Chapter 10

Thermal Energy Storage Systems Design

Abstract

The design of thermal energy storage (TES) system plays a significant role in achieving energy redistribution requirements when integrated with a dedicated cooling or heating system. The sizing of the thermal storage system as a function of demand load profile and on the basis of operating strategies can effectually achieve reduction in chiller load during electrical peak periods. The design methodology of TES systems incorporating flexible provisions to include or change operating strategies depending on the changing load demand can result in a more promising way of shifting the peak load demand to off-peak periods. The operating strategies of TES systems can be designed to fully utilize excess storage capacity during low demand periods, which would enable reduction in overall operating costs of the system.

Keywords

Chilled water storage

Cooling capacity

Freezing

Ice storage

Payback period

Piping

Pressurized thermal storage

TES

Waste heat recovery

10.1 Introduction

The most important part of recommending thermal energy storage (TES) systems, either sensible heat or latent heat, to be integrated with the cooling/heating systems in buildings essentially depends on their inherent design aspects. To enable thermal storage systems as fully functional, some crucial factors need to be considered during the design phase, which include the following:

 Thermal load (cooling/heating) profile of the building under consideration

 Type of TES system (e.g., full storage or partial storage)

 Selection of proper heat storage material

 Mode of operation (e.g., active or passive system)

 Availability periods of power supply

 Cooling/heating plant redundancy

 Space availability

 Capital and operating costs

In this context, the basic design of some sensible and latent TES systems with example calculations are demonstrated in forthcoming sections.

10.2 Sensible heat storage systems

In the sensible heat storage system, the quantity of heat energy that can be stored in the material (solid or liquid) by virtue of raising the temperature can be expressed as

Q=mcpΔT

si1_e  (10.1)

Equation (10.1) can be expressed in another form as

Q=mcpThTl

si2_e  (10.2)

where m is the mass of the storage medium, Th and Tl are the maximum and initial temperature of the material (K), and (Th − Tl) is referred to the temperature swing (K).

The volume (in m3) of the material that is required to store a given quantity of heat energy can be calculated by

V=md

si3_e  (10.3)

where, d is density of the material (kg/m3).

The volume of the material required can also be estimated using the relation given by

V=EdcpΔT

si4_e  (10.4)

where, cp is specific heat of the storage material (kJ/(kg K)).

For a typical office space subjected to a temperature swing of 2 °C, the quantity of energy that can be stored is about 0.250 MJ/m2. For an industrial space undergoing a temperature swing of 3 °C, the amount of energy that can be stored is about 0.370 MJ/m2. Thus, the quantity of sensible heat energy storage can be expressed as

E=0.250×Aforofficespaceapplication

si5_e  (10.5)

E=0.370×Aforindustrialapplication

si6_e  (10.6)

where, E is thermal energy being stored (kJ) and A is floor or building area (m2).

10.3 Latent Heat Storage Systems

From the perspective of latent heat storage systems, thermal energy can be stored or released by virtue of the phase transition process of a material occurring at or near isothermal conditions. The change in the state of the material from either liquid to solid (freezing) or solid to liquid (melting) is the key phenomenon for enabling the TES in phase change materials. The change in the latent heat enthalpy of the material during the freezing and melting processes determines the storage capacity of phase change materials (PCMs). This physical process can be suitably expressed in the form as given by

Q=mcpΔTsensible+H+cpΔTlatent

si7_e  (10.7)

where, H is latent heat enthalpy of the heat storage material (kJ/kg).

The simple design procedures for ice thermal energy storage (ITES) and chilled water-packed bed TES systems are presented in forthcoming sections:

10.3.1 Sizing of ITES system

Inputs for design of ITES system:

Requirement of cooling energy on daily basis—3000 kWh

Time of charging (freezing) of the ice storage—8 h

Time of discharging (melting) of the ice storage—10 h

Peak cooling load demand persisting in the building space—500 kW

A rotary screw type chiller (cooling plant) considered

Energy storage efficiency factor—0.95 (assumed)

Storage capacity—50%

Estimation of the ice storage capacity:

The energy generation requirement on a per day basis can be determined by

Eg=Coolingenergyrequirementperday*storagecapacity

si8_e  (10.8)



Thus, Eg = 3000 × (50/100) = 1500 kWh

The total energy storage capacity can be evaluated by

ET=EgEnergystorageefficiencyfactor

si9_e  (10.9)



Thus, ET = 1500/0.95 ≈ 1580 kWh

The charging (freezing) of ice storage using the chilled water medium can be determined by

Icestoragecharging=ETTimeofchargingoftheicestorage

si10_e  (10.10)



That is, ice storage charging = (1580/8) = 198 kWh

The chiller cooling capacity during the design day operation can be estimated by

Chillercoolingcapacity=ETTimeofdischargingoftheicestorage

si11_e  (10.11)



That is, chiller cooling capacity = (1580/10) = 158 kWh.

Thus, the chiller nominal capacity can be determined by

Chillernominalcapacity=PeakcoolingloaddemandpersistinginbuildingChillercoolingcapacity

si12_e  (10.12)



Therefore, chiller nominal capacity = (500 − 158) = 342 kWh.

The chiller plant being selected for charging the ice storage (during nighttime) is capable of shifting the peak load demand in a building during daytime at 50% higher capacity. Hence, the design cooling capacity of the chiller can be estimated to by ≈ 300 kWh (i.e., 198 kW × 1.5).

10.3.2 Sizing of chilled water packed bed LTES system

The design of a chilled water-packed bed LTES system is proposed for a building located in a hot and humid climatic condition. The on-peak and off-peak cooling load requirements are represented by red and blue colors, respectively, in Table 10.1. The total cooling load of the building considered is estimated to be 4130 kW. The efficiency factors for the charging and discharging processes are assumed to be 0.9 and 0.8, respectively.

Table 10.1

Design of the chilled water-packed bed LTES system

Time (h)Total Cooling Energy Demand (kW)Load Satisfied byChiller + TES Charging (kW)TES Balance (kW)
Chiller (kW)TES Tank (kW)
 0100164100164353
 1100164100164416
 2100164100164480
 3101164101164542
 4103164103164603
 5101164101164666
 6107164107164722
 7112164112164774
 8120164120164818
 9225184 41  0777
10245184 61  0716
11270184 86  0630
12300184116  0514
13320184136  0378
14300184116  0262
15270184 86  0176
16255184 71  0105
17245184 61  0 45
18229184 44  0  0
19113164113164 50
20110164110164104
21105164105164162
22101164101164225
23100164100164289
Total4130184022902290

t0010

The nominal cooling capacity of the chiller plant can be estimated and is given by

Nominalcoolingcapacity=Totalcoolingload(Totalcharginghoursefficiencyfactor+Totaldischarginghoursefficiencyfactor)

si13_e  (10.13)

Thus, nominal cooling capacity = (4130/{(14*0.9) + (10*0.8)}) = 204 kW.

The cooling capacity of the chiller during direct cooling (on-peak load conditions) can be determined by

Coolingcapacityofchilleron-peak=204*0.9=184kW

si14_e

Likewise, the cooling capacity of the chiller during charging of the LTES system (off-peak conditions) can be obtained by

Coolingcapacityofchilleroff-peak=204*0.8=164kW

si15_e

The cooling capacity shared by the LTES system (energy redistribution) during on-peak condition can be estimated as follows:

At the commencement of the off-peak load condition (typically at 19 h):

CoolingcapacityofLTES=(CoolingcapacityofchilleratthespecifichourofpartloadconditionTotalcoolingloadatthathour)+Storagebalanceattheprevioushour

si16_e  (10.14)

Thus, (cooling capacity of LTES)commencement = (164 − 113) + 0 = 50 kW.

At the completion of the off-peak load condition (typically at 8 h):

CoolingcapacityofLTES=(Totalcoolingload((Nominalcoolingcapacityofthechillerpeakloadoperatinghoursefficiencyfactor)+SCoolingcapacityofchillerduringchargingatpartloadconditions))

si17_e  (10.15)

Thus,coolingcapacityofLTEScompletion=(4130((204*10*0.9)+S164*9))=818kW

si18_e

CoolingcapacitysharedbyLTES=(CoolingcapacityofLTESatthecompletionofpartload(TotalcoolingloadChillercoolingcapacityduringdirectcooling))

si19_e  (10.16)

Thus, the cooling load shared by LTES during on-peak load conditions can be estimated by

CoolingloadsharedbyLTESonpeak=818225184=777kW

si20_e

Therefore, it can be observed from Table 10.1 that the LTES system is completely discharged at 18 h (completion of on-peak load demand period), which signifies that the LTES system is ready for the commencement of the next cycle of the charging process.

10.4 Design Examples

10.4.1 Long-term thermal storage option

For a building cooling application, a chiller of 350 kW cooling capacity is considered to be fully operational for about 720 h. The criteria is to store a minimum annual cooling load, which is given by

Annualcoolingloadtobestoredmin=350*720=252,000kWh

si21_e

For ice to be used as a latent heat storage medium, for every megajoule of cooling energy, about 3 liters of ice (equivalent to 3 kg) is required.

Thus, the volume of ice required for thermal storage can be determined by

Icerequiredvolume=3L/MJ*252,000kWh*3.6MJ/kWh=2,721,600liters2722m3

si22_e

Assuming the depth of the storage tank to be 2 m,

Areaofthestoragetank,A=2722/2=1361m2

si23_e

Considering a cylindrical configuration of the storage tank,

Diameter of the storage tank = (4A/π)^0.5 = ((4*1361)/3.1415)^0.5 ≈ 42 m.

Thus, based on the preceding calculations, it is seen that a very large diameter of the storage tank is actually required for meeting the seasonal cooling energy redistribution requirements in the building. Furthermore, this condition can also be treated as a major constraint in establishing long-term TES options for cooling applications in buildings, which involves additional cost factors.

10.4.2 Short-term thermal storage option

For the same cooling capacity of the chiller as discussed earlier, if the chiller is operated for about 10 h, then the minimum annual cooling load is given by

(Annual cooling load to be stored)min = 350*10 = 3500 kWh

For ice to be used as a latent heat storage medium, for every megajoule of cooling energy, about 3 liters of ice (equivalent to 3 kg) is required.

Thus, the volume of ice required for thermal storage can be estimated by

Icerequiredvolume=3L/MJ*3,500kWh*3.6MJ/kWh=37,800liters37.8m3

si24_e

Assuming the depth of the storage tank to be 2 m,

Areaofthestoragetank,A=37.8/2=18.9m2

si25_e

Considering a cylindrical configuration of the storage tank,

Diameter of the storage tank = (4A/π)^0.5 = ((4*18.9)/3.1415)^0.5 ≈ 5 m

It is easily observed that the storage tank diameter is almost 8–9 times smaller than to that of the long-term storage option. Thus, the LTES systems can be integrated with building cooling systems, which can be advantageous in meeting the energy redistribution requirements on diurnal or short-term basis.

10.4.3 Short-term thermal storage option in piping systems

The chilled water circulating in the hydronic piping network, which connects the building side with the chiller plant, can be effectively used as a cool thermal storage medium for offsetting the peak load demand in buildings. Usually, the chilled water at a temperature of 8–9 °C is supplied to the cooling coil heat exchanger of the building air handling unit. Reducing the supply temperature of the chilled water by 4 or 5 °C prior to on-peak load conditions can help to reduce the load at the chiller during peaking periods of electricity. For instance, the volume of chilled water in the piping network is considered to be 4000 liters with the chilled water temperature differential remaining at 4 °C, and the refrigeration capacity of the chiller can be estimated by

Refrigerationcapacity=VdΔTcp/3600=(4000144.2)/3600=18.7kWh

si26_e

This means that, 18.7 kWh of thermal energy is stored in the chilled water, which can be utilized an hour prior to the commencement of the on-peak load for experiencing a reduction in the load at the chiller side during electrical peak periods.

Assuming the electricity demand charges for this system to be $10/kW and the coefficient of performance of the chiller to be 3.5, the cost savings on annual basis can be obtained by

Annualcostsavings=18.7*10*12/3.5$642

si27_e

Assuming the cost incurred for a timer and reset control for the system to be $1000, the payback period can be calculated by

Paybackperiodsimple=$1000/$6421.6years

si28_e

10.4.4 Heating thermal storage option with pressurized water systems

For a domestic hot water application, a pressurized storage system is considered to be integrated with the hot water circuit, in which the water present in the storage tank can be heated up to 135 °C prior to the occurrence of the peak electrical demand period. The hot water can be distributed at 90 °C during the peak period. Assuming 1 liter of water, the additional heat storage capacity of the water can be estimated based on Eq. (10.1) given by

Q=mcpΔT=14.213590

si29_e

Therefore,Q=189kJ/kg=0.189MJ/kgorMJ/L

si30_e

For a building with 2600 kW of electric water heating facility and with four pressurized storage tanks with a of volume 9500 liters installed, the storage energy required for the same temperature conditions of hot water as above can be evaluated by

Heatingenergystored=Volume*additionalcapacityofenergystorage=4*9500*0.189=7182MJ

si31_e

The electrical load reduction for 1 h can be determined by

Reductioninelectricalload=Heatingenergystored*Peakhourshift/3.6=7182*1/3.6=1995kW

si32_e

where, the value of 3.6 is expressed in terms of MJ/kWh.

Assuming the electricity demand charge for this system to be $10/kW and for a heating season period of about 4.5 months, the cost savings on annual basis can be obtained by

Annualcostsavings=1995*10*4.5$89,775/year

si33_e

Assuming the cost incurred for the installation of the four pressurized storage tanks and the associated piping network to be $260,000, the payback period can be calculated by

Paybackperiodsimple=$260,000/$89,7753years

si34_e

10.4.5 TES option with waste heat recovery

An industrial batch process is considered in which about 20,000 liters of water at 90 °C are discharged to the drain. By installing a holding tank with a capacity 20,000 liters and a heat exchanger facility, the heat that is wasted from the discharged water can be effectively utilized for heating the incoming makeup water. Assuming the temperature of the water exiting the heat exchanger to be 30 °C, the heat energy being stored in the waste water tank during each drain cycle can be estimated using Eq. (10.1), given by

Q=mcpΔT=200004.29030/1000

si35_e

Therefore, Q = 5023 MJ

It is understood that roughly 80% of the heat energy can be transferred from the hot water to the incoming makeup water, whereas the remaining 20% can be accounted for inherent thermal losses occurring at the tank and piping elements. The waste heat that is recovered from the heat exchanger can help to reduce the preheating energy required for the gas-fired boiler to heat the incoming makeup water.

Assuming the costing charge for the gas to be $0.50/m3, the cost savings on an annual basis can be obtained by

Annualcostsavings=QEfeCfNEfbfuelheatingvalue

si36_e  (10.18)

where, Efe is efficiency of heat exchanger (assumed to be 80%), Cf is fuel cost ($/m3), N is number of tank cycles/year (assumed to be 1000), and Efb is efficiency of boiler (assumed to be 70%).

Therefore, annual cost savings = (5023*0.8*0.5*1000)/(0.7*37.2) = $77,158.

Assuming the cost incurred for the heat exchanger, tank, and associated piping network to be $180,000, the payback period can be calculated by

Paybackperiodsimple=$180,000/$77,1582.3years

si37_e

The capacity of the TES for this option depends on the volume of the liquid (water) being drained in each tank cycle as well as the temperature gradient between the entering and leaving water at the heat exchanger or heat pump. By properly maintaining the heat exchanger system from contamination or fouling effects, the reduction in the effectiveness of heat transfer can be prevented.

10.5 Concise Remarks

The successful implementation of TES systems for cooling and heating applications primarily depends on the way they are designed to match the purpose. The crucial factors in determining the performance of the TES systems have to be carefully considered during the design phase. The inclusion of modest safety factors into the design of TES systems can help reduce oversizing or underestimation of chiller and storage systems. Flexibility in design methodology is most vital in the sense that it can accept additional storage capacities depending on the future load demand.

Further Reading

[1] ASHRAE. Thermal storage (Chapter 51). ASHRAE handbook—HVAC systems and equipment, 2012.

[2] Thermal storage. Energy management series 19 for industry commerce and institutions, Energy mines and Resources, Canada, https://oee.nrcan.gc.ca/sites/oee.nrcan.gc.ca/files/pdf/commercial/password/downloads/EMS_19_thermal_storage.pdf (accessed January 2014)

[3] Parameshwaran R, Kalaiselvam S. Energy efficient hybrid nanocomposite-based cool thermal storage air conditioning system for sustainable buildings. Energy. 2013;59:194–214.

[4] Seaman A, Martin A, Sands J. HVAC thermal storage: practical application and performance issues. 2000 BSRIA Application Guide AG 11/2000.

[5] Parameshwaran R, Kalaiselvam S. Thermal energy storage technologies, nearly zero energy building refurbishment: a multidisciplinary approach. London: Springer Publications; 2013 pp. 483–536.

[6] Cool thermal energy storage: shifting cooling load off peak, energy design resources, 2009.

[7] Niehus TL. Designing a thermal energy storage program for electric utilities. In: Proceedings: ninth symposium on improving building systems in hot and humid climates, Arlington, TX, May 19-20; 1994:285–288.

..................Content has been hidden....................

You can't read the all page of ebook, please click here login for view all page.
Reset
18.118.102.225