement or violation of all copyrights in and to the concept are hereby assigned to Company insofar as they pertain to the right hereby assigned, and Company is hereby empowered to bring, prosecute, defend and appear in suits, actions, and proceedings of any nature under or concerning said copyrights and renewal copyrights and any infringement thereof, or interference with any of the rights hereby granted, assigned and transferred thereunder in its own name or in the name of the copyright proprietor, but at the expense of Company, and, at its option, Company may join copyright proprietor and/or the undersigned as a party plaintiff or defendant in any such suit, action, or proceeding. Any recovery or costs from infringement or violation of any such copyrights, or renewal copyrights, so far as it arises from any violation of said rights hereby assigned, is likewise assigned to and shall be paid to Company.

Without quoting the entire agreement, the owner of the concept had to further represent and warrant that: They were the author and creator of the concept throughout the world and all rights in and to the concept, that it was not in the public domain in any country anywhere in the world where copyright protection is available, and that there were no outstanding legal claims or litigations pending against or involving the title or the ownership and or copyright in the concept; that the owner had the full right and authority to enter into the agreement and convey the rights granted; that no motion picture or any dramatic version of the concept or any part of it had been manufactured or produced in any media; that nothing had been omitted in the transfer of rights and that to the best of owner’s knowledge they had not committed or performed any act that in any way could diminish, encumber, or impair the rights being granted; that the owner had not adapted the concept from any other dramatic or other literary material of any kind, unless it was in the public domain, and that the owner had not copied or used the concept, the plot, any scenes, sequences, or story of any other literary or dramatic material; that the concept does not infringe on any common law; and that nothing contained in the material is libelous or in violation of the rights of privacy to any person, firm, or corporation.

Formation of Production Services Company

It was intended that the picture was to be financed by procuring a bank loan. Every bank loan requires collateral, and as we’ve covered, entertainment loans are no exception. Collateral could be in the form of one or multiple foreign pre-sales, a domestic pre-sale, a combination of foreign and domestic pre-sales, tax credit or subsidy, and, if there is still a gap or shortfall, perhaps an equity component. To recap, banks require completion bonds, and both banks and bond companies require that collateral for the funding of the entire budget and associated costs of financing the picture (the strike price) must be in place prior to closing of the prospective loan. Also, loan and security agreements are meticulously contracted with the bank, which factors in loan fees, interest reserve, bank legal fees, a legal reserve, plus a fully executed contract with a completion guarantor (who generally charges 3% of the film’s budget as a bond fee), in order for the bank to close financing and make funds available for production. A bank requires that a “clean” corporation, with no liens or encumbrances, act as the borrower and rights holder until the loan is repaid in full and the lien is removed, and requires what is known as a “notice and acknowledgement of assignment” (NOA) to be executed with each foreign and domestic buyer or distributor. This is essentially a direction to pay, which obviates the sales agent and legally requires the distributor to pay the bank directly upon delivery of the film.

A single purpose corporation (“Producer”) was formed under the laws of Canada, expressly for the purpose of the production of the film Mongolian Death Worm, with the intent of using both foreign and domestic pre-sale contracts, as well as Canadian and British Columbian subsidies as the total required to meet the strike price for the film.

First Writer Agreement

Producer entered into a writer agreement with the loan out corporation (Lender) of a Canadian writer, which provided the services of the writer. The agreement was a step deal, which engaged the Writer to write an Outline based on the Concept with payment due upon receipt and acceptance by the Company of the Outline, and was a non-union agreement, which was not subject to the terms and conditions of any guild or labor organization. Thereafter at Producer’s sole discretion (if the Producer chose not to terminate the Writer’s services after the Outline and exercise its option for additional steps), Producer could further engage the Writer to write a first draft of a screenplay based on the approved Outline, with payment upon commencement of the first draft and an additional payment upon receipt and acceptance of the completed first draft by the Producer. Subject to the Producer exercising its option for a second draft, the Producer could engage the Writer to write a second draft of a screenplay, with payment upon commencement of the second draft and an additional payment upon receipt and acceptance of the completed second draft by Producer. Subject to Producer exercising its option for a polish, Producer could engage the Writer to write a polish of the screenplay, with payment upon commencement of the polish and an additional payment upon receipt and acceptance of the completed polish by the Producer. The grant of rights mirrored the grant of rights in the Concept Assignment Agreement with the Writer granting and assigning all rights of every nature (including all literary material, the picture, and the copyright), as well as all results and proceeds, to the Producer throughout the universe in perpetuity. A concurrent requirement was the execution of a Certificate of Authorship, which includes the following provisions: The engagement of the Writer is a “work made for hire” for Producer pursuant to the U.S. copyright act and a “work made in the course of employment” pursuant to the copyright act (Canada). Producer shall be deemed the sole and exclusive author of the material, and accordingly shall and does own all right, title, and interest therein, including without limitation the entire copyright therein throughout the universe in perpetuity. Producer shall have the unrestricted right to add to, subtract from, and/or revise the material and/or combine the same with the writings of others in such a manner and to such extent company or any of its successors, licensees, or assignees may suffer or incur by reasons of the breach or alleged breach of any representations or warranties made herein.

First Director Agreement

The Producer entered into an agreement with the loan out company (Lender) for the services of a Canadian Director to further develop the screenplay and to direct the Picture, in accordance with the DGA basic agreement and the terms and conditions of the applicable DGA low-budget motion picture agreement. The Director was to perform services customarily required of directors in the motion picture industry and “consulting services” and “screenplay polish services” (writing), as reasonably required by Producer, but to “exert diligent good faith efforts to shoot the script as delivered to Director by Producer” and “not to make any substantive changes in the script or shooting schedule without the express prior written consent of Producer.” The Director was also contractually bound to a litany of duties and obligations, including using good faith efforts to insure that the Picture was produced at a cost that did not exceed the budget as established by Producer and in accordance with the production schedule and cash flow as established by Producer, and to cooperate with the Editor to complete and deliver a first assemblage of the Picture immediately following the completion of principal photography. All representations and warranties, indemnities, and transfer of any and all rights in and to any material created or contributed to the Picture were the sole and exclusive property of the Producer in language that mirrored all of the rights granted in the other two agreements. An initial payment was paid to the Director, which constituted full and final consideration for all rights in and to any Director’s polishes of the screenplay for the Picture. The rest of the Director’s compensation was to be paid in increments: on the first day of prep, on the first day of principal photography, on the final day of principal photography, upon delivery and acceptance of the Director’s cut of the Picture.

The Director warranted and agreed that all material, works, writings, ideas, “gags,” or dialogue written, composed, prepared, submitted, or interpolated by Director in connection with the Picture or its preparation or production “shall be wholly original with Director and shall not be copied in whole or in part from any other work, except that which has been submitted to Director by Producer as a basis for such material” or material in the public domain.

First Director #1 Quitclaim and Release

When the production plans changed and it was decided to finance and shoot the Picture in U.S., in consideration of a flat payment to the Director, a Quit-claim and Release agreement was executed between the Owner, Producer, and the Director Lender. In this document, the Director and Lender, for a onetime flat payment, granted and quitclaimed

to Producer and its representatives, affiliates, predecessors, successors and assigns, parents, employees, directors, agents, contractors, and any and all other individuals and/or companies related to Producer, Guarantor, or the Picture (together “Related Parties”) and assigns forever all rights including the advertising/exploitation throughout the world in perpetuity, Lender or Director may have in that certain literary property (the “Story”) on which the Picture is to be based, including all outlines thereof, all contents thereof, present and future adaptations, title and characters and the copyright thereof, including renewals and extensions.

Lender and Director further acknowledged that they had no rights or claim in and to the Picture and/or to any screenplay to be used in the creation of the Picture or any other screenplay otherwise using or incorporating the Story in any manner, and/or any further compensation under any contract between Producer and Lender or Director or otherwise in connection with the Picture. The Lender and Director also released and discharged Producer, Guarantor, and the Related Parties from any and all actions, claims, demands, “whatsoever, which may have existed from the beginning of time” through the execution of the quitclaim and release, with all of the releases, indemnities, representations, and warranties that mirror the language in the other documents.

Proof of Quitclaim and Release Payment to First Director

Where intellectual property rights are concerned, irrefutable proof of payment such as a wire transfer or cancelled check are critical components of chain of title. In this instance, the evidence of payment was a copy of the wire transfer instructions from the Producer’s Production Services Company to the Lender and Director, along with the date and time of the transfer.

Evidence of Payment to First Writer

The First Writer wrote the Outline and First Draft and was then terminated under the terms of the step deal. Cancelled checks, as evidence of payments for the Outline and the delivery and acceptance of the first draft, were required as part of the chain of title.

Canadian Production Services Agreement Termination

Under the laws of Canada, and for good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which was acknowledged, the agreement between Company and Producer was terminated in its entirety and “are of no force or effect. All rights in and to the film remained vested with Company” and “in the event that any statutory rights of Producer are now or in the future created by law, then any and all such rights are hereby assigned by Producer to Company.”

Assignment and Assumption Agreement to U.S. Production Company

This agreement was between both the original Canadian Company (“Assignor”), which acquired the concept rights from the owner (“Creator”), the Canadian production services company that was formed with the original intent to produce the film in Canada (“Prodco”), and the newly formed U.S. production services entity (“Producer”). The document essentially commemorated in writing, step-by-step, the chain of title from inception of the Concept to that point: Pursuant to a Concept Assignment, Assignor acquired all of creator’s right, title, and interest in and to that certain motion picture entitled Mongolian Death Worm (“The Project”) and any copyrights and registrations in connection there with and including all right, interest, choices in action, titles, elements, stories, plots, incidents, dialogue, characters, character names, dramatizations, and spinoffs; all components, parts, and manuscripts; all versions and translations thereof; and all renewals in extensions of copyright and all of the results and proceeds thereof (collectively the “Initial Property”); Pursuant to a Writer Agreement between Assignor and Lender f/s/o Writer, Assignor engaged the services of Writer to write a complete screenplay based on the Initial Property. Pursuant to a Production Services Agreement between Assignor and Prodco, Assignor engaged Prodco to provide certain production services in connection with the Project. Pursuant to a director Loan-Out agreement between Prodco, acting as agent for Assignor, and Lender f/s/o Director, Prodco engaged the services of Director to provide a rewrite of the script and to direct the project.

Second Writer Agreement—Certificate of Ownership of Results and Proceeds

The second Writer (in addition to the writing contributions made by the first and second Directors), was a staff employee of one of the U.S. companies who acted as a broker of the deal from Canada to the U.S., and was the liaison with the SyFy channel for network notes and performed writing services to adjust the screenplays accordingly. His agreement was a one-page Certificate of Ownership of Results and Proceeds, which stated that for a fee of $1.00, all of his services in connection with the “Work” were being rendered pursuant to this agreement between him and Producer. All results and proceeds of his writing work constituted within the meaning of copyright laws in the United States, a “work-made-for-hire” for Producer “with Producer and/or its assignees owning all rights in the universe in perpetuity, mirroring the grant of rights and ownership language in the other agreements, with identical representations, warranties, and indemnities made by Writer. Further,

insofar as Writer may possess any right, title, and interest in and to the Work, Writer hereby irrevocably assigns any and all such right, title, and interest to Producer. Writer at the request of Producer, shall execute and deliver to Producer such assignments or other instruments as Producer may deem reasonably to establish. Protect, enforce and/or defend any and all of Producer’s rights in the Work or under the Agreement.

Producer was also irrevocably appointed Writer’s “attorney-in-fact for the execution of any future documents that may require Writer’s signature.”

Second Director Agreement

The (now U.S.) Producer entered into an agreement with a new Director to further develop the screenplay and to direct the Picture. His agreement was non-DGA and upon execution of the agreement and a Certificate of Authorship, he was paid a percentage of his overall fee, “which amount shall also constitute full and final consideration for any and all writing services performed by Director hereunder.” The rest of the Director’s compensation was to be paid in increments: in six weekly installments commencing on the first day of principal photography for six consecutive weeks a final payment on delivery to Producer of the Director’s cut of the Picture. The Director was to be paid a bonus “in the event that the weekly cost report for the week ending three (3) weeks following the wrap of principal photography shows that an amount equal to fifty percent (50%) of the budgeted contingency remains unspent.”

The Director’s services became exclusive during the period four weeks prior to the commencement of principal photography and continuing until delivery of the Producer’s cut, and thereafter on an as needed basis through the completion of the final video master of the Picture. During subsequent non-exclusivity, Director “shall refrain from rendering services elsewhere which would interfere in any way with the services of Director in connection with the Picture or interfere with the completion of the Picture in accordance with the post-production schedule mutually approved by Producer and Director.” The Director specifically agreed to “deliver his Director’s cut, with a running time of not less than ninety-three (93) minutes excluding main and end titles, nor more than one hundred and ten (110) minutes including main and end titles, no later than three (3) weeks following the completion of principal photography and further agreed to complete the Picture in conformity to the budget as established by Producer and in accordance with the production schedule and cash flow as established by Producer.” All representations and warranties, indemnities, and transfer of any and all rights in and to any material created or contributed to the Picture were the sole and exclusive property of the Producer in language that mirrored all of the rights granted in all other agreements.

The Director warranted and agreed that all material, works, writings, ideas, “gags,” or dialogue written, composed, prepared, submitted, or interpolated by Director in connection with the Picture or its preparation or production, which “shall be wholly original with Director and shall not be copied in whole or in part from any other work, except that which has been submitted to Director by Producer as a basis for such material” or material in the public domain. Director was obligated to deliver a cut of the Picture that would be “suitable for the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) for a rating no more restrictive the ‘R,’ and additionally meet the standards applicable to and acceptable for network television primetime licensing and usage.” The Director was responsible for a Picture that did not contain any graphic violence, sexual content or implication of sexual content, or foul language without the prior written consent of Producer, and to provide Producer with “cover shots” necessary for the release of the Picture on television based on network continuity standards in existence at the time of principal photography of the Picture. Producer retained all final approvals of all aspects of the pre-production, production, budget, schedule, post-production and post-production schedule, editing, distribution, release title, publicity and marketing, and release of the Picture, and all other artistic and production in connection with the Picture.

Certificate of Authorship

In this one-page document, the Director certified that he contributed to the screenplay as a “work for hire” and “subject to the terms and conditions of the Agreements,” and that Producer and/or its assignees own(s) all rights in the universe in perpetuity, mirroring the grant of rights language in the other agreements, with identical representations, warranties, and indemnities made by Director.

Evidence of the United States Copyright Registration

A copy of the U.S. copyright application and registration number was provided, as the actual copyright certificate had not yet been received by from the Copyright Office.

As you can see, voluminous amounts of paperwork and documentation were required to prove the fairly complex linear chain of title, for this very small film. In a much less complicated scenario, a script would be purchased, or commissioned as a work for hire, by a production company with financing in place, and a writer agreement and certificate of authorship, and a director’s agreement, may constitute the complete chain of title.

..................Content has been hidden....................

You can't read the all page of ebook, please click here login for view all page.
Reset
3.142.97.235