12

Useful tips for the management of libraries in times of change

Abstract.

Analyses of the case studies of this research project led to useful tips for the management of libraries in times of change. These range from seizing opportunities that emerge from a deliberate large-scale change, communication rules, the careful handling of people affected by the change, the adoption of professional change management, the chance to learn throughout a change process, the importance of the correct scheduling of a change project, and the realisation and acceptance of things that can’t be changed.

Keywords

change management

communication

learning

non-changeable aspects

opportunities

people

scheduling

12.1 Opportunities during the change process

There are a lot of opportunities during a change process that should be seized and used for the completion of the ongoing change process as well as for any further change projects.

image It is possible and important to search for opportunities even in threatening change situations and to communicate these to the team members who are affected by these alterations. One example may be encouraging staff to work from home during major construction work at the library.1

image The top management as well as the middle management should ask the staff for their opinions and ideas about the expected changes so that they have the opportunity to use their knowledge as experts in their jobs.

image If team members are really unhappy about a situation or a step in the change process and think that it isn’t possible to fulfil this task then – assuming a good leadership style – they will articulate their reservations. This gives a good opportunity for reactions.

image Resistance to new methods of leadership can be reduced through pilot projects with leaders and team members.

image Discussions with working groups can be used to find out if some of the members of the staff affected by a major change can be appointed as change agents.

image Why not try out mixed working groups with members from each hierarchical level and different teams and departments?

image A lot of official opening hours in libraries are nowadays carried out by student assistants. It might therefore be important to integrate them into the change process so that problems that arise during these hours and any new needs of users which might then be articulated can be accounted for.

image By means such as a ceremony to bury an old culture where all team members write down something on a piece of paper and put this into a treasure chest to be shut away it is possible to get rid of aspects of the old culture that are not needed or wanted any more.

image Another possibility is to hold a mourning session with the aid of an expert in psychology. During such a session all members of staff write down their feelings about the changes and what they think they are losing as well as ideas for the future of their library, their own tasks and their career.

image New names can be helpful in creating a new identity. For example, a major change project can be accompanied by the change of old job titles and departmental names and teams to modern names and titles.

image The first step after a major change which has affected users enormously can be an opinion card to ask them about their satisfaction with the change and the alterations in their library.

image This should be followed by a survey which includes the users that are no longer coming to the library.

12.2 Communication – say it loud and clear

It is not possible to successfully complete a change project without a lot of communication.2 Therefore the communication process – who, when, to whom and by what methods – should be planned thoroughly in advance. Below is listed advice to help effective communication with the people who are affected by a deliberate large-scale change.

image It is helpful to plan beforehand what needs to be said, to whom and when.

image The communication plan should include part-time members of staff. If they cannot attend official meetings they should get several opportunities to meet with their superior at a time which is convenient to them.

image Throughout the entire change process it should be clear for everybody why it needs to be done. The purpose of the major change as well as the long-term benefits need to be explained.

image If no one needs to be dismissed because of the change it is important to make this clear to everybody at an early stage.

image If there are constraints that no one can change, it is best to say so.

image Alternatives to the change project should be outlined, especially if these indicate that a less desirable future might be the result or that there might be more work during the change process as well as afterwards.

image If there are concerns throughout the change process the leader or the top management should not hide them. It can sometimes be of help for the team members to see that their leader or even the top management do not look at everything through ‘rose-tinted spectacles’ but question things.

image If a project group is set up for the entire duration of a change process the minutes of the meetings should made public for everyone through email or intranet, or a notice board if not everyone in the library has access to the intranet.

image The communication process should include the users of the library as well as the parent institution or the government. These should not be forgotten in times of change.

12.3 There are people working in the team(s) or department(s) affected by a deliberate large-scale change

It doesn’t matter what kind of major change takes place, whether it is a technological or an organisational change, there are always people involved in the process and people have to be handled carefully during the entire change project.

Everyone – leaders as well as team members – will act differently in times of change than in times when they are working in familiar and safe conditions. This very often leads to anxieties and also to resistance to change.3

image It should be clear and never forgotten that it is not possible to change something in the organisation reasonably without the consent of the people working in that organisation.

image If possible, promises should never be broken, because this will be remembered in the organisation for a very long time.

image People are usually capable of working under pressure longer than one would think, but nevertheless during a change process they need breaks. It is helpful in a change project to give team members the time to do their routine jobs and the chance to recover from everything concerning the change process. Furthermore, everybody needs time for recreation.

image Usually it is not just the leader’s own team members involved in a change process. Other departments should never be forgotten or – worse – ignored by those leaders.

image The top management should also never be forgotten. A leader has to include his or her superior in the decisions, or at least inform the superior of new ideas and aspects of the change project.

image Team members should be rewarded for helping the leader through the change process. This should be done throughout the process and after bringing the change project to a good ending. The reward does not need to be something big.

image Successful changes should always be celebrated by those team members and leaders that took an interest in the change project and those that were affected by it. It doesn’t have to be something expensive or out of the ordinary. An invitation from the leader to a joint breakfast with the staff affected by the change process shows the leader’s appreciation. In addition a party to celebrate the success sponsored by the top management can be a good ending to a major change project. To celebrate it is even possible to ask team members if they would like to make donations such as cakes or ice cream, as in the change project described in section 6.2.1.

12.4 Change management

As can be seen in the case studies and from the change theory as well as the new aspects of leadership discussed in earlier chapters, major changes (and sometimes also smaller changes, if these lead to anxieties and worries) need professional change management.

image The managers at all levels who are the ‘true change managers’4 with responsibility in the end for the final decision should have competences in the various methods of change management.

image It helps to give the change a project motto, as for example was done in the change process described in section 8.2 ‘Under Full Sails’. To bring everybody together at the beginning of a change project, a competition for the best idea for a motto can be announced.

image To prioritise and organise change projects, project management needs to be established as a management method.

image Project management means to implement project groups in every change project where team leaders that are involved in the change process are represented. The top management should be represented in the steering committee.

image It might be helpful if the project group continued after the change process and met on a regular basis with a defined purpose.5 This group should be put together using voluntary members of the staff of the library and it might be useful if the membership rotated.

image If the library has a mission statement, the change process should be based on its contents. This is especially important for aspects such as how to communicate and everything concerning the relationship between leaders and their team members, such as information transfer or delegation of tasks.

image Lower or middle management leaders need to have a direct contact for questions concerning leadership style, organisational culture and management inside the organisation or help from external coaches.

image If there are district libraries, departments, teams or single persons who are willing to try out something new it is essential to win these over for pilot projects.

image The roll-out of a new management method is easier if members of the staff are trained to support their colleagues in terms of ‘learning on equal terms’.

image Sometimes it can be helpful to ask external consultants for support as good change management means also to know who can help us through our change process and to recognise when such help is needed.

image It’s essential never to ignore or forget to include the works council. For example, in Germany the works council has various participation rights, such as the right to be informed about change activities, the right to consult the management during change processes and co-determination rights.6

image It is sometimes helpful to bring the works council in on some decisions, even if it doesn’t need to be agreed on by the works council by law, because some decisions taken by the top management alone might not be carried jointly by all members of the staff.

12.5 Learning throughout the change process

Every change project leads to a learning process in the library. This includes top management and leaders of the middle and lower management as well as team members.

image Reflection and feedback are important for learning during and after every change process.

image The implementation of a management circle gives leaders at all levels the opportunity to discuss leadership aspects on a regular basis and learn from each other.

image Coaching helps leaders to better undertake changes with their team members.

image Mentoring programmes can also help leaders to fulfil the requirements arising from a deliberate large-scale change.

image Team coaching helps team leaders in critical situations within the team or between teams.

image Informal discussion sessions in which all or just the affected leaders of a library participate can be helpful not only during major changes in the library, but also afterwards. These may be accomplished with the help of someone neutral leading the discussions, for example someone from the parent institution’s personnel management.

image If necessary, a moderated conflict resolution meeting should be offered and organised. It should be ensured that it will be repeated after a while.

image If the change process affects team members directly, they should be supported through specific training.

image Training courses for team leaders should also be offered.

image Before beginning a deliberate large-scale change project it should be ensured that there is at least some budgetary provision to finance training courses for those team members and team leaders affected by the changes.

image It is helpful to ask others what they have done – no leader should be too cautious to adopt good ideas from other libraries. Those who have implemented the same alterations and modifications might be seen as experts and asked for advice. Best practices can help to avoid mistakes in the planning of and during the change process.

image It is helpful to introduce a leadership development programme which includes not only aspects of change management, but which also enhances other skills needed in times of change, such as management by delegation, management by objectives, conflict management, etc.

image It is possible to learn from every change project so that change becomes routine for the leaders. As a result the self-composure of the leaders may increase so that they are able to carry out a more explicit and determined course of action from change project to change project.

image A lot can be learned about a change project once it is accomplished through an employee survey with questions on the change project. In this way every member of staff has the chance to evaluate the change management process in the deliberate large-scale change in the library.

12.6 Scheduling

Scheduling and timing are important for everything that needs to be transformed and changed in a library. There is only a certain amount of working time that can be mobilised for and invested in deliberate large-scale changes.

image It is important never to do too much at the same time. There should always be a fair balance between the goals of the organisation and the possibilities of the staff. It is often better to take small steps instead of making big leaps forward that no one can follow.

image On the other hand it is essential that top management and leaders don’t hesitate too long! If something needs to be done they shouldn’t wait too long to get started. Top management as well as leaders should not only talk about the future, but start creating tomorrow today.

image Change projects in libraries are often planned with too narrow a time schedule, particularly if unexpected alterations (mostly from the outside) arise during the change process. In such circumstances the scheduled time for change projects quite often needs to be prolonged. If time is running out leaders should try to keep calm and carry on.

image Not everything works perfectly as planned after the change project is officially completed. It often needs a lot of communication afterwards as well as participation.7 This should be considered in the scheduling.

12.7 Things that can’t be changed

As does every public institution, libraries have to work under many constraints (such as budget and staff) and within the requirements of the government. This implies that there are often things that can’t be altered throughout a change process, even if the library’s management would like to. This needs to be realised and accepted by the management team as well as every member of staff.

image It is important to realise that some conditions can’t be altered during the change process. In Germany, for example, performance-related pay based on management by objectives with the remuneration of the team members depending on the goals they have reached is still in its infancy. One problem in non-profit organisations is that only marginal rewards and bonuses can be given to the library staff. Another problem is that staff reports in nonprofit organisations and public service do not often go into great individual detail: everyone seems to be as good or as average as everyone else.8

image If the alterations have a significant effect on some members of the staff, these alterations should be handled very carefully. One example is the merger of libraries, departments or teams resulting in a reduction in management positions. Generally speaking not every manager is going to retire quite so soon. In this case the advertisement of the post as well as the decision to appoint one of the previous leaders should be handled very carefully. One approach can be seen in section 5.1. In this library the new management position was only advertised in-house and even then was not open to everyone: only those leaders affected by the merger could apply for this position. The advertisement followed common procedure with interviews being conducted, but the committee members interviewed the candidates not just once but twice to be sure of their decision.

image Sometimes more than one change project has to be handled at the same time as a result of external pressure. Handling multiple change projects might raise worries about asking too much of the team members.

image Those who do not want to support the change process – often the team members whose work is generally inefficient – may have a higher rate of sick leave throughout the change process. This can’t be changed, but it can be seen in a positive light in that they do not hold up or hinder the process.

image Sometimes it helps – even if this is not the best possible way – to sit something out. Often team members that are very unhappy about the alterations in their teams or their tasks apply for other jobs or positions and move to another activity area during the change project or a relatively short time after it is completed.


1.This has happened, for example, in an academic library in the USA (see section 6.2.2).

2.This can be seen in every case of major change described in this book.

3.As can be seen in most of the deliberate large-scale change projects described in this book.

4.See also section 10.1.5.

5.As can be seen, for example, in the case study in section 5.2, where the quality management group is still working and meeting on a regular basis.

6.For example, written down in the HmbPersVG § 86 ‘Mitbestimmung’ and § 87 ‘Eingeschränkte Mitbestimmung und sonstige Beteiligung’.

7.This can be seen in the case study in section 5.2, where for example the quality manual is still in progress. But even with such a highly visible and widely promoted management tool it happens that it isn’t used as planned. In this case, even after two years, it is still a learning process for team members as well as leaders to use this tool.

8.One leader in a university library, for example, related the impossibility of making performance-related payments as there is only one ‘pot’ for the entire university. Because the other members of the university want their staff to get some extra payments, they give them the best possible evaluation. This makes it impossible to rank the library members of staff as some might not get anything while the university’s other members of staff might get it all. This would be – in the opinion of this leader – unfair as he rates his members of staff higher than others in the university.

..................Content has been hidden....................

You can't read the all page of ebook, please click here login for view all page.
Reset
3.146.178.165