Katsunori Wakabayashi
Department of Nanotechnology for Sustainable Energy, Kwansei Gakuin University, Gakuen 2-1, Sanda 669-1337, Hyogo, Japan
Graphene, a single-layer hexagonal lattice of carbon atoms, is a fascinating system for fundamental studies in condensed matter physics, as well as a promising candidate material for future applications in carbon-based nanoelectronics and molecular devices [1–4]. Since the honeycomb crystal structure of graphene consists of two nonequivalent sublattices, graphene has a unique band structure for the itinerant -electrons near the Fermi energy. In particular, the motion of electrons in graphene near the Fermi energy is well described by the massless Dirac equation (Weyl equation). Since electrons in graphene have Dirac electron nature, graphene provides an environment for highly unconventional two-dimensional (2D) electronic properties [5–7] such as the half-integer quantum Hall effect [2, 3], the absence of backward scattering [6, 8, 9], Klein tunneling [10]. Owing to its high electronic mobility [11] and thermal conductivity [12], graphene is recognized as one of the key materials for realizing next-generation electronic devices.
In nanometer-sized graphene-based electronic devices, the effect of edges on the electronic properties of graphene becomes crucial. The presence of edges in graphene has strong implications for the low-energy spectrum of the -electrons [13–15]. There are two basic edge shapes, armchair and zigzag, which determine the properties of graphene ribbons. It has been shown that nanoribbons with zigzag edges (zigzag nanoribbons) possess localized edge states with energies close to the Fermi level [13–17]. In contrast, edge states are absent for ribbons with armchair edges.
The presence of graphene edge states results in a relatively large contribution to the density of states (DOS) near the Fermi energy in a nanoscale graphene system. Thus, these edge states induce the ferrimagnetic spin polarization along the zigzag edge [13, 16]. The properties of such magnetic states has been widely studied theoretically [13, 16, 18–23]. Since the structural or chemical modification of graphene edges affects the electronic states near the Fermi energy [23–27], they can be used to design the functionality of nanocarbon systems.
Several routes have been reported for the synthesis of graphene nanoribbons: a top-down approach using lithographic patterning of graphene samples [28, 29], solution dispersion and sonication [30], longitudinal unzipping of carbon nanotubes [31, 32]. In addition, recent bottom-up synthesis approach provides graphene nanoribbons with the atomically precise edge structures on metal surface [33–35]. Transport measurements were also demonstrated by several groups [28, 36–42].
In this chapter, we briefly review the theoretical aspects of nanoscale edge effects on electronic and magnetic properties of graphene system and discuss the possible application for the nanoscale devices.
Electronic states of graphene near the Fermi energy are governed by -electrons which originate from orbital of carbon atoms. Here we shall briefly review the -band structure of a graphene sheet [43]. Figure 5.1a and b show the lattice structure and the first Brillouin zone (BZ) of graphene, respectively. Graphene has a honeycomb lattice structure, and thus its first BZ is hexagonal. The corners of the first BZ are called or points, which are also referred to as Dirac points because the energy spectrum at these corners can be described by the massless Dirac equation (Weyl equation). A single-orbital nearest-neighbor tight-binding model for the -electron network gives energy dispersion of graphene in momentum space as , namely,
with 1. is the transfer integral between nearest-neighbor carbon sites, which has been estimated to be about 2.75 eV in a graphene system [5]. Because one carbon site has one -electron on average, only the band is completely occupied. Thus, and correspond to the conduction and valence bands, respectively. Figure 5.1c depicts the energy band structures of graphene with the corresponding DOS. Thus, the Fermi energy is at , and and become Fermi points. Figure 5.1d is the 3D plot of energy band structure in 1st BZ.
The presence of a graphene edge has a strong impact on the electronic states of Dirac electrons. There are two types of graphene edge: armchair and zigzag edges. These two edges have a 30 difference in their orientation within the graphene sheet. A large difference in the -electronic structures is induced by the two types of graphene edges [13]. In particular, a zigzag edge exhibits localized states, whereas an armchair edge does not exhibit such localized states. The appearance of graphene edge states is a source of the peculiar magnetic and transport properties of nanoscale graphene, as will be discussed in the following section.
The graphene nanoribbon model is useful for analyzing the electronic states of nanographene. Because of the periodicity along the longitudinal direction of nanoribbons, we can define the crystal momentum (wave number ) so as to apply the ordinal approach of solid state physics to these systems. The lattice structures of graphene nanoribbons are shown in Figure 5.2a and b. Figure 5.2a shows a graphene nanoribbon with armchair edges (armchair nanoribbon). Figure 5.2b shows a graphene nanoribbon with zigzag edges (zigzag nanoribbon).
We define the width of a graphene ribbon as , where is the number of dimer (two carbon sites) lines for an armchair nanoribbon and the number of zigzag lines for an zigzag nanoribbon. Here all dangling bonds at graphene edges are terminated by hydrogen atoms.
Note that the same number for both zigzag and armchair ribbons does not give the same ribbon width when the ribbons are measured by the same unit of length. Therefore, when we compare the physical quantities of zigzag and armchair ribbons with the same width , we will use the following definition
where = (0.246 nm) is the lattice constant of graphene.
Figure 5.2c shows the DOS and energy band structures of armchair ribbons with width ( nm). The top of the valence band and the bottom of the conduction band are located at . It is known that armchair nanoribbons become metallic when , where . For semiconducting ribbons, the direct band gap decreases with increasing ribbon width and approaches zero in the limit of very large . For narrow undoped metallic armchair nanoribbons, an energy gap can be formed by Peierls instabilities at low temperatures [22, 44–46].
For zigzag ribbons, however, a remarkable feature arises in the band structure, as shown in Figure 5.2d. The top of the valence band and the bottom of the conduction band are always degenerate at , and the degeneracy of the center bands at does not originate from the intrinsic band structure of the graphene sheet. These two special center bands flatten with increasing ribbon width. A pair of partial flat bands appears within the region , and makes the sharp peak in the DOS at the Fermi energy especially when the ribbon width is nanometer scale. The electronic states in the partial flat bands of the zigzag ribbons can be understood as localized states near the zigzag edge (edge states) as shown in the inset of Figure 5.2d [13–15, 47–49].
The edge states are reasonably robust even if the graphene edge does not have a clear zigzag edge. Actually, a general edge structure that is not parallel to the armchair edge can have a zero-energy edge state, which was shown by analogy to the condition of the zero-energy Andreev bound state in an unconventional superconductor [50]. In addition, the analytical form of full energy spectrum and corresponding wave functions for the nearest-neighbor tight-binding model can be found in [51]. Even for an armchair edge, a localized state and a completely flat band can be obtained in the case of a strong imbalance of the on-site potential energy between two sublattice sites [25].
The presence of a sharp peak in the DOS near the Fermi energy should induce lattice distortion via the electron–phonon interaction and/or magnetic polarization via the electron–electron interaction. Because of the non-bonding character of the edge states, lattice distortion in the vicinity of zigzag edges is unlikely with the expected strength of the electron–phonon coupling [44]. The absence of lattice distortion was also confirmed based on the density functional theory (DFT) [22, 46].
Figure 5.3a shows a schematic picture of the spin structure in real space for , which was evaluated by the mean field approximation of Hubbard model [13]. Here is the strength of onsite Coulomb interaction between electrons. Although the vanishing total spin for the ground state is consistent with the exact statement of the half-filled Hubbard model [52], it can be seen that the magnetic moments align along a zigzag edge with a ferrimagnetic correlation. Figure 5.3b shows the energy band structure and corresponding DOS for with . Since a finite opens the band gap at accompanying with the spin polarization, the peak in the DOS at splits into two peaks. Recent experiment has reported the peak splitting of edge states for chiral graphene nanoribbons at low temperatures using scanning tunneling spectroscopy, which might be attributed to the occurrence of edge spin polarization [53, 54].
Edge spin magnetism along the zigzag edge is interesting from the viewpoint of the magnetic properties of nanographenes. In further, this magnetic states are very sensitive to the carrier doping [55]. Figure 5.4 shows the spin–spin correlation function for a zigzag graphene nanoribbon with a finite length, which is calculated by using the configuration interacation (CI) method. Here is the number of holes doped in the nanoribbon. Figure 5.4a is the spin–spin correlation function along a zigzag edge, which indicates the spin–spin correlation between a spin located 0th site of the upper (bottom) edge, that is, central site of a edge, and a spin located at th site. Since spins have ferrimagnetic correlations along a zigzag edge, they have the positive values. In zigzag nanoribbons, spin–spin correlation function does not have exponential decay, but power-low decay. This means that edge magnetism along a zigzag edge is rather robust and even after hole doping. On the other, Figure 5.4b is the spin–spin correlation function between upper and bottom edges. Negative values indicate that edge spins are antiferromagnetically coupled between upper and bottom edges. Interestingly, this antiferromagnetic correlation is rapidly decreased by the hole doping. In fact, the spin excitation energy becomes almost zero by hole doping, that is, magnetic ground state are expected.
The magnetic and transport states of zigzag nanoribbons can be chemically modified by replacing all the edge carbon atoms by boron atoms. As shown in Figure 5.5a, the linear energy bands appear near the Fermi energy resulting in the appearance of the mobile electrons, that is, metallic behavior. However, as each boron atom has one less electron compared to the carbon atom, the system becomes hole doped and the ground state shows ferromagnetic behavior with parallel alignment of spins along the same edge as well as within opposite edges, as can be seen in Figure 5.5b. There have been several other interesting reports about the possible ways to achieve the half-metallic or ferromagnetic behavior in graphene systems.
The application of a transverse electric field to a zigzag nanoribbon can lift the spin degeneracy and induce a half-metallic state [56]. Half-metallic materials are crucial for the application of spintronics devices because they can be used as the source of spin-polarized current or as a spin-filtering device. A schematic figure of the DOS for half-metallic materials is drawn in Figure 5.6a. In half-metallic materials, the spin degeneracy near the Fermi energy is lifted, and one of the two spin states becomes absent. Thus, only one spin component contributes to the electronic conduction as a spin-polarized current.
The conceptual setup for an electric-field-induced half-metallic device is shown in Figure 5.6b. The electric voltage is applied along the transverse direction of zigzag nanoribbons; thus, the electric field is given by . Figure 5.6c shows the energy band structure and corresponding DOS in the presence of an electric field, where the spin degeneracy is lifted. Here, the energy gap for the up-spin starts closing with increasing electric field, while that for the down-spin remains open. In this situation, only up-spins become metallic in the vicinity of under the application of transverse electric field, that is, the system becomes half-metallic. The critical electric field strength beyond which the system behaves as half-mettalic, decreases with increase in width of the zigzag nanoribbon [56, 57].
In this chapter, we have briefly reviewed nanoscale effects on the electronic properties of graphene. The presence of a graphene edge crucially affects the electronic states of nanoscale graphene (nanographene). Two typical types of graphene edges, namely, we al armchair and zigzag edges exhibit completely different electronic properties. Although the presence of an armchair edge tends to preserve the properties of Dirac fermions of graphene, the presence of a zigzag edge is detrimental to Dirac fermions and induces localized edge states at the Fermi energy. Since the presence of edge states produces a non-negligible large peak in the DOS at the Fermi energy of nanographene, the magnetic properties of nanographene are considerably different from those of graphene. We have also seen that the strong Fermi instability of the edge states induces the ferrimagnetic spin polarization even along the zigzag edge. The careful control and theoretical designing of such magnetic states will serve to realize carbon-based spintronic devices.
Since the field of graphene nanotechnology is still growing, we could not include all the important topics in this single chapter. It is also known that the lattice defect or vacancy can also be source of magnetism [58]. The spin–orbit interactions can also be tuned by the hydrogenation to induce the spin-Hall effect [59]. In further, the presence of edge states in graphene nanoribbons becomes a source of a perfectly conducting channel, that is, absence of Anderson localization [50, 60–62]. This peculiar transport properties of nanoribbons will serve to design the ultra-low power consumption electronic devices composed of carbon nanomaterials [41].
The recent rapid progress in graphene research has revealed the unconventional electronic properties of massless Dirac fermion systems. However, we have seen that graphene can exhibit a strong nanoscale edge effect. Such an effect might be the origin of the diverse of physical and chemical properties of aromatic molecules. Further exploration of the physics of nanoscale graphene will be demanded for the realization of carbon-based devices.
18.191.157.186