Applying a Client-Centered Value Strategy ◾ 85
Perspective 1: The Generalist and the Specialist
“To be a generalist or a specialist, that is the question.”
The dichotomy between the generalist and the specialist represents a
common dilemma at the heart of consulting. You find specialists at all lev-
els of the corporate structure: industrial engineers, financial analysts, and
experts in a variety of disciplines. The management consultant, however, is
not understood to have a comparable specialization.
The argument runs that generalists lack the in-depth knowledge required
to fully understand and resolve problems, and provide little added value to
the client business. Your clients will add fuel to this debate by implicitly or
explicitly expecting that you be both a generalist and a specialist. The reality
is that the strategic objectives of an organization in this fast-changing world
require both generalists and specialists or a combination thereof.
For the consultant, the dilemma is that the more specialized your
approach, the more difficult it is to obtain sufficient business, and the more
generalist your approach, the less credibility you carry in the eyes of your
client. The Odyssey consultant’s position is as a generalist, but as a specialist
within a niche market.
Specialist or technical consultants tend to focus on business processes,
structures, systems, and technology in areas such as production, construction,
legal, finance, and accounting. The generalists tend to focus on the human side
of organizations, such as personal development, cultural change, strategic lead-
ership, and energizing and empowering people to performance improvement.
Although you may be a generalist in your field, your clients need to
perceive and believe that you are a specialist in their area of need. Imagine
yourself as a zoom lens, capable of taking the broad approach but retain-
ing the ability to zero in on your own particular area of competency and
the specific need of the client sitting in front of you. In a generalist posi-
tion, the consultant initiates the Odyssey Arrow and recommends a variety
of solutions, some of which may require other niche consultant expertise.
You become the coordinating consultant. For example, you might consult on
human resource matters, but bring in a finance or technology consultant to
implement other Recommendations.
Perspective 2: Business or Profession?
Is consulting a business or is it more accurately described as a profes-
sional service? Disciplines like medicine, law, accounting, and engineering