47The Forces Driving Online Reputation
smaller discussions (“threads”) about a particular topic (such as the
role of steroids in sports). Any user can post any message, subject
only to the whim of the website owner. The result is massively mul-
tidirectional conversations about every topic under the sun. To just
paraphrase one short list of topics, it is possible to find discussions
about parenting, painting, the playoffs, the Partridge Family, Picasso,
Proctor and Gamble, Portland (Oregon), Portland (Maine), and
myriad other niches. There is probably a discussion group for any
identifiable interest. And, even if there isn’t, many forums have “off-
topic” sections where anything else can be discussed.
The owners of Web 2.0 or discussion websites may choose to
moderate discussions by deleting offensive content, or they may sim-
ply choose to let users set their own standards. Moderation is time-
consuming for site owners; everyone has a different idea of what it
means for something to be offensive (consider, for example, the con-
troversy about depictions of the religious figure Mohammed in a se-
ries of editorial cartoons), and moderation decisions frequently lead
to more bickering and debate among users. As a result of the diffi-
culty of moderation and the natural tendency of humans toward
scandal, some user-created content has a tendency to devolve toward
the lowest common denominator. Gossip and scandal attracts atten-
tion, online and off, and there is a strong temptation for site owners
to allow (or even encourage) users to discuss scandalous topics in or-
der to attract more traffic, which usually leads to more ad revenue.
Unfortunately, some users take this freedom and use it to spread
gossip, to attack other people out of jealousy or spite, and to repeat
misinformation. And, unlike the tabloids of yore, website users often
don’t limit themselves to discussing celebrities and public figures.
The open publishing model of Web 2.0 is the first ingredient of the
sometimes dangerous online mix.
Everyone Is (Almost) Equal
To the extent that everyone can create content, everyone is equal. For
just a few dollars, anyone can purchase her own “.com” domain name