The reflectance Cuprite data scene in Figure 1.12 was used for experiments by PBS with BP/ID-BD to investigate an application in endmember extraction where a threshold value ε for ID-BD was empirically set to 0.01 to remove correlated bands. After BP/ID-BD, only 95 spectral bands were retained. Table 23.1 tabulates the first 50 spectral bands after BP/ID-BD using 7 BP criteria: variance, SNR, skewness, kurtosis, entropy, ID, and negentropy. Interestingly, the interband correlation for this scene is clearly characterized by second-order statistics rather than by high-order statistics (HOS), where only a few bands are removed by ID-BD using three specific HOS criteria: kurtosis, ID, and negentropy.
50 BP/BD bands | Bands removed by ID-BD | |
Variance | 87/78/98/189/75/94/96/95/67/123/124/122/ 120/125/117/114/129/112/54/131/46/40/ 187/108/133/102/106/25/20/188/18/141/ 143/142/145/140/146/144/139/147/16/ 138/149/137/150/151/152/15/153/154 |
85/88/86/89/84/91/80/90/92/83/82/79/93/81/ 99/97/77/76/100/74/73/72/101/71/70/69/ 68/121/66/65/119/64/118/63/127/126/128/ 62/116/115/61/113/59/60/58/57/55/56/ 130/111/53/52/51/50/110/49/48/47/41/44/ 43/45/42/39/38/109/37/36/132/35/34/33/ 135/32/134/107/31/29/30/28/27/26/103/ 104/24/23/105/22/21/19/17 |
SNR | 68/26/89/20/18/53/76/39/16/15/14/114/120/ 112/117/124/122/12/123/125/11/129/9/97/ 131/108/96/8/94/95/7/133/6/5/106/149/ 142/150/146/147/151/4/152/153/143/141/ 145/3/144/155 |
71/67/69/70/72/66/73/65/74/25/27/23/24/28/ 22/64/21/75/63/87/88/85/86/91/19/83/84/ 42/29/90/52/17/49/43/54/51/38/50/62/45/ 35/57/32/55/41/31/37/47/33/48/34/44/ 113/36/56/82/118/13/93/119/46/30/115/ 126/121/92/111/127/110/128/116/40/109/ 61/10/130/98/77/99/100/81/132/60/58/59/ 101/80/134/107/135/79/78/104/148/103 |
Skewness | 2/1/3/4/5/6/7/8/9/11/12/14/184/15/185/183/ 181/16/179/178/180/182/177/170/171/18/ 159/169/20/158/176/157/186/172/156/25/ 155/175/173/49/174/160/154/168/43/153/ 167/166/152/64 |
10/13/17/19/21/22/23/24/26/30/27/31/28/32/ 29/33/50/51/48/52/47/34/53/46/54/45/35/ 44/55/56/42/36/57/37/41/38/39/40/58/59/ 60/61/62/63 |
Kurtosis | 2/3/1/4/5/6/7/8/9/185/181/183/184/179/178/ 180/170/182/177/11/169/171/12/176/172/ 14/159/158/168/157/156/175/155/15/154/ 160/167/173/153/174/166/16/152/186/ 151/165/150/164/18/161 |
10/13/17 |
Entropy | 90/101/189/82/96/37/95/111/75/112/124/ 187/117/126/123/122/46/107/188/174/25/ 175/173/67/103/102/131/172/176/20/52/ 177/105/171/18/168/134/169/178/179/ 137/170/162/159/167/161/163/160/158/ 136 |
92/88/99/89/91/93/86/87/100/85/84/98/83/ 97/81/94/80/79/78/77/38/76/40/39/36/41/ 35/113/110/109/42/34/114/120/115/121/ 116/118/74/33/119/43/73/32/44/29/108/ 72/45/31/28/125/128/127/30/71/27/129/ 70/26/47/69/130/68/24/23/48/66/22/104/ 65/49/60/63/21/64/61/59/62/50/106/58/ 51/54/53/56/55/132/57/19/133/135/17 |
ID | 1/2/3/5/153/154/152/4/151/150/9/6/8/185/ 144/146/7/11/139/140/155/145/149/184/ 156/12/182/183/147/142/180/143/165/ 138/181/164/186/141/160/157/167/14/ 170/166/163/158/169/179/15/161 |
10/148/13 |
Negentropy | 2/3/1/4/5/6/7/8/9/185/181/184/183/179/178/ 180/11/170/182/177/171/169/12/176/14/ 159/172/158/157/15/168/156/175/155/ 154/16/160/173/167/153/174/186/166/ 152/151/165/18/150/164/161 |
10/13/17/19 |
Figure 23.1(a)–(g) shows the results of IN-FINDR-extracted mineral signatures among A, B, C, K, and M using BP/ID-BD-generated spectral bands given in Table 23.1, where the figures on the right and the left were obtained by PBS with/without using ID-BD, respectively. Also in Figure 23.1, a vertical line in each figure shows a cutoff threshold for determined and set by DDA = 26 that was the largest value obtained by Huffman coding among five mineral signatures.
Comparing Figure 23.1 with Figure 21.8, the results produced by BP/ID-BD-generated bands are different from the results the generated by using BP without BD. However, the improvement of endmember extraction was not really significant.
3.145.115.195