Keeping Organization Culture Alive and Well

Given the critical contributions that organization culture makes to organizational success, managers must keep organization culture alive and well in their organizations. Important steps in this process include establishing a vision of organization culture, building and maintaining organization culture through artifacts, integrating new employees within organization culture, and maintaining the health of organization culture. Each of these steps is discussed in the following sections.

Establishing a Vision of Organization Culture

Managing organization culture usually begins by establishing a vision of what the culture of an organization should be. In essence, this vision becomes a target at which management aims. Without such a target, management will not have a benchmark for modifying and improving the organization culture over time.

Management should first reflect on what type of culture would be appropriate, given the organization’s specific circumstances. Because of the complexity of circumstances in most modern organizations, most such cultures tend to be multidimensional. Managers should strive to establish the dimensions in their own culture that will best contribute to accomplishing the organizational mission. Dimensions commonly observed in modern organization cultures include focusing on quality, ethics, innovation, spirituality, diversity, and customers. Bear in mind that not all organization cultures contain all of these dimensions; instead, managers tend to decide which dimension(s) will best help enhance organizational success and then take steps to include that dimension as a major feature of organization culture. Each of these dimensions is discussed here.

Quality Dimension

The quality dimension of organization culture is an element of organization culture that focuses on making sure a product, in the opinion of the customer, does what it is supposed to do. Organizations with such a culture tend to focus on communicating to customers their focus on quality and explaining how quality processes operate within the organization. Management generally hopes to benefit from such cultural emphasis by earning customer loyalty and repeat purchases because of customer satisfaction with products or services. An example of an organization with a strong quality dimension in its organization culture is KB Home, a home builder that operates mainly in 18 states in the southwest and southeast parts of the United States. KB Home uses its website to communicate to customers its focus on quality. At KB Home, the quality of the houses it produces is especially important: The company has a “100% Satisfied Pledge,” which offers home buyers 10 quality construction checkpoints.

Ethics Dimension

The ethics dimension of organization culture is a facet of organization culture that focuses on making sure that an organization emphasizes not only what is good for the organization but also what is good for other human beings. Until recently, an ethics dimension has been unwisely ignored.27

Ethisphere magazine named Starbucks one of its World’s Most Ethical Companies. A Starbucks manager claims treating employees right provides an environment where they treat others right, and ethical values include doing good both in the sense of providing communities with a gathering place and performing acts of community service.

ARIANE KADOCH/KRT/Newscom

Ethics training is arguably the most commonly used method for developing the ethics dimension of organization culture.28 This training normally focuses on developing a common understanding throughout the organization of the role ethics plays in organizational operations. However, ethics training does not guarantee that employees will choose the ethical behavior in every situation. Such training will, however, start a useful dialogue about correct and incorrect behavior in various organizational situations. In essence, ethics training is designed to give employees a usable framework for ethical reasoning that will help them make ethical choices in various organizational situations after training ends.

What can managers do to increase the probability that ethics training influences organization members to act ethically over time? First, after ethics training concludes, management can provide employees with a means for making ethical queries anonymously. Some organizations provide a hotline that employees can call to get advice about ethical dilemmas. Management can also try to make sure that organization members act ethically after ethics training concludes by establishing methods for reviewing the topics covered in ethics training. For example, a company can use its intranet, publish brochures, and even use screen savers to continually remind employees about the issues covered in ethics training. Another tactic management can use is to promote employees who behave ethically. Rewarding past ethical behavior is a powerful way to increase the probability that organization members will act ethically in the future.

Innovation Dimension

The innovation dimension of organization culture is an aspect of organization culture that encourages the application of new ideas to improve organizational processes, products, or services. Innovation is a major source of organizational change and improvement. However, once an innovation dimension is established, management cannot assume it will continue to exist as time passes. An innovation dimension of organization culture can become significantly weakened or even disappear if it is not properly nurtured.

The 3M Company is known for producing thousands of imaginative products, which emerge from a culture widely regarded as innovative and creative. By its nature, invention is commonly a disorderly and inefficient process. Historically, 3M has allowed researchers to spend years testing products with little regard for the efficiency of the process.

Consider the invention of the Post-it note. The 3M inventor, Art Fry, fiddled with the idea for several years before the product went into full production in 1980. But then, management began making changes to the culture to emphasize efficiency. What the company didn’t realize was that, in emphasizing efficiency, innovation was being squeezed out. Once 3M management realized that this innovation focus was being damaged, it took steps to somewhat deemphasize the focus on efficiency and to spend more on research and development in an effort to reinvigorate its culture of innovation, long considered to be the lifeblood of the company.29

Spirituality Dimension

The spirituality dimension of organization culture is an aspect of organization culture that encourages organization members to integrate spiritual life and work life. A spiritual awakening seems to be occurring in the American workplace, and many managers are encouraging the development of this trend.30 Managers seem to be doing so because of their belief that a spiritually humanistic work environment is beneficial for both employees and the organization. According to the logic of such managers, a spiritually reflective work environment will be personally satisfying to organization members, who will thereby become more productive and creative. On the other hand, such managers tend to believe that a workplace without a spiritual dimension will normally result in unsatisfied organization members, who will become frustrated and thereby consistently absent from the workplace.31 Organization cultures that have a spiritual dimension typically do not focus on one specific type of spiritual belief or religion but instead emphasize the acceptance of whatever spiritual focus an organization member might possess. In emphasizing a spiritual focus, organizations create opportunities for spiritually based activities such as offering prayer, performing meditation, reading sacred texts, listening to worship music, and having objects in the workplace as reminders of one’s spiritual beliefs.

Diversity Dimension

The diversity dimension of organization culture is a component of organization culture that encourages the existence of basic human differences among organization members. Such differences can be in ethnicity, religion, physical ability, and/or sexual orientation. The diversity dimension is a mainstay of modern organization culture primarily because managers are anxious to reap diversity-related advantages such as an increased number of perspectives on how to solve problems and how to better relate to diverse customers.

Toyota’s American division recently concluded that its corporate culture lacks diversity.32 Organization members as a group were thought to be too homogeneous, thereby depriving management of the benefits of a diverse workforce. To solve this problem, Toyota is trying to make the population of organization members more diverse by hiring people from other industries and companies. These hirings, however, are being done carefully. Management does not want these new employees ruining its present and otherwise healthy corporate culture.

Customer Dimension

The customer dimension of organization culture is a facet of organization culture that focuses on catering to the needs of those individuals who buy the goods or services the organization produces. One recent survey indicates that 80 percent of executives believe they are doing an excellent job of serving customers, whereas only 8 percent of their customers agree.33 Perhaps because of such survey results along with the realization of the calamity that such results could cause in organizations, many managers are strengthening their organization culture’s focus on customers.

Some organizations, however, are well known for their enduring commitment to customer satisfaction, have achieved much success because of it, and are expected to continue benefiting from it in the future. For example, many believe that Apple’s success over the years is primarily due to its enduring commitment to know what customers want even before customers know it themselves. As another example, General Electric CEO Jeffrey Immelt has initiated “dreaming sessions” to brainstorm with key customers and develop a forward-looking view of customer needs.

Building and Maintaining Organization Culture Through Artifacts

A cultural artifact is a dimension of an organization that helps to describe and reinforce the culture—or the beliefs, values, and norms—in which an artifact exists. As organization culture changes over time, cultural artifacts can also change because what the artifacts represent, how they appear, how they are used, and why they are used are no longer pertinent in the new culture. Several cultural artifacts commonly used by modern managers are discussed here.34

Values

At the heart of any organization’s culture, by definition, are its values. From a societal viewpoint, a value is a person’s or social group’s belief in which they have an emotional investment. In society, values can be “for” something, such as excellent health care for all of society, or “against” something, such as violence among society members. In organizations as well, values can be for things, such as hiring talented workers, rewarding excellent performance, and developing leadership skills, or against things, such as polluting the environment, discriminating in hiring practices, and maintaining the status quo.

Organizational values are reflected in organizational characteristics, including strategy, structure, and processes. Values are also reflected in the way leaders lead as well as in organizational rules, reward systems, policies, and procedures. More and more, modern managers are crafting values statements to clearly communicate cultural values held throughout the organization. A values statement is a formally drafted document that summarizes the primary values within the culture of a specific organization. A values statement gives managers the opportunity to effectively and efficiently communicate the values that drive the organization and thereby help increase the probability that appropriate values will influence organization member behavior. Figure 16.4 contains a statement of values for Microsoft.

Social psychologist Michael O’Malley studies organization culture and, in his spare time, practices beekeeping. Indulging in his hobby has led O’Malley to study the habits of bees and, in his book The Wisdom of Bees: What the Hive Can Teach Business about Leadership, to apply those habits to management practices in building organizational values. For example, O’Malley says that older bees in the hive “mentor” younger bees. Culture is also important to the hive’s overall productivity and well-being, and when colonies from two hives occasionally merge, an “enculturation” process goes on to ensure the success of the merger.35

Figure 16.4 Statement of Values for Microsoft36

Organizational Myths

An organizational myth is a popular belief or story that has become associated with a person or institution and is considered to illustrate an organization culture ideal. Myths are used to explain organizational beginnings or other events that are of great significance to the organization. Myths stimulate organization members to do a good job and provide the logic for actions taken. The events reported in myths never actually happened, but they nevertheless serve as an inspirational foundation for behavior. Organizational myths are commonly perpetuated in organizations to enhance organization member pride in belonging and overall commitment to the organization.

One of the most famous myths in business history centers on Lee Iacocca and how he “saved” Chrysler Corporation from bankruptcy.37 Iacocca took over as chairman of Chrysler Corporation in 1979. At that time, Chrysler was in serious crisis. The company was losing money, had acquired unprofitable companies, and was producing low-quality products that necessitated huge, expensive product recalls. Iacocca took bold, nontraditional actions to save the company: He negotiated government backing of the company, took charismatic personal ads to the marketplace asking for customer support, and negotiated significant concessions with the United Auto Workers Union to dodge bankruptcy. Word began to quickly spread that Iacocca had single-handedly saved the company, which of course was not true. Many people were involved in saving Chrysler. However, the myth of Iacocca saving the company single-handedly helped create the Chrysler cultural value of trust and support for Chrysler leadership.

Organizational Sagas

An organizational saga is a narrative describing the adventures of a heroic individual or family significantly linked to an organization’s past or present. In general, the purpose of a saga is to identify and perpetuate the organization’s shared values. Organizational sagas usually reveal important historical facts such as early pioneers and products, past triumphs and failures, and the leaders who founded or transformed the company.

Mary Kay Ash was the founder of Mary Kay Cosmetics and one of the most successful entrepreneurs in the history of the United States. Information on the website of the company she founded describes a saga related to Mary Kay Cosmetics’s company history. This information serves as an inspiration to all organization members because it lets them know that significant success is obtainable by all within the company through hard work, dedication, and self-confidence.

Mary Kay Cosmetics builds its company culture through inspirational stories, including that of founder Mary Kay Ash; organizational ceremonies; and rewards, including autos for top-selling representatives.

Barry Lewis/Alamy

Managers at all levels can become involved in organizational storytelling, the act of passing along organizational myths and sagas to other organization members. From the example of Mary Kay Ash, it is obvious that modern managers can tell stories not only via word of mouth but also via the Internet.

Organizational Language

The language used in organizations often indicates the organization’s shared values. Some companies reveal how they view the competition by repeatedly using phrases such as “Let’s be #1 in the marketplace” or how they feel about technology by repeatedly using phrases such as “Win through technology.” Still other organizations repeatedly use the phrase “The customer is king” to emphasize how they feel about customer satisfaction. The language used at Walt Disney Companies reflects organizational values that are particularly noteworthy. At Walt Disney, rather than being called an employee, everyone is called a “member of the cast.” This terminology emphasizes that rather than simply working, organization members should think of themselves as always being on stage and always needing to give customers the best performance possible. Many companies use slogans internally and externally through advertising to convey important organizational values. Figure 16.5 presents several well-known slogans and the companies that use them to convey important organizational values.

Figure 16.5 Well-known companies, their slogans, and the values these slogans reflect

Organizational Symbols

An organizational symbol is an object that has meaning beyond its intrinsic content. Symbols provide a road map indicating what is important in a particular organization. Some companies use impressive buildings to convey company strength. Other companies use logos, flags, and coats of arms to convey the importance they place on certain ideas or events. As examples, Prudential Life Insurance Company uses the Rock of Gibraltar to symbolize the company’s dependability, strength, and unwavering commitment to its customers, and McDonald’s uses the clown Ronald McDonald to symbolize the child-friendliness and fun available at McDonald’s restaurants.

Organizational Ceremonies

An organizational ceremony is a formal activity conducted on important organizational occasions. Such occasions could include openings of new stores, anniversary dates of when employees were hired, and employee promotions. Perhaps one of the most well-known organizational ceremonies is the ceremony celebrating successful sales campaigns at Mary Kay Cosmetics. At the company’s sales celebrations, everything—not just the decorations but also the sales prizes, including the automobiles awarded—has a significance.

Organizational Rewards

Rewards modify behavior in some way in most organizations.39 Some rewards come from within the organization and can include compensation, satisfying work, and verbal recognition. Rewards can also come from outside the organization and can include comments from customers, competitors, and suppliers. Management should continually identify and reward those individuals who uphold the values of the organization. Rewarding people for engaging in behavior that reflects the important values of the organization culture is critical in increasing the probability of organizational success.

MyManagementLab : Try It, Organizational Culture

If your instructor has assigned this activity, go to mymanagementlab.com to try a simulation exercise about two textbook publishers.

Integrating New Employees into the Organization Culture

The previous section discussed how to keep organization culture alive and well through the use of cultural artifacts. This section focuses on how to keep organization culture alive and well by appropriately integrating newly hired organization members into the existing organization culture.

Organizational socialization is the process by which management can appropriately integrate new employees into the organization’s culture.40 As the U.S. economy improves, it is likely that employers will need to integrate more new employees. During periods of uncertainty and layoffs, employees who still have jobs tend to “stay put” even if they are dissatisfied with their positions. However, as the economy improves, those same employees will begin to leave their jobs, thus requiring employers to recruit new employees.41 The illustration in Figure 16.6 presents the recommended steps for a socialization process and how the steps relate to one another. The following material discusses the process as a whole as well as each step in more detail.

Figure 16.6 Possible steps of a socialization process

As shown in Figure 16.6, the organizational socialization process can begin by carefully planning the organization’s recruitment process. As part of this planning, management should determine what types of individual characteristics would best fit into the organization culture. Such characteristics might include an individual’s determination to be successful in the job, commitment to personal ethics, and levels of self-confidence and competitiveness. After such best-fit characteristics have been determined, management should use the recruitment process to identify the individuals possessing those characteristics. Naturally, after management has made this identification, purposeful steps should be taken to hire those individuals.

Once individuals possessing the best-fit characteristics are hired, management should continue the socialization process (step 2) by carefully crafting meaningful experiences for them during the first four to six weeks of the new recruits’ presence within the organization. In this situation, experiences are meaningful if they expose the new hires to the important organizational culture values and emphasize the importance of the new individuals’ commitment to those values. Such values might include the importance of tackling challenging work, the openness to training for handling new situations, and the importance of functioning as a team member. Such initial experiences can also involve new recruits observing and practicing new jobs with input from established organization members.

Once the individuals with the appropriate personal characteristics have been hired and have taken part in meaningful activities during the first four to six weeks of their employment, management should continue with their socialization by exposing them to appropriate role models (step 3). Management should focus on pairing new recruits with role models who possess the characteristics that would be valuable for the new recruits to develop themselves. The role models should exemplify cultural values such as being productive, highly motivated, and loyal to the organization and having significant trust in management.42

As the next step in the organizational socialization process, management should help new recruits understand various facets of the organization’s informal structure and how it complements the formal structure. Helping new recruits become members of the informal groups that uphold important organizational values should be especially important to management. Likewise, ignoring the informal focus in the organizational socialization process could result in new recruits unknowingly aligning themselves with the less productive facets of the organization’s informal structure and thereby limit the new recruits’ contributions to organizational success.

In the final step of the organizational socialization process, management must evaluate the cultural fit of the new recruits. New recruits are generally considered new for about one year. During new recruits’ first year in the organization, management must keep in mind that they will make mistakes and struggle to appropriately adapt to the organization culture. This struggle to fit in with the organizational culture can be frustrating for new recruits and lead to premature turnover if not handled sensitively by management. New recruits must be able to practice new tasks, at times employing trial and error, without fear of punishment or failure.

With more than 2,500 attorneys in its offices on four continents, Jones Day is one of the world’s largest law firms. Like most large firms, it has a set of qualities it looks for when recruiting new lawyers. For example, candidates must not exhibit a sense of entitlement or appear too focused on personal success. Also, because of its collaborative culture, the firm rules out candidates who seem likely to compete with their colleagues or are too interested in their peers’ performance. Jones Day also has what is called a “closed” compensation system, and even its partners are not privy to information about the salaries of their peers. Although this kind of secrecy may be highly unusual in other businesses, it seems to be accepted within the firm’s culture. What’s more, it doesn’t appear to adversely affect the firm’s success: Unlike many of its competitors, Jones Day did not lay off lawyers during the recent global recession.43

Management must also remember that not all recruits are suitable for the organization culture and that some recruits may need to be weeded out to make room for other new recruits who may be a better fit. This weeding out can take place by moving poor performers either out of the organization or to jobs with less critical roles. As this weeding-out process occurs, management should reflect on any possible mistakes made during the organizational socialization process of the recruits and come up with ideas on how to improve the process so that such mistakes will not be made in the future.

Maintaining the Health of Organization Culture

Arguably, the most important step that management can take to maximize the success of an organization is to create a healthy culture within that organization. A healthy organization culture is an organization culture that facilitates the achievement of the organization’s mission and objectives. An unhealthy organization culture is an organization culture that does not facilitate the achievement of the organization’s mission and objectives.

Figure 16.7 Eight characteristics of a healthy organization culture44

Managers must continually analyze the symptoms or signs related to the health of the organization and take action to build and maintain a healthy organization culture. A healthy organization culture is usually people oriented and includes the characteristics listed in Figure 16.7. A manager should keep the characteristics of a healthy organization climate in mind and focus on maintaining and building organization culture health whenever possible. For example, if managers believe that organization culture is healthy, they should take steps to improve this health wherever possible. Even though an organization culture might be considered healthy, increasing the cultural focus on risk taking or on excellence in job performance might make the culture even healthier. On the other hand, a manager might believe that his or her organization culture is unhealthy. In such a case, the manager must determine what factors are making the organization culture unhealthy, take steps to eliminate those factors, and introduce ingredients into the culture that will make it healthy.

That was the strategy implemented by Jonathan Ciano when he became CEO of Uchumi Supermarkets in Kenya, Africa. Soon after joining the company, Ciano saw obvious signs that organization culture was unhealthy. Staff theft and unregulated procurement systems led to record debt and uncertainty regarding the company’s sustainability. To change the unhealthy culture into a healthy one, the new CEO confronted the issues of theft and uncontrolled procurement and also initiated a culture in which employees are able to think for themselves on behalf of the company. As a result, Uchumi employees are now making independent judgments and decisions.45

If Ciano’s steps to make organization culture healthier are successful, he will see signs such as organization members fixing mistakes rather than rationalizing them, and new ideas and information will start to flow freely within the company. On the other hand, if the organization culture does not become healthier, the CEO will see signs such as employees blaming others when mistakes occur.

..................Content has been hidden....................

You can't read the all page of ebook, please click here login for view all page.
Reset
18.188.98.148