1

CONTROL SYSTEM MODELING

1.1 Introduction

A system is a combination of components connected to perform a required action. The control component of a system plays a major role in altering or maintaining the system output based on our desired characteristics. There are two types of control systems: manual control and automatic control. For example, in manual control, a man can switch on or switch off the bore well motor to control the level of water in a tank. On the other hand, in automatic control, level switches and transducers are used to control the level of water in a tank.

Control systems have naturally evolved in our ecosystem. In almost all living things, automatic control regulates the conditions necessary for life by tackling the disturbance through sensing and controlling functionalities. They operate complex systems and processes and achieve control with desired precision. The application of control systems facilitates automated manufacturing processes, accurate positioning and effective control of machine tools. They guide and control space vehicles, aircrafts, ships and high-speed ground transportation systems. Modern automation of a plant involves components such as sensors, instruments, computers and application of techniques that involve data processing and control.

It is essential to understand a system and its characteristics with the help of a model, before creating a control for it. The process of developing a model is known as modeling. Physical systems are modeled by applying notable laws that govern their behaviour. For example, mechanical systems are described by Newton's laws and electrical systems are described by Ohm's law, Kirchhoff's law, Faraday's and Lenz's law. These laws form the basis for the constitutive properties of the elements in a system.

1.2 Classification of Control System

Control systems are generally classified as (i) open-loop control systems and (ii) closed-loop control systems as shown in Fig. 1.1.

C01F001

Fig. 1.1 ∣ Classification of control systems

1.2.1 Open-Loop Control System

A control system that cannot adjust itself to the changes is called open-loop control system. In general, manual control systems are open-loop systems. The block diagram of open-loop control system is shown in Fig.1.2.

C01F002

Fig. 1.2 ∣ Block diagram of an open-loop control system

Here, Eqn1 is the input signal, Eqn2 is the control signal/actuating signal and Eqn3 is the output signal.

In this system, the output remains unaltered for a constant input. In case of any discrepancy, the input should be manually changed by an operator. An open-loop control system is suited when there is tolerance for fluctuation in the system and when the system parameter variation can be handled irrespective of the environmental conditions.

In olden days, air conditioners were fitted with regulators that were manually controlled to maintain the desired temperature. This real-time system serves as an open-loop control system as shown in Fig.1.3.

C01F003

Fig. 1.3 ∣ Open-loop control system of an air conditioner

1.2.2 Closed-Loop Control System

Any system that can respond to the changes and make corrections by itself is known as closed-loop control system. The only difference between open-loop and closed-loop systems is the feedback action. The block diagram of a closed-loop control system is shown in Fig.1.4.

C01F004

Fig. 1.4 ∣ Block diagram of closed-loop control system

Here, Eqn5 is the input signal, Eqn11 is the error signal/actuating signal, Eqn12 or m(t) is the control signal/manipulated signal, b(t) is the feedback signal and Eqn3 is the controlled output.

Here, the output of the machine is fed back to a comparator (error detector). The output signal is compared with the reference input Eqn10 and the error signal Eqn11 is sent to the controller. Based on the error, the controller adjusts the air conditioners input [control signal Eqn12]. This process is continued till the error gets nullified. Both manual and automatic controls can be implemented in a closed-loop system. The overall gain of a system is reduced due to the presence of feedback. In order to compensate for the reduction of gain, if an amplifier is introduced to increase the gain of a system, the system may sometimes become unstable.

Present-day air conditioners are designed with temperature sensors, comparators and controller modules. The reference temperature (the desired room temperature) is fed and compared with actual room temperature, which is sensed by a temperature sensor. The difference between these two values, i.e., the error signal is fed to a controller and the controller performs the necessary action to minimize the error. The block diagram for this example is shown in Fig.1.5.

C01F005

Fig. 1.5 ∣ Closed-loop control system of an air conditioner

A person driving a car is also an example for a closed-loop control system as shown in Fig.1.6. During the ride, the brain controls the hands for steering, gear, horn and the legs for brake and accelerator so as to perform the driving in a perfect manner. The eyes and the ears form the feedback, i.e., eyes for determining the pathway and mirror view and ears for sensing other vehicles nearby. The driver also accelerates or decelerates depending on the terrain and traffic involved.

C01F006

Fig. 1.6 ∣ Closed-loop system of a driver controlled car

1.3 Comparison of Open-Loop and Closed-Loop Control Systems

Table 1.1 discusses the comparison of open-loop and closed-loop control systems.

Table 1.1 ∣ Comparison of open-loop and closed-loop control systems

tbl1

1.4 Differential Equations and Transfer Functions

For the analysis and design of a system, a mathematical model that describes its behaviour is required. The process of obtaining the mathematical description of a system is known as modeling. The differential equations for a given system are obtained by applying appropriate laws, for example, Newton's laws for mechanical systems and Kirchhoff's law for electrical systems. These equations may be either linear or non-linear based on the system being modeled. Therefore, deriving appropriate mathematical models is the most important part of the analysis of a system.

A system is said to be linear if it obeys the principles of superposition and homogeneity. If a system has responses Eqn13 and Eqn14 for any two inputs Eqn15 and Eqn16 respectively, then the system response to the linear combination of these inputs Eqn17 is given by the linear combination of the individual outputs Eqn18, where Eqn19 and Eqn20 are constants. The principle of homogeneity and superposition is explained in Fig. 1.7.

C01F007

Fig. 1.7 ∣ Principle of homogeneity and superposition

If the coefficients of the differential equations are functions of time (an independent variable), then a system is called linear time-varying system. On the other hand, if the coefficients of the differential equations are not a function of time, then a system is called linear time-invariant system. For the transient-response or frequency-response analysis of single-input and single-output linear time-invariant system, the transfer function representation will be a convenient tool. But, if a system is subjected to multi-input and multi-output, then state-space analysis will be a convenient tool.

1.4.1 Transfer Function Representation

The transfer function of a linear, time-invariant, differential equation system is given by the ratio of Laplace transform of output variable (response function) to the Laplace transform of the input variable (driving function) under the assumption that all initial conditions are zero.

Transfer function, Eqn21 at zero initial conditions.

It is to be noted that non-linear systems and time-varying systems do not have transfer functions because they do not obey the principles of superposition and homogeneity. With the concept of transfer functions, it is possible to represent system dynamics by algebraic equations in Eqn22 domain. The highest power of Eqn23 in the denominator of a transfer function is the order of the system.

1.4.2 Features and Advantages of Transfer Function Representation

The following are the features and advantages of transfer function representation:

  1. Using transfer functions, mathematical models can be obtained and analyzed.
  2. Output response can be obtained for any kind of inputs.
  3. Stability analysis can be performed.
  4. The usage of Laplace transform converts complex time domain equations to simple algebraic equations, expressed with complex variable s.
  5. Analysis of a system is simplified due to the use of s-domain variable in the equations, rather than using time-domain variable.

1.4.3 Disadvantages of Transfer Function Representation

The following are the disadvantages of transfer function representation:

  1. It is not applicable to non-linear systems or time-varying systems.
  2. Initial conditions are neglected.
  3. Physical nature of a system cannot be found (i.e., whether it is mechanical or electrical or thermal system).

1.4.4 Transfer Function of an Open-Loop System

In the block diagram of a system relating its input and output as shown in Fig.1.8, there exists an input (excitation) which operates through a transfer operator called transfer function and it produces an output (response).

C01F008

Fig. 1.8 ∣ Block diagram representation of an open-loop transfer function

From the block diagram representation of an open-loop transfer function, we have

Eqn24

where Eqn25 is the Laplace transform of the input variable or excitation, C(s) is the Laplace transform of the output variable or response and Eqn28 is the transfer function.

1.4.5 Transfer Function of a Closed-Loop System

Closed-loop control systems can be classified into two categories, based on the type of feedback signal as (i) Negative feedback systems and (ii) Positive feedback systems.

(i) Negative Feedback Systems

The simplest form of a negative-feedback control system is shown in Fig. 1.9. It has one block in the forward path and one in the feedback path.

C01F009

Fig. 1.9 ∣ Block diagram representation of negative feedback control system

Practically, all control systems can be reduced to this form. Eqn28 represents the overall gain of the blocks in the forward path, Eqn29 is the feedback signal, Eqn30 is the error signal and Eqn31 represents the overall gain of all the blocks in the feedback path.

The objective is to reduce this control system to a single block by determining the closed-loop transfer function (CLTF) for the negative feedback.

The following relationships can be derived from the block diagram:

Feedback signal, B(s) = output Eqn32 feedback path gain

Eqn33(1.1)

Error signal, Eqn34 = input signal − feedback signal

Eqn35 = Eqn36

Substituting Eqn. (1.1) in the above equation, we obtain

Eqn37(1.2)

Output signal, Eqn38

Eqn39(1.3)

Substituting the value of the error signal, we obtain

Eqn40

Eqn41

Eqn42

Eqn43

Hence, the transfer function of the negative feedback control system is given by

Eqn44(1.4)

Based on the above expression, Fig. 1.9 is reduced to the simplified form as shown in Fig. 1.10.

C01F010

Fig. 1.10 ∣ Reduced form of a negative feedback control system

Thus, the closed-loop transfer function is

T(s) = Eqn45 Eqn46

Hence, the output, Eqn47 = closed-loop transfer function T(s) Eqn48 input Eqn49.

Observations drawn from this relationship are:

  1. The control system transfer function is a property of the system.
  2. The transfer function is dependent only on its internal structure and components.
  3. The transfer function is independent of the input applied to a system.
  4. When an input signal is applied to a closed-loop control system, an output is generated; i.e., it is dependent on the input as well as the system transfer function.

(ii) Positive Feedback Systems

If the feedback is positive, then the closed-loop transfer function can be similarly derived as

Eqn51(1.5)

The block diagram representing positive feedback control system is shown in Fig. 1.11.

C01F011

Fig. 1.11 ∣ Block diagram representation of positive feedback control system

1.4.6 Comparison of Positive Feedback and Negative Feedback Systems

Table 1.2 discusses the comparison of characteristics between positive feedback and negative feedback systems.

Table 1.2 ∣ Characteristics of positive feedback and negative feedback systems

tbl2

Example 1.1: A negative feedback system has a forward gain of 10 and feedback gain of 1. Determine the overall gain of the system.

Solution: Given the forward gain Eqn52 and the feedback gain Eqn53

The overall gain of a closed-loop system is same as its closed-loop transfer function. For a negative feedback system, the transfer function is given by

Eqn54

Substituting the values of Eqn55 and Eqn56, we obtain overall gain of a closed-loop system,

Eqn57.

Example 1.2: A negative feedback system with a forward gain of 2 and a feedback gain of 8 is subjected to an input of 5 V. Determine the output voltage of the system.

Solution: Given the forward gain Eqn58, feedback gain Eqn59 and input Eqn60.

Output voltage for any system is given by

Eqn61 = Transfer function of the closed-loop system Eqn62 input Eqn63

The transfer function of the closed-loop system with negative feedback is given by

Eqn65

Substituting the values of Eqn66 and Eqn67, we obtain

Eqn68

Therefore, the output voltage of the given system Eqn69.

Example 1.3: A positive feedback system was subjected to an input of 3 V. Determine the output voltage of the following sets of gains:

  1. Eqn94, Eqn95
  2. Eqn96, Eqn97
  3. Eqn98, Eqn99
  4. Eqn100, Eqn101
  5. Eqn102, Eqn103
  6. Eqn104, Eqn105

Solution: It is known that Eqn106

Eqn107

The output voltage Eqn108 for different cases can be obtained by substituting the different values of Eqn109, Eqn110 and Eqn111.

  1. When Eqn112 = 1, Eqn113 = 0.75 and Eqn114 = 3 V,

    Eqn115

  2. When Eqn116 and Eqn117,

    Eqn118

  3. When Eqn119 and Eqn120

    Eqn121

  4. When Eqn122 and Eqn123

    Eqn124

  5. When Eqn125 and Eqn126

    Eqn127

  6. When Eqn128 and Eqn129

    Eqn130

It can be noted that, the output becomes very large and approaches infinity when the loop gain approaches a value of 1, i.e., Eqn131.

1.5 Mathematical Modeling

The process involved in modeling a system using mathematical equations, formed by the variables and constants of the system is called the mathematical modeling of a system. For example, an electrical network can be modeled using the equations formed by Kirchhoff's laws.

Fig 1.12 shows a flow chart for determining the transfer function of any system.

C01F012

Fig. 1.12 ∣ Flow chart for deriving the transfer function

1.5.1 Mathematical Equations for Problem Solving

Basic Laplace transform of different functions are

Eqn138

Eqn139

Eqn140

Cramer's rule:

For a given pair of simultaneous equations, we have

Eqn141

Eqn142

The above equations can be written in matrix form as

Eqn143

Therefore,

Eqn144Eqn145 and Eqn146Eqn147

where Eqn148Eqn149 and Eqn150.

1.6 Modeling of Electrical Systems

An electrical system consists of resistors, capacitors and inductors. The differential equations of electrical systems can be formed by applying Kirchhoff's laws. The transfer function can be obtained by taking Laplace transform of the integro-differential equations and rearranging them as a ratio of output to input. The relationship between voltage and current for different elements in the electrical circuit is given in Table 1.3.

Table 1.3 ∣ Relationship of voltage and current for R, L and C

tbl3

Example 1.4: A rotary potentiometer is being used as an angular position transducer. It has a rotational range of 0°–300° and the corresponding output voltage is 15 V. The potentiometer is linear over the entire operating range. Determine its transfer function.

Solution: Given output voltage = 15 V and input rotation = 300°

The transfer function of the potentiometer Eqn157 is given by

Eqn158

Substituting the given values, we obtain

Eqn159

Example 1.5: Determine the transfer function of the electrical network shown in Fig. E1.5.

C0E1F009

Fig. E1.5

Solution: The output voltage across the capacitor is Eqn167

Applying Kirchhoff's voltage law, the loop equation is given by

Eqn168

Taking Laplace transform of the above equations, we obtain

Eqn169(1)

Eqn170

Simplifying the above equation, we obtain

Eqn171(2)

Substituting Eqn. (2) in Eqn. (1), we obtain

Eqn172

Hence, the transfer function of the system is given by

Eqn173

Example 1.6: Determine the transfer function of the electrical network shown in Fig. E1.6(a).

C0E1F010a

Fig. E1.6(a)

Solution: In the given circuit, there exist two impedances Eqn174 as shown in Fig. E1.6(b).

C0E1F010b

Fig. E1.6(b)

Therefore, Eqn175

Eqn176

Eqn177

Eqn178

The output voltage across the impedance Eqn179 is Eqn180

Applying Kirchhoff's voltage law, the loop equation is given by

Eqn181

Taking Laplace transform of the above equations, we obtain

Eqn182(1)

Eqn183

Simplifying, we obtain

Eqn184(2)

Substituting Eqn. (2) in Eqn. (1), we obtain

Eqn185

Hence, the transfer function of the system is given by

Eqn186

Therefore,

Eqn187

Example 1.7: Determine the transfer function of the electrical network shown in Fig. E1.7.

C0E1F012

Fig. E1.7

Solution: The output voltage of the given electrical network is

Eqn202

Taking Laplace transform, we obtain

Eqn203(1)

The loop equations for each loop can be obtained by applying Kirchhoff's voltage law.

Loop equation for loop (1) is

Eqn204

Taking Laplace transform on both the sides, we obtain

Eqn205(2)

Loop equation for loop (2) is

Eqn206

Taking Laplace transform, we obtain

Eqn207(3)

Representing Eqn. (2) and Eqn. (3) in matrix form,

Eqn208

Applying Cramer's rule, we obtain

Eqn209

where Eqn210

and Eqn211

Eqn212

Eqn213

Therefore,

Eqn214

But, Eqn215 Eqn216

Hence, the overall transfer function of the given electrical system is given by

Eqn217

Example 1.8: Determine the transfer function of the electrical network shown in Fig. E1.8(a).

C0E1F013a

Fig. E1.8(a)

Solution: The above electrical network can be modified as shown in Fig. E1.8(b).

C0E1F013b

Fig. E1.8(b)

The output voltage of the given electrical circuit is

Eqn218

Applying Laplace transform, we obtain

Eqn219Eqn220(1)

Applying Laplace transform, we obtain transformation of the parallel RC circuit as shown in Fig. E1.8(c).

C0E1F013c

Fig. E1.8(c)

Thus, the given electrical circuit is re-drawn as shown in Fig. E1.8(d).

C0E1F013d

Fig. E1.8(d)

Now, Kirchhoff's voltage law is applied to the individual loops for the above electrical circuit.

Then the equation for loop (1) is

Eqn221

Eqn222

Eqn223

Eqn224

Eqn225(2)

Loop equation for loop (2) is

Eqn226

Eqn227

Eqn228(3)

The Eqn. (2) and Eqn. (3) are written in matrix form as

Eqn229

Applying Cramer's rule, we obtain

Eqn230

Eqn231

Eqn232

Eqn233(4)

Substituting Eqn. (4) in Eqn. (1), we obtain

Eqn234

Eqn235

Thus, the overall transfer function is

Eqn236

1.7 Modeling of Mechanical Systems

The dimensions in which the movement of a mechanical system can be described are translational, rotational or a combination of both. For modeling of mechanical system, it is necessary to have the equations governing the movement of mechanical systems. The laws that are used directly or indirectly to formulate those equations are obtained from Newton's laws of motion.

The general classification of mechanical system is of two types: (i) translational and (ii) rotational as shown in Fig. 1.13.

C01F013

Fig. 1.13 ∣ Classification of mechanical system

1.7.1 Translational Mechanical System

The modeling of linear passive translational mechanical system can be obtained by using three basic elements: mass, spring and damper. The mass that is concentrated at the center of a system is used to represent the weight of a given mechanical system, whereas the spring is used to represent the elastic deformation of the body and the damper is used to represent the friction existing in a mechanical system. An example of such linear passive translational mechanical system is the suspension system existing in the automobiles (such as car, van, etc.). For the analysis of linear passive translational mechanical system, it is assumed that the elements are purely linear.

The opposing forces due to mass, friction and spring act on a system when the system is subjected to a force. Using D'Alembert's principle, for a linear passive translational mechanical system, the sum of forces acting on a body is zero (i.e., the sum of applied forces is equal to the sum of the opposing forces on a body). Displacement, velocity and acceleration are the variables used to describe the linear passive translation mechanical system.

In translational mechanical systems, the energy storage elements are mass and spring and the element that dissipates energy is viscous damper. The analogous elements for energy storage in an electrical circuit are inductors and capacitors, whereas those of the energy dissipating element are resistors.

Inertia Force Eqn237

The element that stores the kinetic energy of translational mechanical system is mass. Mass is considered to be a conservative element, as the energy can be stored and retrieved without loss.

When a force Eqn238 is applied to a mass M, it experiences an acceleration and it is shown in Fig. 1.14.

C01F014

Fig. 1.14 ∣ Mass element

According to Newton's second law, the force experienced by the mass is proportional to the acceleration.

Eqn239

Eqn240

Eqn241

Eqn242

where M is the mass (kg), a is the acceleration (m/s2), Eqn243 is the velocity (m/s) and Eqn244 is the displacement (m).

Eqn245

Here, Eqn246 is measured in Newton (N) or Kg-m/s2.

Damper

The damping that is desirable in the motion for a mechanical system is provided by an element called damper. A frictional force that exists between one or two physical systems when there exists a movement or a tendency of movement between them. The characteristics of frictional forces that are non-linear in nature depends on the composition of the surfaces, the pressure between the surfaces, their relative velocity and others that add difficulty in obtaining the mathematical description of the frictional force. The different types of frictions that are commonly used in practical system are viscous friction, static friction and coulomb friction in which the viscous friction is commonly found in a translational mechanical system.

Static Friction or Stiction

The retarding force Eqn247 which tends to prevent the motion is known as static friction or stiction. This type of frictional force exists only when the body is not in motion (stationary), but has the tendency to move. The sign or direction of static friction is opposite to the direction in which the body tends to move or initial direction of the velocity. This frictional force vanishes once the movement of a system is started.

Viscous Friction

The retarding force that is experienced by a system when it is in motion is known as viscous friction. This type of friction exists between a system and a fluid medium. There exists a linear relationship between the applied force and the velocity. Hence, this frictional forceEqn248 is proportional to the velocity of the movement of a system.

Eqn249

This frictional force that is more common in a mechanical system is represented by a dashpot or a damper system. When a force is applied to a damping element B, it experiences a velocity and it is shown in Fig. 1.15(a).

C01F015a

Fig. 1.15 ∣ (a) Dash-pot or Damper element

Eqn250

Eqn251

where Eqn252 is the viscous friction coefficient (N-s/m), Eqn253 is the velocity (m/s) and Eqn254 is the displacement (m).

Dashpot or damper element with two displacements is shown in Fig. 1.15(b).

C01F015b

Fig. 1.15 ∣ (b) Dash-pot or Damper element with different displacements

Eqn255

Eqn256

Here, Eqn257 is measured in Newton (N) or Kg-m/s2.

Coulomb Friction

The retarding force Eqn258 which is experienced by the system (dry surfaces) when it is in motion is known as coulomb friction. The coulomb friction is similar to the viscous friction, but the coulomb friction has constant amplitude with respect to the change in velocity, but the sign/direction of the frictional force depends on the direction of velocity.

The relationship between the different frictional forces and velocity of the direction of motion is given in Figs. 1.16(a) through (c).

C01F016

Fig. 1.16 ∣ Frictional force versus velocity

Spring Force Eqn259

In general, an element that stores potential energy in a system is known as spring. The analogous component of spring in an electrical circuit is the capacitor that is used to store voltages. In real time, the springs are non-linear in nature. However, if the spring deformation is small, the behaviour of the spring can be approximated by a linear relationship. The opposing force developed by the spring is directly related to the stiffness of the spring and the total displacement of the spring from its equilibrium position.

When a force Eqn260 is applied to a spring element K, it experiences a displacement and it is shown in Fig. 1.17.

C01F017

Fig. 1.17 ∣ Spring element

According to Hooke's law, the spring force is directly proportional to the displacement:

Eqn261

The spring stores the potential energy. Therefore,

Eqn262

Velocity, Eqn263

Eqn264

Integrating the above equation, we obtain

Eqn265

Therefore, Eqn266

where K is the spring constant (N/m), i.e., Eqn267 , Eqn268 is the velocity (m/s) and Eqn269 is the displacement (m).

Spring element with two displacements is shown in Fig. 1.18.

C01F018

Fig. 1.18 ∣ Spring element with two displacements

Eqn270

Eqn271

Eqn272

Here, Eqn273 is measured in Newton (N) or Kg-m/s2.

1.7.2 A Simple Translational Mechanical System

According to D'Alembert's principle, “The algebraic sum of the externally applied forces to any body is equal to the algebraic sum of the opposing forces restraining motion produced by the elements present in the body.”

A simple translational mechanical system with all the basic elements and its free body diagram are shown in Figs. 1.19 (a) and (b) respectively.

C01F019a

Fig. 1.19 ∣ (a) A simple translational mechanical system

C01F019b

Fig. 1.19 ∣ (b) Free body diagram

Let Eqn274 be the external force applied to the given system,

Eqn275 be the opposing force produced by the element mass M,

Eqn276 be the opposing force produced by the element damper B and

Eqn277 be the opposing force produced by the element spring K.

Using D'Alembert's principle,

Eqn278

Eqn279

The above equation is referred to as D'Alembert's basic equation for translational mechanical systems.

Example 1.9: For the mechanical translational system shown in Fig. E1.9, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function of the system.

C0E1F014

Fig. E1.9

Solution: For the system given in Fig. E1.9, the input is Eqn280 and the outputs are Eqn281 and Eqn282.

Using D' Alembert's principle for the mass Eqn283, we obtain

Eqn284

Eqn285(1)

For the mass Eqn286 , we obtain

Eqn287

Eqn288(2)

Taking Laplace transform of Eqn. (1) and Eqn. (2), we obtain

Eqn289

Eqn290

Representing the above equations in matrix form,

Eqn291

Using Cramer's rule, we obtain

Eqn292

Eqn293 Eqn294

Eqn295 Eqn296

Eqn297 Eqn298

Eqn299

Therefore, Eqn300 Eqn301

and Eqn302 Eqn303

Thus, the transfer function of the given mechanical system is given by

Eqn304

Eqn305

where Eqn306

Example 1.10: For the mechanical translational system shown in Fig. E1.10, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function of the system.

C0E1F017

Fig. E1.10

Solution: For the system given in Fig. E1.10, the input is Eqn361 and the outputs are Eqn362 and Eqn363.

Using D' Alembert's principle for the mass Eqn364,

Eqn365

Eqn366

For the mass Eqn367 , Eqn368

Eqn369

Taking Laplace transform of the above equations, we obtain

Eqn370

Eqn371

Representing the above equations in matrix form,

Eqn372

Using Cramer's rule, we obtain

Eqn373

Eqn374 Eqn375

Eqn376 Eqn377

Eqn378 Eqn379

Eqn380

Therefore, Eqn381Eqn382

Eqn383Eqn384

Thus, the transfer functions of the given mechanical system is given by

Eqn385

Eqn386

where Eqn387

Example 1.11: For the mechanical translational system shown in Fig. E1.11, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function of the system.

C0E1F018

Fig. E1.11

Solution: For the system given in Fig. E1.11, the input is Eqn388 and the output is Eqn389

Using D' Alembert's principle for the mass Eqn390

Eqn391

Eqn392

Taking Laplace transform on both the sides, we obtain

Eqn393

Hence, the transfer function of the system is given by

Eqn394

Example 1.12: For the mechanical translational system shown in Fig. E1.12, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function of the system.

C0E1F019

Fig. E1.12

Solution: For the system given in Fig. E1.12, the input is Eqn395 and the outputs are Eqn396 and Eqn397.

Using D' Alembert's principle for the mass Eqn398,

Eqn399

Eqn400

For the mass Eqn401 , Eqn402

Eqn403

Taking Laplace transform of the above equations, we obtain

Eqn404

Eqn405

Representing the above equations in matrix form,

Eqn406

Using Cramer's rule, we obtain

Eqn407

Eqn408 Eqn409

Eqn410 Eqn411

Eqn412 Eqn413

Eqn414

Eqn415

Therefore,

Eqn417 Eqn418

and Eqn419 Eqn420

Thus, the transfer functions of the given mechanical system are given by

Eqn421

where Eqn422

Example 1.13: For the mechanical translational system shown in Fig. E1.13, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function of the system.

C0E1F020

Fig. E1.13

Solution: For the system given in Fig. E1.13, the input is Eqn423 and the output is Eqn424

Using D' Alembert's principle for the mass Eqn425,

Eqn426

Eqn427(1)

Taking Laplace transform on both the sides, we obtain

Eqn428

Hence, the transfer function of the system is given by

Eqn429

Example 1.14: For the mechanical translational system shown in Fig. E1.14, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) Eqn430

C0E1F021

Fig. E1.14

Solution: For the system shown in Fig. E1.14, the inputs are Eqn431 and Eqn432 and the outputs are Eqn433 respectively.

Using D' Alembert's principle for the mass Eqn434, Eqn435

Eqn436

Using D' Alembert's principle for the mass Eqn437 , Eqn438

Eqn439

Taking Laplace transform on both the sides, we obtain

Eqn440

Eqn441

Representing the above equations in matrix form,

Eqn442

Using Cramer's rule, we obtain

Eqn443

Eqn444 Eqn445

Eqn446 Eqn447

Therefore,

Eqn448Eqn449

Eqn450

Laplace transform of the given inputs f1(t) = 10 and f2(t) = 6 sin 5t are

Eqn451Eqn452

Substituting the known values in the above equation, we obtain

Eqn453

Eqn454

Example 1.15: For the mechanical translational system shown in Fig. E1.15, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function of the system.

C0E1F022

Fig. E1.15

Solution: For the system given in Fig. E1.15, the input is Eqn455 and the outputs are Eqn456 and Eqn457.

Using D' Alembert's principle for the mass Eqn458, Eqn459

Eqn460(1)

For the mass Eqn461 , Eqn462

Eqn463(2)

Taking Laplace transform of Eqn. (1) and Eqn. (2), we obtain

Eqn464

Eqn465

Representing the above equations in matrix form,

Eqn466

Using Cramer's rule, we obtain

Eqn467

Eqn468 Eqn469

Eqn470 Eqn471

Eqn472

Eqn473

Therefore,

Eqn474 Eqn475

Eqn476 Eqn477

Thus, the transfer functions of given mechanical system are given by

Eqn478

Eqn479

where Eqn479a

1.7.3 Rotational Mechanical System

The modeling of a linear passive rotational mechanical system can be obtained by using three basic elements: inertia, rotational spring and rotational damper. The modeling of a rotational mechanical system is similar to that of a translational mechanical system except that the elements of the system undergo a rotational instead of a translation movement.

The opposing torques due to inertia, rotational spring and rotational damper act on a system when the system is subjected to a torque. Using D'Alembert's principle, for a linear passive rotational mechanical system, the sum of all the torques acting on a body is zero (i.e., the sum of applied torques is equal to the sum of the opposing torques on a body). Angular displacement, angular velocity and angular acceleration are the variables used to describe a linear passive rotational mechanical system.

In rotational mechanical systems, the energy storage elements are inertia and rotational spring and the energy dissipating element is the rotational viscous damper. The analogous for the energy storage elements in an electrical circuit are the inductors and the capacitors and the analogous of energy dissipating element in an electrical circuit is the resistor.

The analogous of linear passive translational and rotational mechanical system is given in Table. 1.4.

Table 1.4 ∣ Analogous of translational and rotational mechanical system

tbl4

Inertia Torque Eqn485

The element that stores the kinetic energy of a rotational mechanical system is inertia. Inertia is considered to be a conservative element as the energy can be stored and retrieved without any loss. The factors on which the inertial element depends are geometric composition about the rotational axis and its density.

When a torque Eqn486 is applied to an inertia element J, it experiences an angular acceleration and it is shown in Fig. 1.20.

C01F020

Fig. 1.20 ∣ Inertia element

According to Newton's second law, the inertia torque is proportional to the angular acceleration.

Eqn487

Eqn488

Eqn491

where J is the moment of inertia (kg-m2/rad), α is the angular acceleration (rad/s2), ω(t) is the angular velocity (rad/s), θ(t) is the angular displacement (rad) and TJ (t) is measured in Newton-meter (N-m).

Damping Torque Eqn497

The description discussed about the damper in the linear translational mechanical system holds good for the linear rotational mechanical system except for the fact that force is replaced by torque. A damper element is represented by a dashpot system.

When a torque Eqn498 is applied to a damping element B, it experiences an angular velocity and it is shown in Fig. 1.21.

C01F021

Fig. 1.21 ∣ Damper element

The damping torque is proportional to the angular velocity. Therefore,

Eqn499

Eqn500Eqn501

where B is viscous friction coefficient (N-s/m), ω(t) is the angular velocity (rad/s) and θ(t) is the angular displacement (rad).

Damper element with two angular displacements and a single applied torque is shown in Fig. 1.22.

C01F022

Fig. 1.22 ∣ Damper element with two angular displacements

Eqn504

Eqn505

Here, Eqn506 is measured in Newton-meter.

Torsional/rotational Spring Torque Eqn521

In general, an element that stores potential energy in a rotational mechanical system is known as torsional/rotational spring. The analogous component of torsional/rotational spring in an electrical circuit is the capacitor that is used to store voltages. The opposing force developed by the rotational spring is directly related to the stiffness of the torsional/rotational spring and its total angular displacement from its equilibrium position.

When a torque Eqn508 is applied to a spring element K, it experiences an angular displacement and it is shown in Fig. 1.23.

C01F023

Fig. 1.23 ∣ Torsional spring element

According to Hooke's law, spring torque is proportional to the angular displacement.

Eqn509

Eqn510Eqn511

where Eqn512 and Eqn513

where K is the spring constant (N-m/rad), i.e., K = Eqn514Eqn515 is the angular velocity (rad/s) and Eqn516 is the angular displacement (rad).

A spring element with two angular displacements is shown in Fig. 1.24.

C01F024

Fig. 1.24 ∣ Torsional spring element with two angular displacements

Eqn517

Eqn518

Similarly,

Eqn519

Eqn520

Here, Eqn521 is measured in Newton-meter.

1.7.4 A Simple Rotational Mechanical System

According to D'Alembert's principle, “The algebraic sum of the externally applied torques to any body is equal to the algebraic sum of opposing torques restraining motion produced by the elements present in the body.”

A simple rotational mechanical system with all the basic elements and its free body diagram is shown in Fig.1.25 and Fig.1.26 respectively.

C01F025

Fig. 1.25 ∣ A simple rotational mechanical system

C01F026

Fig. 1.26 ∣ Free body diagram

Let Eqn522 be the external torque applied to the given system,

Eqn523 be the opposing torque produced by the element mass J,

Eqn524 be the opposing torque produced by the element damper B and

Eqn525 be the opposing torque produced by the element spring K.

Using D'Alembert's principle, Eqn526

Eqn527

The free body diagram of the system denoting the applied and opposing torques is shown in Fig. 1.26.

Restraining torques are given below:

Inertia torque Eqn528

Damping torque Eqn529

Spring torque Eqn530

Example 1.16: Set up the differential equations for the mechanical system as shown in Fig. E1.16(a). Also, obtain its transfer function Eqn532.

C0E1F024a

Fig. E1.16(a)

Solution: The given mechanical system is modified indicating the various angular displacements as shown in Fig. E1.16(b).

C0E1F024b

Fig. E1.16(b)

Eqn533 is between the angular displacements Eqn534 and Eqn535.

Eqn536 is under the angular displacement Eqn537.

Eqn538 is between the angular displacements Eqn539 and Eqn540.

Eqn541 is between the angular displacements Eqn542 and Eqn543.

Eqn544 and Eqn545 are under the angular displacement Eqn546.

Eqn547 is between the angular displacements Eqn548 and Eqn549.

Eqn550, Eqn551 and Eqn552 are under the angular displacement Eqn553.

The equivalent mechanical system is shown in Fig. E1.16(c).

C0E1F024c

Fig. E1.16(c)

Method 1–Using substitution method

The differential equations are

Eqn554

Eqn555

Eqn556

Eqn557

Eqn558

Taking Laplace transform of the above five equations, we obtain

Eqn559(1)

Eqn560(2)

Eqn561(3)

Eqn562(4)

Eqn563(5)

Using Eqn. (1), we obtain

Eqn564(6)

Using Eqn. (2) and Eqn. (6), we obtain

Eqn565

Rearranging, we obtain

Eqn566

Therefore, Eqn567(7)

where Eqn568

Using Eqs. (3), (6) and (7), we obtain

Eqn569

Therefore, Eqn570(8)

where Eqn571

Using Eqs. (4), (7) and (8), we obtain

Eqn572

Therefore, Eqn573(9)

where Eqn574

Using Eqs. (9) and (8) in Eqn. (5), we obtain

Eqn575

The required transfer function of the given system is

Eqn576

where Eqn577

Eqn578

Eqn579

Eqn580

Eqn581

Eqn582

Eqn583

Eqn584

Method 2–Using Cramer's rule

Writing Eqs. (1) through (5) in matrix form, we obtain

AX = Y

where

Eqn585

Eqn586

Eqn587

Required transfer function of the system,

Eqn588

Using Cramer's rule, we obtain

Eqn589

where Eqn590

Eqn591

Eqn592

Eqn593

Eqn594

Eqn595

Eqn596

where Eqn597

Eqn598

Eqn599

Eqn600

Therefore, Eqn601

  1. Eqn602
  2. Eqn603

    Eqn604

  3. Eqn605

    Eqn606

Therefore, the transfer function of the given system is

Eqn607

Example 1.17: For the mechanical rotational system shown in Fig. E1.17(a), obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function of the system.

C0E1F026a

Fig. E1.17(a)

Solution: For the given system, the input and output are applied torque Eqn659 and angular displacements are Eqn660 respectively. Hence, the required transfer function are Eqn661.

The system has two nodes and they are masses with moment of inertia Eqn662 and Eqn663. The differential equations governing the system are given by torque balance equations at these nodes.

Let the angular displacement of mass with moment of inertia Eqn664 be Eqn665. The Laplace transform of Eqn666 is Eqn667. The free body diagram of J1 is shown in Fig. E1.17(b). The opposing torques acting on Eqn668 are marked as Eqn669 and Eqn670.

Eqn671

Eqn672

C0E1F026b

Fig. E1.17(b)

Using Newton's second law, we have

Eqn673

Eqn674

Taking Laplace transform, we obtain

Eqn675(1)

The free body diagram of Eqn676 is shown in Fig. E1.17(c). The opposing torque acting on Eqn677 are marked as Eqn678 and Eqn679.

C0E1F026c

Fig. E1.17(c)

According to D' Alembert's principle, we have

Eqn680

Eqn681

Taking Laplace transform, we obtain

Eqn682

Eqn683(2)

The Eqs. (1) and (2) can be written in matrix form as

Eqn684

Applying Cramer's rule, we obtain

Eqn685 Eqn686

Eqn687

Eqn688 Eqn689

and Eqn690

Then, Eqn691

Eqn692

Thus, the overall transfer function of the given mechanical system is

Eqn693

Eqn694

1.8 Introduction to Analogous System

Two equations of similar form are defined as analogous systems. The advantage of analogous system is that, if the response of one system is known, then the other system is also known without actually solving it.

Generally, mechanical systems are converted into analogous electrical system. There is a similarity between the equilibrium equations (integro-differential equations) of electrical systems and mechanical systems. Due to this, an electrical equivalent can be drawn to a mechanical system.

Example of Analogous Systems

A transformer is analogical to a gear. The transformer adjusts its “voltage-to-current” ratio (V/I) based on the load applied on the transformer that is similar to that of a gear mechanism, by which it adjusts the “torque-to-speed” ratio (T/ω) based on the load requirement.

1.8.1 Advantages of Electrical Analogous System

The following are the advantages of electrical analogous system:

  1. Standard symbols are available in electrical systems such as resistance, inductance, capacitance, etc.
  2. Standard and simple laws are available in electrical system that makes it easier for calculation.

    Example: Kirchhoff's laws, Thévenin's theorem, etc.

  3. (iii) It is easy to analyze a system for different parameter values in an electrical system, because R, L and C cannot be varied and their response can be seen.

In an electrical system, the dual networks are analogous systems and both are in electrical form. The analogous parameters in dual network are listed in Table 1.5.

Table 1.5 ∣ Analogous parameters in dual network

tbl5

Types of Analogies

The different types of analogies are discussed as shown in Fig. 1.27.

C01F027

Fig. 1.27 ∣ Types of analogies

1.8.2 Force–Voltage Analogy

Consider a simple translational mechanical system as shown in Fig. 1.28.

C01F028

Fig. 1.28 ∣ Translational mechanical system

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Sum of the applied forces = sum of the opposing forces

Eqn695(1.6)

Consider a series RLC circuit as shown in Fig. 1.29.

C01F029

Fig. 1.29 ∣ Series RLC circuit

Using KVL, the integro-differential equations can be written as

Eqn696(1.7)

Rearranging Eqs. (1.6) and (1.7), we obtain

Eqn697

Eqn698

Since the force of mechanical system is made analogous to the voltage of electrical system, the above two equations are represented as analogous system. This analogy is known as force–voltage (or) FV analogy. The analogous parameters in FV system are given in Table 1.6.

Table 1.6F–V analogous parameters

tbl6

1.8.3 Force–Current Analogy

Consider a simple parallel RLC Circuit as shown in Fig. 1.30.

C01F030

Fig. 1.30 ∣ Parallel RLC circuit

Using KCL, the integro-differential equations can be written as follows:

Eqn699

Eqn700(1.8)

The force equation for translational mechanical system is

Eqn701(1.9)

Rearranging Eqs. (1.8) and (1.9), we obtain

Eqn702

Eqn703

Since the force of mechanical system is made analogous to the current of electrical system, the above two equations are represented as analogous system. This analogy is known as force–current (or) FI analogy. The analogous parameters in FI system are given in Table 1.7.

Table 1.7F–I analogous parameters

tbl7

The analogous variables for translational mechanical system and an electrical system are listed in Table 1.8.

Table 1.8 ∣ Analogous of FV and FI to translational mechanical system

tbl8

Flow chart for problems related to force–voltage and force–current analogy

A flow chart for solving problems related to force–voltage and force–current analogy is shown in Fig. 1.31.

C01F031

Fig. 1.31 ∣ Flow chart for force-voltage and force-current analogy system

Free Body Diagram

If all the opposing forces and applied forces acting on mass are marked separately, then it is named as free body diagram.

Example 1.18: For the mechanical system shown in Fig. E1.18(a), obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.

C0E1F027a

Fig. E1.18(a)

Solution:

Free body diagram of mass M1:

The mass spring damper system and the free body diagram of mass Eqn705 indicating the opposing and applied forces acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.18(b) and (c) respectively.

C0E1F027b        C0E1F027c

Fig. E1.18(b)   Fig. E1.18(c)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Eqn706

Eqn707(1)

Free body diagram of mass Eqn708:

The mass spring damper system and the free body diagram of mass Eqn709 indicating the opposing and applied forces acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.21(d) and (e) respectively.

C0E1F027d   C0E1F027e

Fig. E1.18(d)   Fig. E1.18(e)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Eqn710

Eqn711(2)

Replacing the displacements with velocity in the Eqs. (1) and (2) governing the mechanical translational system, we obtain

Eqn712(3)

Eqn713(4)

(a) FV Electrical Analogy

The FV analogous elements for the mechanical system are given below:

Eqn714   Eqn715   Eqn716   Eqn717

Eqn718   Eqn719   Eqn720

Eqn721

The FV analogous equations for Eqs. (3) and (4) are:

Eqn722(5)

Eqn723(6)

The FV analogous circuit shown in Fig. E1.18(f) is constructed using the above Eqs. (5) and (6). Since the system contains two masses, the electrical circuit is constructed with two loops.

FV Circuit:

C0E1F027f

Fig. E1.18(f)

(b) FI Electrical Analogy

The FI analogous elements for the mechanical system are given below:

Eqn724   Eqn725   Eqn726   Eqn727

Eqn728   Eqn729      Eqn730

Eqn731

The FI analogous equations for Eqs. (3) and (4) are:

Eqn732 (7)

Eqn733(8)

The FI analogous circuit shown in Fig. E1.18(g) is constructed using the above Eqs. (7) and (8). Since the system contains two masses, the electrical circuit is constructed with two nodes.

FI Circuit:

C0E1F027g

Fig. E1.18(g)

Example 1.19: For the mechanical system shown in Fig. E1.19(a), obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.

C0E1F029a

Fig. E1.19(a)

Solution:

Free body diagram of mass M2:

The mass spring damper system and the free body diagram of mass Eqn782 indicating the opposing and applied forces acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.19(b) and (c) respectively.

C0E1F029b   C0E1F029c

Fig. E1.19(b)   Fig. E1.19(c)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we obtain

Eqn783

Eqn784(1)

Free body diagram of mass M1:

The mass spring damper system and the free body diagram of mass Eqn785 indicating the opposing and applied forces acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.19(d) and (e) respectively.

C0E1F029d   C0E1F029e

Fig. E1.19(d)   Fig. E1.19(e)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Eqn786

Eqn787(2)

(a) FV Electrical Analogy

The F–V electrical analogous elements for the mechanical system are given below:

Eqn788   Eqn789   Eqn790   Eqn791

Eqn792   Eqn793   Eqn794   Eqn795

Eqn796          Eqn797

The F–V electrical analogous equations for Eqs. (1) and (2) are:

Eqn798(3)

Eqn799`(4)

The F–V analogous circuit shown in Fig. E1.19(f) is constructed using the above Eqs. (3) and (4). Since the system contains two masses, the electrical circuit is constructed with two loops.

F–V Circuit:

C0E1F029f

Fig. E1.19(f)

(b) F–I Electrical Analogy

The F–I electrical analogous elements for the mechanical system are given below:

Eqn800   Eqn801   Eqn802   Eqn803

Eqn804   Eqn805   Eqn806   Eqn807

Eqn808          Eqn809

The F–I electrical analogous equations for Eqs. (1) and (2) are:

Eqn810(5)

Eqn811(6)

The F–I analogous circuit shown in Fig. E1.19(g) is constructed using the Eqs. (5) and (6). Since the system contains two masses, the electrical circuit is constructed with two nodes.

F–I Circuit:

C0E1F029g

Fig. E1.19(g)

Example 1.20: For the mechanical translational system shown in Fig. E1.20(a), obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) F–V analogous circuit and (iii) F–I analogous circuit.

C0E1F031a

Fig. E1.20(a)

Solution:

Free body diagram of mass M3:

The mass spring damper system and the free body diagram of mass Eqn839 indicating the opposing and applied forces acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.20(b) and (c) respectively.

C0E1F031b

Fig. E1.20(b)

C0E1F031c

Fig. E1.20(c)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Eqn840

Eqn841(1)

Free body diagram of mass M2:

The mass spring damper system and the free body diagram of mass Eqn842 indicating the opposing and applied forces acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.20(d) and (e) respectively.

C0E1F031d   C0E1F031e

Fig. E1.20(d)   Fig. E1.20(e)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Eqn843

Eqn844(2)

Free body diagram of mass M1:

The mass spring damper system and the free body diagram of mass Eqn845 indicating the opposing and applied forces acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.20(f) and (g) respectively.

C0E1F031f

Fig. E1.20(f)

C0E1F031g

ig. E1.20(g)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Eqn846

Eqn847(3)

(a) F–V Electrical Analogy

The F–V analogous elements for the mechanical system are given by

Eqn848   Eqn849   Eqn850   Eqn851

Eqn852   Eqn853   Eqn854

Eqn855   Eqn856   Eqn857

Eqn858      Eqn859

The F–V analogous equations for Eqs. (1) through (3) are given by

Eqn860(4)

Eqn861(5)

Eqn862(6)

The F–V analogous circuit shown in Fig. E1.20(h) is constructed using the above Eqs. (4) through (6). Since the system contains three masses, the electrical circuit is constructed with three loops.

F–V Circuit:

C0E1F031h

Fig. E1.20(h)

(b) F–I Electrical Analogy

The F–I analogous elements for the mechanical system are given below:

Eqn863   Eqn864   Eqn865   Eqn866

Eqn867   Eqn868   Eqn869   Eqn870

Eqn871   Eqn872

Eqn873

The F–I analogous equations for Eqs. (1) through (3) are:

Eqn874(7)

Eqn875(8)

Eqn876(9)

The F–I analogous circuit shown in Fig. E1.20(i) is constructed using the Eqs. (7) through (9). Since the system contains three masses, the electrical circuit is constructed with three nodes.

F–I Circuit:

C0E1F031i

Fig. E1.20(i)

Example 1.21: For the mechanical system shown in Fig. E1.21(a), obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.

Solution:

C0E1F034a

Fig. E1.21(a)

Free body diagram of mass Eqn936:

The mass spring damper system and the free body diagram of mass Eqn937 indicating the opposing and applied forces acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.21(b) and (c) respectively.

C0E1F034b   C0E1F034c

Fig. E1.21(b)   Fig. E1.21(c)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we obtain

Eqn938

Eqn939(1)

Free body diagram of mass Eqn940:

The mass spring damper system and the free body diagram of mass Eqn941 indicating the opposing and applied forces acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.21(d) and (e) respectively.

C0E1F034d   C0E1F034e

Fig. E1.21(d)   Fig. E1.21(e)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we obtain

Eqn942

Eqn943(2)

(a) F–V Electrical Analogy

The F–V electrical analogous elements for the mechanical system are given below:

Eqn944   Eqn945   Eqn946Eqn947

Eqn948   Eqn949   Eqn950

Eqn951

The F–V electrical analogous equations for Eqs. (1) and (2) are:

Eqn952(3)

Eqn953(4)

The F–V analogous circuit shown in Fig. E1.21(f) is constructed using the above Eqs. (3) and (4). Since the system contains two masses, the electrical circuit is constructed with two loops.

F–V Circuit:

C0E1F034f

Fig. E1.21(f)

(b) F–I Electrical Analogy

The F–I electrical analogous elements for the mechanical system are given below:

Eqn954   Eqn955   Eqn956

Eqn957   Eqn958   Eqn959

Eqn960

The F–I electrical analogous equations for Eqs. (1) and (2) are:

Eqn961(5)

Eqn962(6)

The F–I analogous circuit shown in Fig. E1.21(g) is constructed using the above Eqs. (5) and (6). Since the system contains two masses, the electrical circuit is constructed with two nodes.

F–I Circuit:

C0E1F034g

Fig. E1.21(g)

Example 1.22: For the mechanical system shown in Fig. E1.22(a), obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.

C0E1F035a

Fig. E1.22(a)

Solution:

Free body diagram of mass Eqn963:

The mass spring damper system and the free body diagram of mass Eqn964 indicating the opposing and applied forces acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.22(b) and (c) respectively.

C0E1F035b   C0E1F035c

Fig. E1.22(b)   Fig. E1.22(c)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Eqn965

Eqn966(1)

Free body diagram of mass Eqn967:

The mass spring damper system and the free body diagram of mass Eqn968 indicating the opposing and applied forces acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.22(d) and (e) respectively.

C0E1F035d   C0E1F035e

Fig. E1.22(d)   Fig. E1.22(e)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we obtain

Eqn969

Eqn970(2)

Free body diagram of mass Eqn971:

The mass spring damper system and the free body diagram of mass Eqn972 indicating the opposing and applied forces acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.22(f) and (g) respectively.

C0E1F035f   C0E1F035g

Fig. E1.22(f)   Fig. E1.22(g)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Eqn973

Eqn974(3)

(a) F–V Electrical Analogy

The F–V analogous elements for the mechanical system are given below:

Eqn975   Eqn976   Eqn977   Eqn978 Eqn979

Eqn980   Eqn981   Eqn982   Eqn983

Eqn984   Eqn985

Eqn986

The F–V analogous equations for Eqs. (1) through (3) are:

Eqn987(4)

Eqn988(5)

Eqn989(6)

The F–V analogous circuit shown in Fig. E1.22(h) is constructed using the above Eqs. (4) through Eqn. (6). Since the system contains three masses, the electrical circuit is constructed with three loops.

F–V Circuit:

C0E1F035h

Fig. E1.22(h)

(b) F–I Electrical Analogy

The F–I analogous elements for the mechanical system are given below:

Eqn990   Eqn991   Eqn992   Eqn993

Eqn994   Eqn995   Eqn996   Eqn997

Eqn998   Eqn999

Eqn1000

The F–I analogous equations for Eqs. (1) through (3) are:

Eqn1001(7)

Eqn1002(8)

Eqn1003(9)

The F–I analogous circuit shown in Fig. E1.22(i) is constructed using the above Eqs. (7) through (9). Since the system contains three masses, the electrical circuit is constructed with three nodes.

F–I Circuit:

C0E1F035i

Fig. E1.22(i)

1.8.4 Torque–Voltage Analogy

Consider a simple rotational mechanical system as shown in Fig.1.32.

C01F032

Fig. 1.32 ∣ Rotational mechanical system

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Sum of the applied torques = sum of the opposing torques

Eqn1098(1.10)

Consider a series RLC circuit as shown in Fig. 1.33.

C01F033

Fig. 1.33 ∣ Series RLC circuit

Applying KVL, we obtain

Eqn1099(1.11)

Since the torque of the mechanical system is made analogous to the voltage of the electrical system, Eqs. (1.10) and (1.11) are represented as analogous system. This analogy is known as torque–voltage (or) T–V analogy. The analogous parameters in T–V system are given in Table 1.9.

Table 1.9T–V analogous parameters

tbl9

1.8.5 Torque–Current Analogy

Consider a simple rotational mechanical system as shown in Fig. 1.34.

C01F034

Fig. 1.34 ∣ Rotational mechanical system

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Eqn1100(1.12)

Consider parallel RLC Circuit as shown in Fig. 1.35.

C01F035

Fig. 1.35 ∣ Parallel RLC circuit

Applying KCL, we obtain

Eqn1101

Eqn1102(1.13)

Since the torque of the mechanical system is made analogous to the current of the electrical system, Eqs. (1.12) and (1.13) are represented as analogous system. This analogy is known as torque–current (or) T–I analogy. The analogous parameters in T–I system are given in Table 1.10.

Table 1.10TI analogous parameters

tbl10

The analogous variables for rotational mechanical system and electrical system are listed in Table 1.11.

Table 1.11 ∣ Analogous of TV and TI to rotational mechanical system

tbl11

A flow chart for solving problems related to torque–voltage and torque–current analogy is shown in Fig. 1.36.

C01F036

Fig. 1.36 ∣ Flow chart for torque-voltage and torque-current analogy system

Example 1.23: For the mechanical rotational system shown in Fig. E1.23(a), obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) TV analogous circuit and (iii) TI analogous circuit.

C0E1F040a

Fig. E1.23(a)

Solution: The given mechanical rotational system has three nodes, i.e., three moment of inertia of masses. The differential equations governing the mechanical rotational systems are given by torque balance equations at these nodes. Let the angular displacements of Eqn1156, Eqn1157 and Eqn1158 be Eqn1159, Eqn1160 and Eqn1161 respectively. The corresponding angular velocities are ω1(t), ω2(t) and ω3(t), respectively.

Free body diagram for inertia J1:

The rotational mechanical system and the free body diagram of Eqn1164 indicating the opposing and applied torques acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.23(b) and (c) respectively.

C0E1F040b   C0E1F040c

Fig. E1.23(b)   Fig. E1.23(c)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Eqn1165

Eqn1166(1)

Free body diagram for inertia J2:

The rotational mechanical system and the free body diagram of Eqn1167 indicating the opposing and applied torques acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.23(d) and (e) respectively.

C0E1F040d   C0E1F040e

Fig. E1.23(d)   Fig. E1.23(e)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Eqn1168

Eqn1169(2)

Free body diagram for inertia J3:

The rotational mechanical system and the free body diagram of Eqn1170 indicating the opposing and applied torques acting on it are shown in Figs. E1.23(f) and (g) respectively.

C0E1F040f   C0E1F040g

Fig. E1.23(f)   Fig. E1.23(g)

Using D'Alembert's principle, we have

Eqn1171

Eqn1172(3)

Replacing the angular displacements by angular velocity in the differential Eqs. (1) through (3) governing the mechanical rotational system, we obtain

Eqn1173(4)

Eqn1174(5)

Eqn1175(6)

T–V Electrical Analogy

The T–V analogous elements for the mechanical system are given below:

Eqn1176   Eqn1177   Eqn1178    Eqn1179   Eqn1180

   Eqn1181   Eqn1182   Eqn1183   Eqn1184

   Eqn1185   Eqn1186   Eqn1187

The T–V analogous equations of Eqs. (4) through (6) are:

Eqn1188(7)

Eqn1189(8)

Eqn1190(9)

The T–V analogous circuit shown in Fig. E1.23(h) is constructed using the Eqs. (7) through (9). Since the system contains three inertial elements, the electrical circuit is constructed with three loops.

T–V Circuit:

C0E1F040h

Fig. E1.23(h)

T–I Electrical Analogy

The T–I analogous elements for the mechanical system are given below:

Eqn1191   Eqn1192   Eqn1193   Eqn1194   Eqn1195

   Eqn1196   Eqn1197   Eqn1198   Eqn1199

   Eqn1200   Eqn1201   Eqn1202

The T–I analogous equations for Eqs. (4) through (6) are:

Eqn1203(10)

Eqn1204(11)

Eqn1205(12)

The T–I analogous circuit shown in Fig. E1.23(i) is constructed using the Eqs. (10) through (12). Since the system contains three inertial elements, the electrical circuit is constructed with three nodes.

T–I Circuit:

C0E1F040i

Fig. E1.23(i)

Review Questions

  1. What do you mean by a system? Give examples.
  2. What do you mean by a control system? Give examples.
  3. What are the different types of control system?
  4. With the help of block diagram, write a note on open-loop systems.
  5. With the help of block diagram, write a note on closed-loop systems.
  6. Give a practical example for an open-loop system and explain it.
  7. Give a practical example for a closed-loop system and explain it.
  8. With the block diagram, illustrate the control of a car by the driver and identify the components of this closed-loop system.
  9. Distinguish the open-loop and closed-loop control systems.
  10. Explain the concept of principle of homogeneity and superposition.
  11. How are the systems classified based on principle of homogeneity and superposition?
  12. Define linear and non-linear systems with examples.
  13. How are the systems classified based on varying quantity and time?
  14. Define time-variant and time-invariant systems with examples.
  15. Define transfer function of a system.
  16. What are the features and advantages of transfer function?
  17. What are the disadvantages of transfer function?
  18. Determine the transfer function of the open-loop system.
  19. State whether transfer function is applicable to non-linear system.
  20. What are the types of closed-loop system?
  21. Why is negative feedback preferred in control system?
  22. Discuss the concept of negative feedback closed-loop system and derive its transfer function.
  23. Discuss the concept of positive feedback closed-loop system and derive its transfer function.
  24. What are the features or advantages of negative feedback control system?
  25. What is an error detector?
  26. What do you mean by modeling of systems?
  27. Explain with a neat flowchart, how to determine the transfer function of any physical systems.
  28. What are the basic elements used for modeling electrical system?
  29. What are the basic laws that are used for modeling electrical systems?
  30. Explain the relationship between current and voltage across different elements present in the electrical systems.
  31. How are the mechanical systems classified based on the movement of elements?
  32. What are the basic laws used for modeling mechanical systems?
  33. What do you mean by free body diagram of a mechanical system?
  34. What are the basic elements used for modeling translational mechanical system?
  35. Explain the mass element in translational mechanical system.
  36. Explain the damper element in translational mechanical system.
  37. What are the different types of friction in translational mechanical system? Discuss.
  38. Explain the spring element in the translational mechanical system.
  39. Write a short note on simple translational mechanical system.
  40. What are the basic elements used for modeling rotational mechanical system?
  41. Explain the inertia element in rotational mechanical system.
  42. Explain the damper element in rotational mechanical system.
  43. Explain the spring element in rotational mechanical system.
  44. Write a short note on simple rotational mechanical system.
  45. What do you mean by analogous system? Give examples.
  46. Explain the analogous of rotational and translational mechanical system.
  47. Explain the analogous existing within the electrical system.
  48. What are the advantages of electrical analogous system?
  49. What are the different types of analogies existing between the electrical and mechanical system?
  50. Explain the force–voltage analogy.
  51. Explain the force–current analogy.
  52. Tabulate the analogous parameters of the F–V analogy.
  53. Tabulate the analogous parameters of the F–I analogy.
  54. Explain with a neat flowchart, the procedure for determining the F–V and F–I analogous circuits.
  55. Explain the torque–voltage analogy.
  56. Explain the torque–current analogy.
  57. Tabulate the analogous parameters of the T–V analogy.
  58. Tabulate the analogous parameters of the T–I analogy.
  59. Explain with a neat flowchart, the procedure for determining the T–V and T–I analogous circuits.
  60. For the mechanical rotational system shown in Fig. Q1.60, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) T–V analogous circuit and (iii) T–I analogous circuit.
    C0E1F041a

    Fig. Q1.60

  61. For the mechanical rotational system shown in Fig. Q1.61, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) T–V analogous circuit and (iii) T–I analogous circuit.
    C0E1F039a

    Fig. Q1.61

  62. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.62, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) transfer function of the system, (iii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iv) force–current electrical analogous circuit.
    C0E1F028a

    Fig. Q1.62

  63. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.63, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.
    C0E1F038a

    Fig. Q1.63

  64. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.64, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force-current electrical analogous circuit.
    C01Q065

    Fig. Q1.64

  65. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.65, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.
    C01Q066

    Fig. Q1.65

  66. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.66, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.
    C01Q067

    Fig. Q1.66

  67. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.67, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.
    C01Q068

    Fig. Q1.67

  68. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.68, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.
    C0E1F037a

    Fig. Q1.68

  69. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.69, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.
    C0E1F033a

    Fig. Q1.69

  70. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.70, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.
    C01Q071

    Fig. Q1.70

  71. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.71, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.
    C01Q072

    Fig. Q1.71

  72. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.72, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.
    C01Q073

    Fig. Q1.72

  73. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.73, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.
    C01Q074

    Fig. Q1.73

  74. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.74, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) F–V electrical analogous circuit.
    C01Q075

    Fig. Q1.74

  75. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.75, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) F–V electrical analogous circuit and (iii) F–I electrical analogous circuit.
    C01Q076

    Fig. Q1.75

  76. For the mechanical rotational system shown in Fig. Q1.76, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function of the system.
    C01Q077

    Fig. Q1.76

  77. For the mechanical rotational system shown in Fig. Q1.77, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function Eqn1302.
    C01Q078

    Fig. Q1.77

  78. For the mechanical translational system shown in Fig. Q1.78, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function of the system.
    C01Q079

    Fig. Q1.78

  79. For the mechanical translation system shown in Fig. Q1.79, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function of the system.
    C01Q080

    Fig. Q1.79

  80. For the mechanical translational system shown in Fig. Q1.80, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function Eqn1303of the system.
    C01Q081

    Fig. Q1.80

  81. Determine the transfer functions of the electrical networks shown in Fig. Q1.81.
    1. C01Q082i
    2. C01Q082ii
    3. C01Q082iii
    4. C01Q082iv
    5. C01Q082v

      Fig. Q1.81

  82. Write the integro-differential equations for the electrical network given in Fig. Q1.82.
    C01Q083

    Fig. Q1.82

  83. Determine the transfer function for a positive feedback system with a forward gain of 3 and a feedback gain of 0.2.
  84. For the mechanical translational system shown in Fig. Q1.84, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function of the system.
    C0E1F023

    Fig. Q1.84

  85. For the mechanical rotational system shown in Fig. Q1.85, obtain transfer function of the system.
    C0E1F025

    Fig. Q1.85

  86. A negative feedback system is subjected to an input of 5 V. Determine the output voltage for the unity feedback system for the given values of forward gain: (i) c b = 1, (ii) c b = 5, (iii) c b = 50 and (iv) c b = 500
  87. By simplifying the block diagram given in Fig. Q1.87, determine the value of the output Eqn132.
    C0E1F01_6a

    Fig. Q1.87

  88. For the mechanical translational system shown in Fig. Q1.88, obtain (i) differential equations and (ii) transfer function of the system.
    C0E1F015

    Fig. Q1.88

  89. For the mechanical system shown in Fig. Q1.89, obtain (i) differential equations, (ii) force–voltage electrical analogous circuit and (iii) force–current electrical analogous circuit.
    C0E1F036a

    Fig. Q1.89

..................Content has been hidden....................

You can't read the all page of ebook, please click here login for view all page.
Reset
3.141.30.210